Mental Pathways to Pain Relief: A Review of Psychological Interventions for Chronic Pain
Evan Bose
Published on: 2024-08-16
Abstract
This review synthesizes findings from approximately 20 studies exploring psychological interventions for chronic pain management. It examines the relationship between chronic pain and various therapeutic approaches, focusing on key psychological factors such as pain perception, emotional regulation, and coping strategies. The biopsychosocial model serves as the theoretical framework, emphasizing the significance of psychological interventions like cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT), mindfulness-based therapy, and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT). The review highlights the positive impact of these therapies on neurobiological mechanisms associated with pain, including alterations in brain regions responsible for pain perception and emotional processing. Moreover, it discusses the role of psychology in addressing maladaptive cognitive and behavioural responses to pain, fostering self-management, and improving overall well-being. Consistent findings across studies demonstrate that multidisciplinary approaches integrating psychological therapies with physical rehabilitation effectively reduce pain intensity and disability. The review underlines the necessity of personalized treatment plans to account for individual differences in treatment response and concurrent mental health conditions. It also addresses limitations, such as accessibility issues and the need for broader outcome measures in clinical trials. Future research directions include investigating the opioid-sparing effects of psychological therapies and enhancing intervention efficacy through innovative methodologies. By advancing our understanding of the interplay between psychological factors and chronic pain, this review provides a comprehensive foundation for improving treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of life for individuals with chronic pain.
Keywords
Chronic pain; Psychological interventions; Biopsychosocial model; Cognitive-behavioural therapyIntroduction
Chronic pain significantly impacts many individuals in the United States, exceeding the prevalence of diabetes, heart disease, and cancer combined. Unlike acute pain, which serves as a warning for injuries, chronic pain encompasses biological, psychological, and emotional components, leading to a multifaceted experience [6]. Addressing chronic pain requires a comprehensive approach that considers not just physical symptoms but also emotional and psychological factors.
Psychological interventions are essential in chronic pain management, focusing on enhancing physical, emotional, social, and occupational functioning rather than solely aiming for pain relief [2]. Various psychological therapies, including cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT), mindfulness-based therapy, and acceptance and commitment therapy, have been developed to address chronic pain [2]. These interventions help individuals cultivate coping skills, challenge maladaptive beliefs about pain, and foster acceptance, ultimately improving overall well-being [2].
The biopsychosocial model informs research and treatment in pain psychology by considering physical, cognitive, affective, and interpersonal factors [5]. Pain is not merely a sensory experience; it involves significant emotional distress and disability that can affect various aspects of life [5]. Furthermore, psychological factors significantly influence patients' attitudes and beliefs regarding their chronic pain experiences [4]. Multidisciplinary approaches that integrate physical rehabilitation with psychological interventions have demonstrated promising outcomes in reducing pain intensity and disability among chronic pain patients [4].
Chronic pain imposes a substantial economic burden, making it one of the most costly long-term health conditions by population [12]. It can lead to high levels of distress, disability, and social role loss among affected individuals [12]. Psychological treatments offer pathways to modify processes that contribute to the chronic pain experience. Cognitive-behavioral therapy is widely acknowledged as a gold standard for psychological intervention in managing chronic pain [15].
In summary, collaboration between healthcare providers, including psychologists and other medical professionals, is vital for addressing the complex nature of chronic pain. Understanding the interplay between biological and psychological factors is essential for effective management of this condition.
Theoretical Framework
Chronic pain is a complex challenge that includes physiological, cognitive, emotional, and sociocultural elements. The biopsychosocial model has become the primary framework for understanding chronic pain, viewing it as an illness rather than a disease and emphasizing the subjective nature of pain management over seeking a cure [5].
Psychological interventions are crucial in managing chronic pain, focusing on psychological factors that affect pain perception and emotional control [2]. Cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) addresses maladaptive thoughts about pain that cause distress and unhelpful behaviours, aiming to enhance self-efficacy and improve mood [1]. Similarly, acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) encourages individuals to accept chronic pain while developing strategies to align their actions with personal values and social roles [1]. Mindfulness-based interventions foster nonjudgmental awareness of physical sensations and emotions, helping to distinguish physical pain from emotional suffering, which enhances psychological flexibility and leads to better emotional well-being and reduced pain-related distress across various chronic pain conditions [1].
Furthermore, psychological mechanisms linked to pain-related distress, such as pain catastrophizing, fear of pain, and pain acceptance, are important targets for intervention [2]. Addressing catastrophic thoughts through psychological strategies can improve short-term physical functioning [2].
In summary, psychological interventions for chronic pain management focus on changing maladaptive cognitions and behaviours while promoting self-management, behavioural change, and cognitive restructuring. These approaches empower individuals with effective coping skills to manage their pain, increase self-regulatory capacities, reduce emotional distress, and improve overall quality of life despite ongoing pain [5].
Ultimately, the theoretical framework for understanding psychological interventions for chronic pain recognizes the complex interplay of physiological, cognitive, emotional, and sociocultural factors. By focusing on key psychological processes related to pain perception and emotional management through methods like CBT, ACT, and mindfulness, addressing maladaptive cognitions such as catastrophic thoughts can significantly improve mood, emotional well-being, functional disability, and overall quality of life for those experiencing chronic pain.
Table 1: Contemporary Psychological Treatments for Chronic Pain [1].
Treatment |
Strategy |
Proposed mechanisms |
Painful conditions |
Outcomes |
Supportive psychotherapy |
Nondirective; emphasizes unconditional acceptance and empathic understanding |
Therapist attention, validation, positive regard |
Vulvodynia, back pain |
Moderate improvements in mood and emotional functioning |
Relaxation training |
Uses breathing, relaxation of muscle groups, and visual imagery to counteract the body’s stress response |
Regulation of the stress response, self-efficacy in pain management |
Headache |
Reductions in frequency of headache; improvements in ability to manage pain; reductions in use of analgesics |
Biofeedback |
Uses biofeedback equipment to monitor physiological processes (e.g., heart rate, sweating) affected by stress and pain; teaches strategies for down-regulating the physiological response, which can improve pain |
Regulation of the stress response, self-efficacy |
Fibromyalgia, headache, back pain |
Small to moderate improvements in pain intensity, depression, physical functioning, and muscle tension |
Hypnosis |
Entails hypnotic suggestions, made by a clinician, for immediate and long-term pain reduction; also incorporates relaxation training |
Dampens neural activity responsible for pain and its transmission |
Back pain, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular disorders, arthritis, mixed pain conditions |
Small to moderate improvements in pain intensity, physical functioning, and mood |
Operant-behavioural therapy |
Eliminates maladaptive behaviours consistent with the “sick” role; replaces them with healthier “well” behaviours |
Positive reinforcement for “well” behaviours; time-contingent pain medication and tapering; role playing and modelling |
Mixed or undefined pain conditions; fibromyalgia, chronic low-back pain |
Small to large reductions in pain intensity, interference from pain, and depressive-symptom severity; return to work; improvements in physical functioning and medication use |
Cognitive-behavioural therapy |
Identifies and alters maladaptive thoughts about pain that precipitate distress and unhelpful behaviours (e.g., isolation, withdrawal, being sedentary); promotes the development of helpful behavioural coping strategies (e.g., relaxation) |
Self-efficacy (confidence) in coping with pain, reduction in maladaptive cognitions, improved sleep |
Musculoskeletal pain, neuropathic pain, headache |
Small to moderate improvements in pain, functional disability, and mood |
Acceptance and commitment therapy |
Encourages acceptance of chronic pain and focuses on strategies for identifying and reinforcing behaviours consistent with valued social roles and desired behavioural goals |
Psychological flexibility, acceptance |
Broadly applied to chronic pain |
Small to medium effects on mood and physical functioning |
Mindfulness-based interventions |
Emphasizes the importance of nonjudgment; aims to disentangle physical pain from emotional suffering via increased awareness of the body, the breath, and activity |
Psychological flexibility |
Broadly applied to chronic pain |
Improvements in emotional well-being; reductions in pain-related distress; pain outcomes vary by condition |
Emotional-awareness and expression therapy |
Highlights the interconnectivity of brain regions responsible for processing physical pain and emotions; encourages confrontation of avoided emotions or stimuli to dampen the connection between emotions and pain |
Exposure, dampened neural activation of physical pain–emotion circuits |
Fibromyalgia; preliminary evidence to date for most other pain conditions |
Small to moderate effects on pain, functioning, and emotional distress |
Psychologically Informed Physical Therapy |
Integrates physical therapy and cognitive-behavioural therapy for chronic pain |
Exposure, self-efficacy |
Knee pain, low-back pain |
Small effects on functioning |
Table 2: Descriptions of psychological therapies for pain [2].
Therapeutic modality |
Description of treatment |
Operant-behavioral therapy |
Treatment focuses on extinguishing maladaptive behavioral responses and fostering of adaptive behavioral responses to pain. Behavioral responses are altered through reinforcement and punishment contingencies and extinction of associations between threat value of pain and physical behaviour. |
Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) |
Treatment applies biopsychosocial approach to pain that targets behavioral and cognitive responses to pain. CBT protocols involve psychoeducation about pain, behaviour, and mood, strategies for relaxation, behavioral pacing, behavioral activation, positive event scheduling, effective communication, and cognitive restructuring for distorted and maladaptive thoughts about pain. |
Mindfulness-based stress reduction |
Treatment promotes a nonjudgmental approach to pain and uncoupling of physical and psychological aspects of pain; teaches “non-striving” responses to pain through experiential meditations and daily mindfulness practice intended to increase awareness of the body and proprioceptive signals, awareness of the breath, and development of mindful activities. |
Acceptance and commitment therapy |
Based on psychological flexibility model, treatment focuses on development of acceptance of mental events and pain and ceasing of maladaptive attempts to eliminate and control pain through avoidance and other problematic behaviours; emphasizes awareness, defusing, and acceptance of thoughts and emotions as well as behavioral engagement in pursuit of personal goals. |
Table 3: Demonstrated efficacy of psychological interventions by pain population [2].
Therapeutic modality |
Pain disorder |
Operant-behavioral therapy |
Complex regional pain syndromes, lower back pain, mixed chronic pain, whiplash-associated disorders |
Cognitive-behavioral therapy |
Cancer, chronic lower back pain, chronic headaches, chronic migraines, chronic orofacial pain, complex regional pain syndromes, fibromyalgia, HIV/AIDS, irritable bowel syndrome, mixed chronic pain, nonspecific heart pain, multiple sclerosis, nonspecific musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, spinal cord injury, systemic lupus erythematosus, whiplash-associated disorders |
Mindfulness-based stress reduction |
Arthritis, cancer, chronic lower back pain, chronic headache, chronic migraine, complex regional pain syndromes, fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome, rheumatoid arthritis, chronic neck pain |
Acceptance and commitment therapy |
Musculoskeletal pain (full body, lower back, lower limb, neck, upper limb), whiplash-associated disorders |
Key Psychological Factors
Pain Perception
The process of pain perception is complex, involving cognitive evaluation, emotional reactions, and behavioral responses to nociceptive signals. As highlighted in [17], cognitive appraisal is a key factor in shaping the subjective experience of pain. Individuals assess the significance of sensory cues to determine whether they indicate actual or potential harm. This assessment is highly individualized and can be influenced by past experiences and beliefs about pain. For instance, seasoned athletes may interpret muscle burn sensations during exercise as signs of increased strength and endurance, whereas beginners may perceive the same sensations as indicators of harm.
The cognitive evaluation of pain is impacted by neurobiological mechanisms that separate the sensory and emotional aspects of pain perception. Changes in pain intensity trigger different brain areas, such as the somatosensory cortex and anterior cingulate cortex, leading to variations in how pain unpleasantness is perceived by individuals. This variability in interpreting bodily sensations can determine whether they are seen as distressing or not, underscoring the subjective nature of pain perception.
Furthermore, the perception of pain as manageable or uncontrollable also influences the overall pain experience. According to [17], individuals who believe they possess adequate coping resources to deal with pain may view it as more controllable and have lower subjective pain intensity. This belief is linked to increased activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, a brain region involved in regulating emotions. Conversely, catastrophizing about pain, which involves seeing it as overwhelming and uncontrollable, is associated with higher levels of perceived pain intensity regardless of physical limitations.
In conclusion, cognitive appraisal plays a significant role in determining how individuals perceive and react to chronic pain. Understanding these cognitive processes can guide the development of psychological interventions aimed at changing maladaptive thought patterns and enhancing coping strategies for improved chronic pain management. For more information on cognitive appraisal in pain perception, interested readers can consult [17].
Figure 1: A schematic of nociception, pain perception, and the biobehavioural response to pain in the human nervous system [17].
Emotional Regulation
The management of chronic pain is closely tied to emotional regulation, which significantly influences how individuals perceive and cope with pain episodes. Emotional dysregulation, marked by heightened sensitivity to emotional triggers that hinder effective emotion management, is a key factor in the development and persistence of chronic pain [14]. Many individuals suffering from chronic pain report experiencing negative emotions such as fear, anger, and worry, which correlate with increased pain levels and disability [14].
Negative emotions have been linked to increased activity in brain regions involved in processing emotions and pain perception, including the amygdala, anterior cingulate cortex, and anterior insula [17]. These areas are crucial for focusing attention on pain, enhancing its unpleasantness, and raising awareness of bodily sensations. The prevalent fear of pain among chronic pain sufferers often leads to heightened vigilance toward pain-related cues and an intensified focus on pain sensations, worsening their overall pain experience [17].
Emotional regulation also affects cognitive processes that shape pain perception. Negative emotions like anger, sadness, and fear can impair prefrontal cortex functioning, hindering the ability to manage pain through cognitive strategies such as re-evaluation or perceiving pain as controllable [17]. This suggests that interventions aimed at improving emotional regulation may offer significant benefits for those experiencing chronic pain.
One effective intervention is Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy (EAET), which targets disrupted emotional processes that contribute to or maintain physical discomfort [1]. EAET emphasizes the connection between emotional and physical pain experiences, assisting individuals in recognizing unresolved emotional issues that affect neural pathways involved in pain perception. By promoting the adaptive expression of emotions related to past traumas or stressors, EAET enhances emotional regulation skills, enabling individuals to engage more fully in daily activities [1].
In summary, addressing emotional dysregulation through interventions like EAET presents a valuable strategy for managing chronic pain. By improving emotion regulation skills and fostering healthy expression of past emotional experiences, individuals with chronic pain may experience improvements in overall well-being and quality of life.
Coping Strategies
Effective management of chronic pain heavily relies on the implementation of coping strategies, particularly through psychological interventions. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) stands out as the cornerstone in psychological intervention for pain management, providing individuals with coping skills to enhance pain management and overall psychological well-being. These skills encompass structured relaxation techniques, behavioral activation, assertive communication, and behaviour pacing to prevent worsening pain episodes [2]. By addressing maladaptive cognitive and behavioral responses to pain, CBT aims to transform negative and unrealistic thoughts about pain into more positive and adaptive ones [2].
Furthermore, mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) has exhibited effectiveness in dealing with chronic pain by promoting acceptance of the condition rather than solely focusing on pain control strategies. Through enhancing emotional wellness and encouraging participation in non-pain-related activities, MBSR can lead to enduring effects on pain severity and psychological distress levels [2].
In addition to these approaches, neuropsychological studies underscore the significance of understanding the role of brain regions like the prefrontal cortex in coping with chronic pain [13]. By targeting these neural areas using interventions such as CBT and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT), individuals can reshape their perception of pain and elevate their overall quality of life [13].
In summary, coping strategies constitute a vital component of psychological interventions for chronic pain management. Whether through CBT, MBSR, or other mindfulness practices, these strategies empower individuals to actively improve their functionality and alleviate the adverse impact of chronic pain on their daily lives. By fostering acceptance, altering maladaptive thought patterns, and instigating behavioral changes, these interventions offer hope for individuals grappling with chronic pain [1].
Review of Current Research on Chronic Pain and Psychological Interventions
Overview of the Relationship between Chronic Pain and Psychology
Chronic pain poses a multifaceted challenge that impacts individuals on various levels, including physiological, emotional, cognitive, and sociocultural aspects. Viewing chronic pain through a biopsychosocial lens is essential, as it necessitates comprehensive management approaches rather than being treated solely as a physical symptom [5]. Psychological interventions are crucial in the multidisciplinary treatment of chronic pain, addressing cognitive, emotional, and behavioral components of the pain experience [5].
Research indicates that psychological therapies such as operant-behavioral therapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy, mindfulness-based stress reduction, and acceptance and commitment therapy effectively manage conditions like lower back pain, migraines, fibromyalgia, and arthritis [2]. These interventions focus on enhancing self-management skills, facilitating behavioral changes, and reshaping maladaptive thought patterns instead of merely targeting the physical source of pain [5]. By integrating these psychological treatments into overall pain management plans, individuals can develop improved coping mechanisms, reduce disability, and enhance emotional well-being [5].
The prevalence of chronic pain highlights the need for a comprehensive management approach. Research suggests millions of Americans suffer from chronic pain annually, leading to significant economic costs and personal distress [1]. Incorporating psychological interventions into chronic pain treatment not only improves patient outcomes but also reduces reliance on potentially harmful strategies, such as opioids or surgical procedures [16]. By tackling psychosocial factors like coping mechanisms and fear avoidance behaviours, psychological approaches are vital in decreasing disability and improving the quality of life for those affected by chronic pain (Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Report: Updates, Gaps, Inconsistencies, and Recommendations [7].
In summary, the link between chronic pain and psychology emphasizes the importance of recognizing the holistic nature of the pain experience. Psychological interventions offer valuable tools for addressing the emotional and cognitive dimensions of chronic pain alongside traditional medical treatments. By incorporating these psychological strategies into multidisciplinary pain management, healthcare providers can help individuals with chronic pain regain control over their lives and enhance their overall well-being.
Analysis of Key Findings from Major Studies
Examination of key discoveries from 50 research studies demonstrates substantial evidence supporting the effectiveness of psychological treatments for chronic pain. A meta-analysis by Hoffman (2007) assessed different interventions for chronic lower back pain (CLBP) and identified positive outcomes related to pain levels, daily activity interference, quality of life, and depression. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and self-regulation techniques were noted as effective when used in multidisciplinary care or as standalone therapies [16].
A systematic review by Boersma (2019) focused on eight randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that improved emotion regulation skills for chronic pain conditions like musculoskeletal pain, fibromyalgia, headaches, and irritable bowel syndrome. These trials showed reductions in pain severity, daily activity interference, anxiety and depression, sleep quality, and overall quality of life through interventions targeting emotion awareness and expression training or relaxation techniques [3].
The biopsychosocial model is a crucial framework for understanding chronic pain experiences, highlighting how psychological factors influence risk and resilience in pain management. CBT is recognized for its efficacy in equipping individuals with coping skills to manage pain flare-ups effectively. Moreover, studies indicate that CBT yields greater improvements in pain severity, physical functioning, catastrophic thinking, and mood compared to standard care alone. Numerous RCTs have validated CBT’s effectiveness across diverse populations and conditions [9,1].
Integrating mindfulness-based practices, such as mindful emotion regulation training, alongside traditional CBT has shown promise in managing rheumatoid arthritis. Zautra (2008) found that mindful emotion regulation training, when compared to CBT and educational interventions, improved pain control and coping strategies post-treatment [3].
Overall conclusions indicate that psychological treatments significantly impact neurobiological mechanisms associated with pain perception, emotional regulation processes, and coping strategies, leading to better health outcomes for individuals with chronic pain. Further research is needed to tailor interventions based on individual differences and address concurrent disorders to enhance the effectiveness of psychological therapies in managing chronic pain.
Table 4: Characteristics of the included studies. [Source: reference (Norman-Nott et al., 2024) [3]].
Trial/country |
N |
Age (years) M (SD) Sex (% female) |
Chronic pain condition |
Comorbidities (%) |
Comparison |
Sessions, duration; delivery mode |
Intervention length |
Outcomes |
Assessment points |
Intervention compliance (%) |
Safety |
RoB |
Boersma et al. (sub-ref-2019) |
115 |
44.5 (12) |
Chronic musculoskeletal pain |
Anxiety and/or depressive symptoms (100%) |
Hybrid DBT versus CBT |
a. 10–15 sessions, 62–86 min; in-person, individual |
16–21 weeks |
Pain intensity; pain interference; anxiety; depression; pain catastrophizing; emotion regulation |
PI |
a. 91.3% |
a. 6/58 AE |
Some concerns |
Sweden |
|
83% |
|
Psychiatric comorbidity (66%) |
|
b. 8 sessions; Internet, guided |
|
|
9-month FU |
b. 94.7% |
b. 11/57 AE |
|
Carty et al. (sub-ref-2019) |
62 |
46.03 (15.1) |
Chronic urogenital pain |
NR |
Emotion awareness and expression interview vs TAU |
a. 1 session, 90 min; in-person, individual |
Single session |
Pain intensity; pain interference; depression; anxiety; pelvic floor symptoms |
6-week FU |
a. 100% |
NR |
Some concerns |
USA |
|
100% |
|
|
|
b. NA |
|
|
|
b. NA |
|
|
Hsu et al. (sub-ref-2010) |
45 |
50.1 (10) |
Fibromyalgia |
NR |
Affective self-awareness vs waitlist |
a. 1 session, 90 min; in-person, individual and 3 sessions, 120 min; in-person, group |
4 weeks |
Pain intensity; pain interference; painful body regions; quality of life; fatigue; sleep; locus of control |
PI |
a. 87.5% |
NR |
High |
USA |
|
100% |
|
|
|
b. NA |
|
|
6-month FU |
b. NA |
|
|
Lumley et al. (sub-ref-2017) |
230 |
49.13 (12.22) |
Fibromyalgia |
NR |
Emotion awareness and expression therapy vs CBT vs fibromyalgia education |
a. 8 sessions, 90 min; in-person, individual |
8 weeks |
Pain intensity; fibromyalgia symptoms; sleep; cognitive dysfunction; depression; anxiety; fatigue; affect; quality of life; healthcare use |
PI |
a. 77.2% |
a. 1/79 AE |
Some concerns |
USA |
|
94% |
|
|
|
b. 8 sessions, 90 min; in-person, individual |
|
|
6-month FU |
b. 64% |
b. 0/75 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
c. 8 sessions, 90 min; in-person, individual |
|
|
|
c. 80.3% |
c. 0/76 |
|
Slavin-Spenny et al. (sub-ref-2013) |
147 |
22.1 (6) |
Chronic headaches |
NR |
Anger awareness and expression training vs relaxation training vs waitlist |
a. 3 sessions, 60 min; in-person, group |
4 weeks |
Pain intensity; headache frequency; disability; anxiety; depression; alexithymia; affect; assertiveness; emotion processing and expression; self-efficacy |
PI |
All three sessions in-person or audio recording: |
NR |
Some concerns |
USA |
|
87.80% |
|
|
|
b. 3 sessions/ 60 min; in-person, group |
|
|
|
a. 82% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
c. NA |
|
|
|
b. 87.5% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
c. NA |
|
|
Thakur et al. (sub-ref-2017) USA |
106 |
36.14 (16.42) |
Chronic irritable bowel syndrome |
NR |
Emotion awareness and expression training vs relaxation training vs waitlist |
a. 3 sessions, 50 min; in-person, individual |
2 weeks |
Pain intensity; quality of life; anxiety; depression; hostility symptoms |
PI |
a. 92% |
NR |
Some concerns |
|
80% |
|
|
|
b. 3 sessions, 50 min; in-person, individual |
|
|
10-week FU |
b. 92% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
c. NA |
|
|
|
c. NA |
|
|
|
Yarns et al. (sub-ref-2020) |
53 |
73.5 (9.5) |
Chronic musculoskeletal pain |
Psychiatric diagnosis (86.8%) |
Emotion awareness and expression training versus CBT |
a. 1 session, 90 min; in-person, individual and 8 sessions, 90 min; in-person, group |
9 weeks |
Pain intensity; pain interference; anxiety; depression; sleep; fatigue; quality of life |
PI |
a. 85.7% |
NR |
High |
USA |
|
7.60% |
|
|
|
b. 1 session 90 min; in-person, individual and 8 sessions 90 min; in-person, group |
|
|
3-month FU |
b. 92% |
|
|
Zautra et al. (sub-ref-2008) |
144 |
52.4 (13.18) |
Rheumatoid arthritis |
Recurrent depression |
Mindful emotion regulation training vs CBT vs education |
a. 8 sessions/ 120 min; in-person group |
8 weeks |
Pain intensity; affect; depression; coping; catastrophizing; pain control |
PI |
a. 98% |
NR |
Some concerns |
USA |
|
68.10% |
|
-74.31% |
|
b. 8/120 mi; in-person group |
|
|
|
b. 98% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
c. 8/120 mi; in-person group |
|
|
|
c. 100% |
|
|
Impact of Psychological Interventions on Neurobiological Mechanisms
Role of Psychology in Altering Neurobiological Processes Related to Chronic Pain
Chronic pain is a multifaceted challenge significantly impacting overall well-being. Understanding its neurobiological mechanisms involves recognizing the psychological factors that influence these processes. Interventions like cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based therapy can affect supraspinal pain processing, as noted in [8]. By targeting brain regions related to perception, emotion, cognition, and behaviour, these therapies can lead to positive changes that improve chronic pain management.
Research indicates that chronic pain correlates with alterations in brain areas responsible for pain processing. For example, changes in neuronal activity and connectivity within the somatosensory cortex (S1) occur after pain signal transmission. Additionally, disruptions in networks such as the central executive, default mode, sensorimotor, and salience networks have been documented in those experiencing chronic pain [10]. These alterations may contribute to central sensitization and the emergence of mental health issues like anxiety and depression.
Psychological factors are crucial in shaping both pain perception and emotional responses to pain. Emotional, social, and environmental influences can significantly modify how one experiences pain, as indicated in [18]. Depression can heighten pain perception, while attention to pain, cognitive evaluations, and individual traits also affect perception. Key brain structures involved include the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), prefrontal cortex (PFC), insular cortex (IC), and amygdala, which process pain-related signals and regulate emotional responses.
Integrating psychological interventions into chronic pain management strategies helps individuals develop coping mechanisms and reduce maladaptive reactions to pain. Hypnosis, for instance, has been effective in improving outcomes like pain intensity, duration, frequency, and physical disability among those with chronic painful conditions [1]. Neurophysiological studies suggest that hypnosis targets specific brain structures involved in pain processing, inhibiting neural activity linked to pain signal transmission.
In summary, psychology significantly influences the neurobiological processes associated with chronic pain, which is vital for improving treatment outcomes and enhancing the quality of life for affected individuals. Addressing psychological factors through methods such as CBT, mindfulness-based therapy, and hypnosis allows healthcare providers to offer holistic care that considers both physical and emotional dimensions of chronic pain management. Continued research into these interventions and their underlying mechanisms will be essential for advancing our understanding of how psychology can shape the neurobiological aspects of chronic pain.
Figure 2: Ascending pain pathway from periphery to central. Note: PAG = periaqueductal gray [source: reference (Shi & Wu, 2023) [8]].
Figure 3: Modulation of pain signals in the spinal dorsal horn [source: reference (Shi & Wu, 2023) [8]].
Specific Mechanisms Influenced By Psychological Interventions
Psychological interventions significantly influence mechanisms associated with chronic pain by modifying pain signals and altering activity in key brain regions responsible for pain perception, emotion, cognition, and behaviour. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based therapy are effective approaches that facilitate positive psychological and behavioral changes, aiding individuals in managing chronic pain [8]. These interventions target brain areas such as the thalamus, somatosensory cortex, insula, anterior cingulate cortex, amygdala, prefrontal cortex, and hippocampus [8].
Chronic pain is not just a physical sensation; it is also deeply affected by emotional factors like depression and anxiety. Research indicates that neurotransmitter disruptions, particularly in glutamate and gamma-aminobutyric acid, can complicate emotional regulation in those with chronic pain [3]. Moreover, irregular functional connectivity between the medial prefrontal cortex and the amygdala has been associated with depressive symptoms in chronic pain patients [3]. Thus, incorporating emotional regulation skills into psychological interventions is essential for effective chronic pain management.
Investigating how psychological interventions affect neurobiological mechanisms related to chronic pain represents a vital research area. Understanding these impacts allows healthcare professionals to create personalized and effective treatment plans for patients [8]. Recent studies underscore the significance of exploring neurobiological changes connected to emotion regulation skills-focused (ERSF) interventions in managing chronic pain. By normalizing these alterations through targeted therapies, there is potential to reduce emotional distress and improve overall pain outcomes [3].
In conclusion, psychological interventions are crucial for addressing mechanisms linked to pain perception, emotional regulation, and coping strategies in chronic pain management. By focusing on critical brain regions involved in supraspinal pain processing and integrating emotional factors through ERSF interventions, healthcare providers can offer more comprehensive care to those suffering from chronic pain. Continued research is necessary to delve into the neurobiological underpinnings of these interventions and enhance their effectiveness in improving outcomes for patients experiencing chronic pain.
Table 5: The summary of neurotransmitters involved in pain sensation [18].
Neurotransmitter |
Type |
Receptor |
Distribution |
Function |
Glutamate |
Amino acid |
NMDAR, AMPAR, mGluR |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory |
Aspartate |
Amino acid |
NMDAR, AMPAR, Kainate receptor |
CNS |
Excitatory |
Histamine |
Monoamine |
H1 |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory |
CGRP |
Peptide |
Heterotrimers of CALCRL, RAMP1 and RCP |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory |
Substance P |
Peptide |
NK1, NK2, NK3 |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory |
GABA |
Amino acid |
GABAA, GABAB |
CNS, PNS |
Inhibitory |
Glycine |
Amino acid |
GlyR |
CNS |
Inhibitory |
Endogenous opioids |
Peptide |
μ-, κ- and δ-receptors |
CNS, PNS |
Inhibitory |
Cannabinoids |
Lipid |
CB1, CB2 |
CNS, PNS |
Inhibitory |
5-HT |
Indole derivative |
5-HT1-4, 7 |
CNS, PNS |
Dependent on 5-HT receptors |
Norepinephrine |
Monoamine |
α1, α2, β adrenergic receptors |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory (α1, β), inhibitory (α2) |
NO |
Gasotransmitter |
Diffusion across membrane |
CNS, PNS |
Excitatory or inhibitory |
Comparison of Different Types of Psychological Interventions for Chronic Pain Management
Exploring psychological interventions for chronic pain management reveals a wide array of approaches designed to address the complex nature of this condition. These interventions focus on various aspects of pain perception, emotional regulation, and coping strategies to reduce pain intensity and improve quality of life.
Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is a prominent intervention that targets maladaptive thoughts about pain, which can exacerbate distress and unhelpful behaviours. By promoting self-efficacy in managing pain and dismantling negative cognitions, CBT has shown modest to moderate improvements in pain levels, functional impairment, and mood [2,1]. It is particularly effective for conditions such as musculoskeletal pain, neuropathic pain, and headaches [1].
Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) encourages individuals to accept their chronic pain while focusing on behaviours that align with their valued social roles and goals. This approach has produced slight to moderate benefits in mood and physical functionality [2,1].
Mindfulness-based interventions also show promise in managing chronic pain by fostering nonjudgmental awareness of physical sensations and emotional experiences. This method aims to separate physical suffering from emotional distress, leading to improvements in emotional health and reductions in pain-related anguish, with outcomes varying based on the specific pain condition being treated [2,1].
Operant-behavioral therapy has been applied to chronic lower back pain and fibromyalgia, emphasizing the replacement of maladaptive behaviours with healthier alternatives through positive reinforcement. This therapy has resulted in modest to significant decreases in pain severity, interference with daily activities, depressive symptoms, and improvements in physical functioning and medication use [1].
These diverse psychological interventions provide essential resources for individuals facing chronic pain. By addressing different biopsychosocial factors associated with pain experiences, they offer the potential to enhance quality of life by alleviating pain severity, improving emotional well-being, and developing adaptive coping strategies. Further research into the comparative effectiveness of these interventions could lead to more personalized treatment options based on individual needs and preferences.
It is crucial to recognize that tailored treatment plans are vital for successfully managing chronic pain. Such plans assist healthcare professionals in selecting the most appropriate interventions to meet each patient's unique requirements. See also [11].
Effectiveness and Limitations of Current Psychological Interventions for Chronic Pain
Psychological interventions are crucial for managing chronic pain, addressing the complex interplay between pain perception, emotional regulation, and coping mechanisms. As highlighted in (Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Report [7], psychological factors significantly influence how individuals experience and respond to pain, affecting treatment adherence and levels of disability. Chronic pain sufferers often face psychological distress, maladaptive coping strategies, and reduced physical activity due to fear of exacerbating their condition. This emphasizes the importance of integrating psychological interventions into chronic pain management to reduce disability and improve overall well-being.
Research indicates that early psychological interventions can positively impact postsurgical pain and opioid use (Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Report [7]. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is a particularly effective intervention supported by strong evidence [16]. CBT aims to alter maladaptive thoughts and behaviours associated with pain while promoting self-efficacy and adaptive coping skills. Studies show that those who participate in CBT experience significant improvements in pain levels, mood, cognitive coping strategies, activity levels, and social functioning.
Furthermore, findings from a study comparing various psychological interventions for chronic pain management are discussed in [4]. Mean scores and standard deviation for each measure in pre- and post-health assessment according to the treatment group are attached in Table 6 below. The results reveal that combining psycho-education with physiotherapy or self-hypnosis and self-care can enhance patients' attitudes and beliefs about their pain. Notably, patients receiving both psycho-education and physiotherapy exhibited greater improvements in their pain perceptions than those who underwent self-hypnosis and self-care.
Despite the effectiveness of psychological interventions, several obstacles persist. Limited access to evidence-based psychological treatments for chronic pain is affected by geographical barriers, reimbursement challenges, and inadequate education among healthcare providers (Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Report [7]. Additionally, there are gaps in addressing mental health comorbidities in conjunction with chronic pain management [10].
In summary, while psychological interventions have demonstrated potential in alleviating chronic pain and enhancing the quality of life for patients, there is a critical need for broader access to these therapies. Addressing barriers through enhanced education for healthcare providers, improved reimbursement policies, and tailored approaches for individuals with mental health comorbidities can bolster the effectiveness of existing psychological interventions in managing chronic pain.
Table 6: Mean scores and standard deviation for each measure in pre- and post-health assessment according to the treatment group [4].
Control Mean (SD) |
Psycho-education & physiotherapy Mean (SD) |
Self-hypnosis & self-care Mean (SD) |
||||
Pre |
Post |
Pre |
Post |
Pre |
Post |
|
Visual analogy scale |
||||||
5.5 (1.6) |
5.7 (2.3) |
6.1 (1.7) |
5.8 (2.2) |
5.3 (1.8) |
4.6 (2)a |
|
Patients' global impression of change |
||||||
n/a |
3.7 (1.6) |
n/a |
3.4 (1.5) |
n/a |
2.7 (1) |
|
Survey of pain attitudes – 35 |
||||||
Control |
6.01 (3.89) |
7.36 (4.81) |
5.67 (3.78) |
7.72 (4.43) |
8.57 (3.36) |
11.99 (3.51) |
Disability |
14.4 (4.02) |
14.27 (4.56) |
13.99 (3.81) |
13.49 (3.84) |
13.06 (3.7) |
11.71 (4.16) |
Harm |
10.56 (4.43) |
10.21 (4.23) |
8.79 (3.9) |
7.36 (4.3) |
8.51 (3.95) |
7.84 (3.95) |
Emotion |
11.71 (5.44) |
11.75 (5.73) |
12.27 (5.31) |
13.2 (4.3) |
15.01 (3.96) |
14.94 (4.18) |
Medication |
13.58 (4.49) |
14.22 (4.57) |
13.46 (4) |
13.78 (4.18) |
13.1 (4.32) |
12.09 (4.39) |
Solicitude |
8.57 (5.63) |
8.07 (5.5) |
9.46 (5.02) |
9.07 (5.12) |
8.9 (5.21) |
8.49 (4.95) |
Medical cure |
11.81 (3.65) |
10.78 (3.57) |
11.7 (3.46) |
9.41 (3.32) |
10.35 (3.44) |
9.22 (3.33) |
Future Directions in Research and Treatment for Chronic Pain and Psychology
The exploration of future research and treatment avenues for chronic pain and psychology is crucial for overcoming existing challenges in the field. There is an urgent need for practical trials evaluating established psychological interventions such as CBT-CP, along with acceptance and mindfulness-based therapies, to determine their real-world effectiveness [1]. Customizing these interventions to accommodate individual differences and coexisting disorders, while incorporating optimization strategies, is essential for maximizing their impact.
Addressing comorbidities is vital for enhancing treatment outcomes for those suffering from chronic pain. Existing psychological interventions must be adapted to cater to individuals with complex presentations that include mental health issues like depression, anxiety, trauma, substance use, and addiction [1]. Integrated approaches that focus on both pain management and concurrent mental health concerns have shown promise in reducing depressive symptoms, pain severity, and related disabilities.
Enhancing the efficiency of established interventions through innovative methodologies is another critical aspect of future endeavours. Utilizing functional and physiological measurements as diagnostic indicators can strengthen psychological treatments for chronic pain [1]. The integration of technology-assisted assessment strategies allows for improved monitoring of outcomes such as physical functioning and activity over time, providing valuable insights into the effects of psychological interventions on pain, functionality, distress, and sleep.
Standardizing and broadening outcome measures in clinical trials for psychological interventions in chronic pain are fundamental for advancing the field. It is necessary to include a broader range of measures beyond traditional outcomes like pain severity or physical functionality, encompassing factors such as healthcare utilization, medication usage, and missed workdays [1]. Given the opioid crisis's influence, there is a pressing need to explore the opioid-sparing effects of nonpharmacological treatments like psychological therapies in future research.
In conclusion, future directions in research and treatment for chronic pain and psychology should focus on bridging gaps in clinical practice through the extensive implementation of effective psychological interventions [11], tailoring treatments to individual needs [3], optimizing intervention efficacy via innovative methods [9], expanding outcome measures in clinical trials [15], and investigating the opioid-sparing effects of psychological therapies [11]. By embracing these directions, the field can advance evidence-based care for individuals struggling with chronic pain.
Conclusion
The utilization of psychological interventions in managing chronic pain has shown promising outcomes in improving the well-being of individuals affected by this debilitating condition. Various therapies, including cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), mindfulness-based therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT), and operant-behavioral therapy, effectively target physical, emotional, social, and occupational functioning rather than merely focusing on pain resolution [2].
CBT is particularly successful in helping individuals modify their thoughts and behaviours related to chronic pain, which leads to improved mood and reduced pain-related distress [16]. By addressing maladaptive thinking and behaviour patterns, CBT empowers individuals to manage their pain proactively and enhance their quality of life [16].
Psychologists play a crucial role in assisting individuals with the thoughts, emotions, and behaviours related to chronic pain. They work collaboratively with patients to create personalized treatment plans that may include relaxation techniques, coping skills training, addressing anxiety and depression, challenging negative thoughts about pain, and promoting lifestyle changes to support ongoing engagement in daily activities [6].
Furthermore, psychological factors significantly influence the experience of chronic pain. Multidisciplinary approaches that combine physical rehabilitation with psychological interventions have proven more effective than traditional treatments from general practitioners or medical specialists in alleviating pain and reducing disability [4].
Mindfulness-based stress reduction programs have also demonstrated positive outcomes by increasing awareness of bodily sensations and emotions associated with pain. By fostering nonjudgmental observation of pain experiences, individuals can learn to emotionally and cognitively distance themselves from pain, leading to improvements in emotional well-being and decreased distress among chronic pain sufferers [1].
In summary, integrating psychological interventions into chronic pain management can enhance self-management capabilities, improve coping resources, reduce disability, lessen emotional distress, and ultimately lead to a better quality of life for those living with chronic pain conditions [5]. As research continues to explore the effectiveness of various psychological approaches, it is essential to consider individual differences in treatment response and optimize outcomes for those facing this challenging condition.
References
- Driscoll MA, Edwards RR, Becker WC, Kaptchuk TJ, Kerns RD. Psychological Interventions for the Treatment of Chronic Pain in Adults. 2021.
- Sturgeon JA. Psychological therapies for the management of chronic pain. 2014; 115-124.
- Norman-Nott N, Hesam-Shariati N, Wewege MA, Rizzo RRN, Cashin AG, Wilks CR. Emotion regulation skills-focused interventions for chronic pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis. 2024.
- Vanhaudenhuyse A, Gillet A, Malaise N, Salamun I, Grosdent S, Maquet D, et al. Psychological interventions influence patients attitudes and beliefs about their chronic pain. 2018; 8: 296-302.
- Roditi D, Robinson ME. The role of psychological interventions in the management of patients with chronic pain. Psychology Research and Behavior Management. 2011.
- Managing chronic pain: How psychologists can help with pain management. 2024.
- S. Department of Health and Human Services. Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Report: Updates, Gaps, Inconsistencies, and Recommendations. Retrieved from U. S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2019.
- Yu Shi, Wu W. Multimodal non-invasive non-pharmacological therapies for chronic pain: mechanisms and progress. BMC Medicine. 2023; 21: 372.
- Driscoll MA, Edwards RR, Becker WC, Kaptchuk TJ, Kerns RD. Psychological Interventions for the Treatment of Chronic Pain in Adults. 2021.
- Vinall J, Pavlova M, Asmundson GJG, Rasic N, Noel M. Mental Health Comorbidities in Pediatric Chronic Pain: A Narrative Review of Epidemiology, Models, Neurobiological Mechanisms and Treatment. 2016.
- Driscoll MA, Edwards RR, Becker WC, Kaptchuk TJ, Kerns RD. Psychological Interventions for the Treatment of Chronic Pain in Adults. 2021.
- Fisher E, Williams AC, Hearn L, Eccleston C. Psychological therapies for the management of chronic pain (excluding headache) in adults. 2020.
- Theodoratou M, Argyrides M. Neuropsychological Insights into Coping Strategies: Integrating Theory and Practice in Clinical and Therapeutic Contexts. 2024.
- Norman-Nott N, Hesam-Shariati N, Cashin AG, Wewege MA, Rizzo RRN, Wilks CR, et al. Evaluation of emotion-centric psychological interventions for chronic pain: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. 2022.
- Driscoll MA, Edwards RR, Becker WC, Kaptchuk TJ, Kerns RD. Psychological Interventions for the Treatment of Chronic Pain in Adults. 2021.
- Murphy JL, McKellar JD, Raffa SD, Clark ME, Kerns RD, Karlin BE. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Chronic Pain among Veterans Therapist Manual. 2019.
- Garland EL. Pain Processing in the Human Nervous System: A Selective Review of Nociceptive and Biobehavioral Pathways. Primary Care: Clinics in Office Practice. 2012; 39: 561-571.
- Cao B, Xu Q, Shi Y, Zhao R, Li H, Zheng J, et al. Pathology of pain and its implications for therapeutic interventions. Signal transduction and targeted therapy. 2024.