More Than A Mind: A Psychiatry Resident’s Journey through Stigma
Sheikh MI
Published on: 2025-09-10
Abstract
I had chosen psychiatry partly because I imagined a more settled routine long-term care, time to reflect, and space to connect deeply with patients. But the reality turned out to be different than I envisioned.
Psychiatry has its emergencies: it is intense, misunderstood, and often overlooked. Agitated patients in distress, suicide attempts, acute psychotic breakdowns, severe panic attacks all these arrived at our doorstep, and many times, we were expected to manage them without adequate support. There were no emergency nursing staff trained in psychiatric care and no dedicated security personnel. Once a case was labelled “psychiatric,” most others would step back. The patient became solely “ours.”
Keywords
Psychiatry; Overlooked; Suicide attempts; PatientsOpinion
I stepped into psychiatry believing it would be a refuge of calm, a “quiet” field far removed from the chaos of emergencies. That illusion didn’t last long.
The Quiet Field, I Thought
I had chosen psychiatry partly because I imagined a more settled routine long-term care, time to reflect, and space to connect deeply with patients. But the reality turned out to be different than I envisioned.
Psychiatry has its emergencies: it is intense, misunderstood, and often overlooked. Agitated patients in distress, suicide attempts, acute psychotic breakdowns, severe panic attacks all these arrived at our doorstep, and many times, we were expected to manage them without adequate support. There were no emergency nursing staff trained in psychiatric care and no dedicated security personnel. Once a case was labelled “psychiatric,” most others would step back. The patient became solely “ours.”
What made this even more difficult was the stigma that often accompanied mental illness. While physical ailments were met with empathy and urgency, mental health crises were met with hesitation, avoidance, or judgment. As a resident, I found myself not only managing the symptoms of the illness but also trying to combat this stigma in the eyes of colleagues, patients, and even their families.
I soon realized that psychiatry is not just about the mind but about the person as a whole their struggles, their history, and the stigma they carry. We were expected to address not just the clinical aspects but also the societal factors that impacted the patient’s recovery journey. The work was overwhelming at times, but it was also rewarding, as every breakthrough, no matter how small, felt like a victory against the broader societal misconceptions surrounding mental health. Psychiatry demanded far more than I had imagined, resilience, empathy, and a readiness to challenge the stigma at every step.
The Weight of Judgment
Beyond the clinical challenges, what cut deeper was the unspoken attitude around psychiatry the sideways glances, the offhand remarks. Comments like:
- “Psychiatry must be so easy.”
- “Why would you choose that?”
- “Do you even get affected by your patients?”
- “Psychiatry is the easiest job they just talk to patients.”
- “We’re too busy for this; psychiatry has more time anyway.”
- The looks, the tones, the body language it was clear we weren’t taken seriously, even if no one said it out loud.
- There was a quiet implication that what we did was somehow less “medical,” “less essential.”
In meetings, discussions about psychiatry were often hurried or skipped altogether. Our patients were sometimes described in frustratingly dismissive terms. Some even questioned whether psychiatric patients deserved medical care. It was painful to witness because behind each case was a person struggling deeply, often silently, and our role was anything but easy.
The stigma wasn’t just external; it seeped into the system itself. Resources were often limited.
Despite this, we showed up. We fought to be heard. We advocated for our patients, not just as doctors, but as their voice in a system that often overlooked them. The emotional toll was immense. Some days, it felt like an uphill battle, convincing colleagues, administrators, and even patients themselves that their suffering was real and that their treatment mattered.
The Unspoken Crisis Within
As the months passed, I started noticing another kind of emergency one that unfolded quietly among our colleagues.
We saw a steady flow of undergraduate students, interns, nurses, and postgraduate trainees coming in for psychiatric consultations. Many presented with anxiety, depression, adjustment difficulties, or even psychotic symptoms. Beneath the diagnoses, the causes often echoed the same themes: isolation, lack of social or emotional support, interpersonal difficulties, toxic senior-junior dynamics, departmental pressure, and the fear of not measuring up.
But what made this crisis even more heartbreaking was how invisible it remained. These weren’t just statistics or anonymous cases; they were people we worked with every day, people who sat beside us in the cafeteria and reviewed cases with us in rounds. Yet, their suffering was often dismissed, overlooked, or even ridiculed.
There was a culture of silence. Those who sought help were often met with whispers and judgment:
“She’s acting strange.”
“He’s just trying to get out of work.”
“People like them shouldn’t be in medicine.”
Instead of support, there was distance. Instead of empathy, suspicion. Yes, there were moments of solidarity small pockets of kindness, peers who quietly supported one another but those were the exception, not the norm.
The worst part was the internalized shame. Many colleagues hesitated to seek help, not because they didn’t want to, but because they feared what it would mean. “If I see a psychiatrist, will I still be trusted with my patients?” “If my professors find out, will they think I’m weak?” These questions held them hostage, forcing them to suffer in silence rather than risk judgment.
Building Bridges, Not Walls
I coped the only way I knew how: by connecting. I began reaching out to colleagues from other departments, not just for referrals, but to listen. I validated their concerns, respected their pace, and gently shared knowledge one conversation at a time. Over time, I found a few allies who were open, curious, and willing to unlearn old assumptions.
Most importantly, we need to create an environment where medical students and doctors themselves feel safe to acknowledge their mental health struggles. If we are expected to heal, then we must first learn that we, too, deserve healing.
Why I Stay
Despite the judgment, despite the lack of infrastructure, I remain passionate about psychiatry. The complexity of the human mind, the stories patients bring, and the transformation that’s possible with the right care all of it continues to inspire me. I stay because each day offers a chance to make someone feel understood, to ease suffering, and to challenge stigma from within.
I stay because I have seen what happens when mental health is ignored. I have seen brilliant medical students crumble under the weight of unrelenting expectations. I have seen residents turn to substance use just to get through another exhausting shift.
I dream of a system where psychiatry is treated with the same respect as any other branch of medicine. Where psychiatric symptoms are not dismissed as drama, but investigated with as much seriousness as chest pain. Where our patients are seen not as problems, but as people in pain, yes, but deserving of care, dignity, and hope.
Psychiatry is not a quiet field. It’s full of noise of distress, confusion, healing, and hope. And amid that noise, I’ve found clarity. I’ve found purpose. And most importantly, I’ve found my voice.
And with that voice, I will keep speaking, because silence is no longer an option. Mental health is precious, and it cannot afford to be marred by stigma. Not anymore. It is time for change, for compassion, for a system that values both mind and body with equal urgency and respect.
Acknowledgment
The author sincerely thanks Dr. Bhagyavathi H. D., Professor and Head, Department of Psychiatry, MIMS, Mandya, for her valuable suggestions and editorial guidance in refining this article.