Body image and bodyschema: what in between when embodied and exbodied body representation falls apart?
Zatti A
Published on: 1970-01-01
Abstract
The main hypothesis of this work is that the embodiment processes, primarily dependent on cultural pressure, have to be seen in unstable equilibrium with exbodiment experiences, which can be considered as the expression of body schema originated by personal sensory-motor history [1-3]. In order to evaluate the possible separation between the two, a new pictures questionnaire has been elaborated. Dysmorphic "confusion" is widely spreading in contemporary western societies, particularly among adolescents [4.5]. The perception of how we are seen by others (body image) is one of the core issues in social trends, education, and psychopathology [6]. On the other hand, what one implicitly knows of his/her somatic body (body schema) represents the psychological antecedent basis implied in social interaction [2]. This article attempts to give a quantitative dimension to the two sides of the body, the structural, implicit one (body-schema) and the public, partly self-controlled one (body-image).
Keywords
Body Image; Body Schema; Picture Test; Erotic CapitalIntroduction
The frame theory, inspired by the Embodied Cognition and Enaction Theory [7, 8], are theoretical perspectives that share a common background. Oxford Dictionary states: «Embodiment (noun): a tangible or visible form of an idea, quality, or feeling, as in "she seemed to be a living embodiment of vitality".» Following these suggestions, it is possible to interpret embodiment as a "top-down" process of what is the interaction between subjects and cultures. Her subjects are conceived as targets of cultural pressure, composed of social representations or "ideas" [9]. According to the Perception Theory [10], a "top-down process of social models" can be defined as how subjects direct their behaviour based on cultural solicitations. Our social–psychological perspective constantly confronts her or himself with the "collective-mind" point of view [11]. We suggest that the interaction between subject and culture is a two-way process: the top-down influences, embodied by people, and the bottom-up one. We call "exbodiment" this "bottom-up" process, the function of the body schema structure. Exbodiment indicates how subjects "enact" their embodied cultures and how the body expresses their intentionality [12-14] toward the world they live in. This occurs in the Peripersonal Symbolic Sphere (also called in social psychology "the life living", Lewin, [15], where culture is seen as the framework from which people conceive (top-down) norms as a continuous strength to cope with the influence [12]. The verb "to enact" comes from the philosophy of language theory. It emphasises the specific ontology of a bill or a legal proposal because the structure of legal sentences are social facts with a certain grade of objectivity. Action is a more general word, while enaction stresses the institutional nature of people's activity. We cannot just say that "one acts," but we propose that oriented enactions, acted by subjects and structured by a culture, construct one's own social world. Exbodiment indicates how subjects "enact" their embodied cultures. For example, exbodiment refers to the process applied by anorexic girls to organise their social echo system to control their attempt to represent the "fitting form" detected in cultural symbols. Embodiment relates to the incoming shape from a culture to a subject, while exbodiment refers to the never-ending process by which subjects express their mostly contrasted acceptance of a cultural and social model. Picture 1 presents a graphic representation of the general relationship model within embodied and exbodied processes [16].
Figure 1: Embodied and Exbodied Mind Schema.

In Figure. 1, dashed external lines stand like a porous border between the global cultural milieu and what has been here called the "peri-personal symbolic sphere" (not all the possible cultural contents affect an individual!). In a certain way, the Social Representation System is an "engine" that pulses from the general cultural milieu values, images, and symbols into the personal sphere. At the core of it, we find the subject so written because we assume, also, if not verifiable, it is the source or origin of psychological processes. Around the issue are traced lines into the two more relevant psychological processes for our discourse: imagination – facing cultural intentions – and simulation – facing personal enaction –. Individual imagination constitutes a sort of "glue" that captures cultural contents because perception and personal representation become personal beliefs when emotional reactions occur. On the other side, enaction via simulation and direct-action experiences gives access to a unique way to be in the world, called Exbodiment. Following neurological research [17, 18], it is possible to consider embodiment as an effect of cultural pressure that originates from the image of oneself, in other words, called "body image". On the other hand, exbodiment, the word that stays here for personal skills or expressiveness, is a function of body schema because of exbodiment results from the specialisation and integration of the sensory-motor body systems. It is possible to sustain [8] that body schema refers to neural systems implicated in movement while body image refers to the visual-affective beliefs of oneself [19]. The body image can be considered the representation of the Self according to the cultural pressure in a specific society. As stated before, this research hypothesises that body schema (the base on which rest exbodiment) and body image (embodiment) can result in very different balances. The Body Image and Schema Test aims to reveal and describe the body image/schema equilibrium.
Materials and Methods
The research here presented rests on a double approach to the aim of the study (in what balance are body image and body schema), approaches based on two empiric tools developed by authors: The Body Image and Schema Testand the Erotic Capital Grid. The tool we developed called Body Image and Schema Testis based on pictures designed to investigate this unconscious knowledge to overcome the difficulty of verbally expressing one's body schema. The Body Image and Schema Test (this is the full name, shortly called BIST) has been created using symbolic pictures for different anatomic apparatus (cardio-circulatory, respiratory, digestive, reproductive systems) and self-representation, bonds, cultural females and males' images. In figures 1 and 2, samples of two items of the test that be reached at Url: https://forms.gle/ETZ8mNzgwbGNrcgx9.
Figure 2: item “mouth”

Figure 3: Item house.
|
Gender Distribution |
|||
|
|
N° |
% |
|
|
|
Female |
6778 |
54,7 |
|
Male |
5518 |
44,5 |
|
|
Other |
77 |
,6 |
|
|
Tot. |
12373 |
99,8 |
|
|
Missing |
|
24 |
,2 |
|
Total |
12397 |
100,0 |
|

Pictures are ordered on a four Likert scale, from simple to complex. The final version is under validation, counting on a total sample via the Amazon Mechanical Turk tool of around 12000 subjects. The Body Image and Schema Test has also been cross-tested with a subsample of girls confronted by a specific grid for measuring Erotic Capital [20] on Facebook profiles. As it is known, Facebook and other social media (i.e. Instagram) is the most popular instrument to present oneself to an extensive social group. The in-progress test demonstrates initial reliability as a potential objective tool to describe body schema structure and better understand body image in different "body experiences", and what differences between the two could be used as sources for personal inquiry. Catherin Hakim's "Erotic capital" book (2011) is the main inspiration for the here presente7d exploration. Girls and many young women struggle with the image they think reflect the Great Mirror of the Generalised Other (Mead, 11). Users' self-representation in their Facebook bulletin board is the access point of Alberto Zatti and Nicoletta Riva's working team. The "Erotic Capital Grid" of Facebook profile images tries to rate the erotic capital implicitly expressed through a public profile; in other words: the public presentation of self (the body image). It attempts to measure three of the six factors theorised by Hakim (the seventh, fertility, is explicitly omitted by Hakim because of its low relevance in western society). This research also omitted face beauty (because of its innate origin) and sex performance (because not commonly shown on internet socials). The remaining factors from Hakim's theory here taken are body sex appeal, fashion and embellishment, and social and communication abilities. The Grid consists of items which are grouped into four main aspects. Aspects can be illustrated into two principal axes: the "Styling Axis" (the "Me" that is presented ") and the "Seduction Axis" (the "You" to whom the message is implicitly sent). The Styling Axis consists of two aspects/categories: the Embellishment category (i.e. items are hairstyles and makeup) and "Fashion" (i.e. items are clothing, accessories such as handbags, earrings, etc.). The Seduction Axis consists of two categories: "Communication and Charm" (i.e. items are "poses" and "look"); the category called Sex Appeal (which includes items such as the percentage of naked skin, the mouth expression- closed, winking, laughing, etc.). A correction of the relative intrinsic weight of each variable has been made (variables are 0/1 like) to transform them from categorical to scale values. As stated before, this analysis is assumed as an indicator of the body image because it is self-evident that the image itself cannot be done without considering the cultural context by which fashion, embellishment, seduction rules, etc., are core issues. In other words, the body is always dressed, posed, and pictured; rarely (or never) it is nude-flesh presented (with the exception of medical visits!). In Picture 2, the two main axes (Styling and Seduction) and the four categories (Beautifying and Fashion; Sex appeal and communication and charm) are represented.
Figure 4: Reassume categories with grid examples.

Results from the Erotic Capital Grid were then compared with the other instrument, "Body Image and Schema Test of the Somatic-Psychic Imaginary". As presented above, this tool is intended to analyse the "Body schema", which differs from the body image. The body schema refers to implicit, interoceptive knowledge. It is closely related to the innervations that are projected on the plane of the body's brain representation (i.e. the sensual and motor homunculus), with integration with, among others, the proprioceptive system. The body schema is the result of the elaboration of our experiences in life and the interaction between one's body and the surrounding environment throughout years of psychomotor development. The Body image and Body schema may differ from one another, not infrequently causing some degree of suffering due to the discretion between the implicit knowledge of the body's schema and the culturally mediated knowledge according to the aesthetic and functional values transmitted by the female psychosocial models. The Somato-psychic Body Image Test consists of 26 items composed only of images, sorted like a Likert scale with four values. Four images are ordered according to a growing image element complexity (logical criterion) and according to a psycho-evolutionary progression (ontogenic criterion). The Body Image and Schema Test subjects sample now consists of 12397 respondents to the Mechanical Turk platform. These respondents are the baseline (see Figure 5) toward which they are confronted with the here two case study subjects. Tables 1, 2 and 3 show the whole sample by gender, age and family culture.
Table 1: Sample Genderdistribution.
|
Gender Distribution |
|||
|
|
N° |
% |
|
|
|
Female |
6778 |
54,7 |
|
Male |
5518 |
44,5 |
|
|
Other |
77 |
,6 |
|
|
Tot. |
12373 |
99,8 |
|
|
Missing |
|
24 |
,2 |
|
Total |
12397 |
100,0 |
|
Table 2: Sample by age distribution.
|
Age distribution |
|||
|
|
0 19 years |
521 |
4,2 |
|
20 - 32 years |
6388 |
51,5 |
|
|
33 - 49 years |
4192 |
33,8 |
|
|
50 - 80 years |
1215 |
9,8 |
|
|
Tot. |
12316 |
99,3 |
|
|
Missing |
|
81 |
,7 |
|
Total |
12397 |
100,0 |
|
Table 3: sample by family culture distribution.
|
Family Culture distribution |
|||
|
|
N. |
% |
|
|
|
Mediterrenean |
1659 |
13,4 |
|
North American |
2939 |
23,7 |
|
|
Middle Eastern |
191 |
1,5 |
|
|
Hebrew |
110 |
,9 |
|
|
Centre African |
108 |
,9 |
|
|
South African |
115 |
,9 |
|
|
Latin American |
1023 |
8,3 |
|
|
North African |
1906 |
15,4 |
|
|
East European |
286 |
2,3 |
|
|
Russian |
83 |
,7 |
|
|
Far East |
121 |
1,0 |
|
|
Chienese |
165 |
1,3 |
|
|
Indian |
1824 |
14,7 |
|
|
Others |
1105 |
8,9 |
|
|
Europe (North Centre) |
266 |
2,1 |
|
|
Tot. |
11901 |
96,0 |
|
|
Missing |
|
496 |
4,0 |
|
Total |
12397 |
100,0 |
|
A sub-sample of 13 girls was evaluated for this explorative research. Both BIST and the Grid of the Erotic Capital were applied. Moreover, a group of 16 male boys rated on a scale from 1 to 4 the 13 girls' pictures from the "beauty" point of view (their "male view"). Male judges produced a rank of the 13 sub-sample girls.In the end, this research is based on three independent evaluations and a popular indicator like the number of Facebook friends:1) The evaluation made with the application of the Erotic Capital Grid to 10 photos taken randomly by Facebook of each subject, with the corresponding number of "like"; 2) The evaluation of each girl's Somato-psychic Body Image Test; 3) The evaluation received by the group of 16 young males; 4) Number of Facebook friends. A larger Cross-validation of the two main tests (Erotic Capital Grid and Body image Test) is still underway. Here we want to present the first results on the possible meaning of digging into Body image and schema tests taken on a deep analysis of two single girls extracted from the sub-sample.
Results and Discussion
For each of the two subjects here presented, it will be shown: 1. the number of Facebook friends (assumed as a popularity indicator); 2. The so-called "male attraction point" due to votes given by the male "judges" to the girl's picture ("how do you evaluate her beauty on a 1 to 4 scale?"; max score: 64); 3. the profile obtained in the Body Image and Schema Test compared to the average of the entire sample; 4. a correlation between the four Erotic Capital Dimensions calculated with the specific Grid elaborated by authors and the likes received in that photos (see Table 4). In Figure 5, the blue line indicates the averages of the sample. The red line shows the values obtained by the subject. Deviations greater than or equal to two points out of the mean are put under analysis, especially when they coincide with a whole Somato-psychic apparatus. Items are on the abscissa axe. With numbers, here are indicated references between test variable pictures and underline independent meaning: 1 – 2 cardiovascular apparatus; 3 -5 respiratory apparatus; 6 – 7 skin; 8 – 10 oro-digestive apparatus; 11 – 14 Self; 15 – 17 sexual apparatus; 19 – 22 psychomotor system; 23 – 24 Female Male gender symbolic pictures; 18, 25 and 26 items are not relevant. Table 6 shows the correlation between the number of likes a subject receives for her photos on Facebook organised according to the four aspects Embellishment and Fashion (related to the Styling axis) and the category Communication and Sex appeal (enclosed in the Seduction axis). Comments and interpretations will be elaborated, taking concepts from phenomenology, psychoanalytic, and psychosomatic theories [21-23]. Case1. Vara (fantasy name) – 2832 friends; Male attraction points 57/64. Alias: "The Wax Doll" (Pictures 1 and 2 are Facebook Vara's self-representation.)
Pic.1, 2.
Figure 5:Varas Body Image Test Profile VS. Sample Average.


Table 4: Correlation between Facebook Vara’s like and Erotic Capital Grid.
|
Correlation between FB Like &“Beautifying” category. |
0,61 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & “Fashion” category. |
-0,35 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & "Communication and Charm" category. |
-0,10 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & “Sex Appeal” category. |
-0,23 |
In Vara's Body Image and Schema Test, there is a subsidence of values at the epidermic apparatus, while the values of the oral-digestive apparatus are high compared to the average. The configuration suggests a developed control system to counteract a deficiency in the epidermal apparatus: that the distance may occur during the seduction process since the intimate skin dimension seems to be fragile in the examined subject (one could even assume some form of skin allergy predisposition, to be validated with an in-depth interview with the subject herself). However, Vara was the most appreciated girl by the male sample group. The "vitality" reported by the circulatory system is average. Above the average is the item related to self-representation as if it were a house (in the case, a skyscraper-house). Instinctual sexuality is also above the average, while four items are devoted to psycho-sense-motor development at the lowest level. The correlation between the numbers of "likes" and the components of the erotic capital shows that in this specific case study, the "beautification" process (makeup etc.) is a crucial factor in getting "likes" from her friends. Negative and not particularly relevant correlations can be found in the other three poles of erotic capital. Vara seems to be high on the list of approved, especially if not almost exclusively based on her facial care. She seems flattered by her appreciation and takes more care of her look. The other component, which we will call communicative intent, is missing, as the "seduction" component does not seem to be one of her weapons. To sum up, the below-average placement of the body diagrams affecting the skin and psychomotor development may indicate some form of development block in terms of peri-personal space between the individual and his environment. A "silky", fine, delicate epidermal system could limit the ability to "get close" to others. High values in the oral-digestive apparatus associated with control and consideration above the average of the genital apparatus associated with sexuality might indicate a form of "algid" attitude: sexuality that acts more in a "remote "approach rather than in intimacy. For peers' eyes, she was the most appreciated girl, receiving a score of 57 out of 64 as a maximum, and, in addition, the pictures of Vara on Facebook received compliments almost exclusively on her ability to present her face as if she were statically "perfect". She has been labelled a "wax doll", a title that brings together a "distance" of that beauty and diaphanic perfection concentrated on the oval of the face and nothing more. Case 2. Bora (invented name) – 691 friends; Male attraction points 54/64. Alias: Miss "I would like to be a show-girl, but ... ". (Pictures 3 and 4 are Facebook Bora's self-representation.
Figure 6: Boras Body Image Test Profile VS. Sample average.

Pic. 3, 4.
Table 5: Correlation between Facebook Bora’s like and Erotic Capital Grid.
|
Correlation between FB Like & Beautifying” category. |
0,58 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & “Fashion” category. |
-0,06 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & "Communication and Charm" category. |
-0,23 |
|
Correlation between FB Like & “Sex Appeal” category. |
-0,25 |
The Bora profile generally looks livelier than the other girls' profiles. Many items are above or below the population's average so far. The apparatus that receives "contrasting" choices (above or below the average) are, in particular, the cardio-circulatory apparatus, the epidermal, the oral-digestive apparatus and the psychomotor development system. Such considerations suggest that the subject may be disharmonised in many major psychosomatic systems (of the body). Observing now the axes of the erotic capital examined with the Grid, we notice that the only pole that has some correlation between the likes and photographs is the Embellishment factor, i.e. makeup and clothing. For the rest, Bora does not seem to get compliments for other erotic poles investigated by Facebook Grid (all negative and modest value correlations). Such framework allows considering the individual still partially unripe on balance between the body's complexity (the scheme-image equilibrium) and the "instruments" available to a woman to increase the overall erotic capital. It is pointing to this intrinsic potency of a body taken more by opposing polarities and perhaps still to blend as a whole that has been coined the appellative Miss "I would like to be a show-girl, but ..." Dots of suspension are indicative of a state of immature-maturation of the body apparatus and systems as a whole.
Conclusion
The human body is every time a new discovery. Embodied movement in cognition [24], theory of mind [25], artificial intelligence [26], etc., are recent scientific approaches to an "object" that we can consider as "old" as humankind. In psychology, social theories and clinical theories are mostly apart from each other. This tradition is changing because of the wide spread of some cultural-based disturbs, like eating disorder behaviour. Female image, but more general, self-image, is a perception product. As with all perception processes, it consists of a syncretisation of different cognitive sources: icon memory, imagination, sensory stimulus, social context expectations, self believe about social context adequacy, etc. As a cultural species, humankind adjuncts a very complex dimension to oneself presentation, like the dress, fashion, maquillage, etc. Body image is quite never a "flesh fact". Maybe just for medical personnel, the body has to be presented in its nudity, but our body is exhibited naked in no other social place. Body image is always a construction made by organic structure and cultural artefacts. A different discourse can be done for what neurology intends for body schema. Body gesture, movement, and action are results of very complex different neural systems cooperation, combining both sensory and motor brain centres. Training to build neuro-motor schemas requires a very long time and effort, as in each human art like dance, sports, playing drama, art crafts competencies, etc. Our body schema permits our ability to cope with issues an individual finds in his/her world. Social images influence personal imagery. How a social model goes deeply into a mind also depends on the inexperience of oneself body. How to present his/her body, what effect it has on others, and how much control one can have of its expressiveness are dimensions that affect the individual "agentivity". Body image's cultural inscription is referred to as an embodied process. The critical factor that influences if the social body image pressure will be total mimesis or an original interpretation is here attributed to the exbodied capacity coming from body schema structure [27]. Embodied and exbodied mind-body personal structures are supposed to be in circular causality. It is known that some anorexia nervosa patients are frequently engaged in intense physical activities. In our interpretation, their conscious control of the body, coming from the colonisation of embodied images, stands for a disequilibrium between body image and body schema, which is last treated as an organic machine to win. The research here presented is an attempt to face the body study from a psychosocial point of view, considering it (the body) in both its part: a cultural construct and an organic structure. Noticing how in recent times, individual action has been reduced (see the range of possibility in mass-urban societies as quiet as all western societies are), imagery has come to the front stage. In our approach, this is translated into a loss of equilibrium between body image (occupying more and more mental space) and body schema. Via two original instruments, the Psychosomatic Body Image and Schema Test and Erotic Capital Grid, this research has shown in two cases their potential to describe and confront the image and schema sides of the body. The research's first results showed as Vara's success in social media and boys-judges' eyes is very body image based. For the other case, Bora, at Erotic Capital Grid, points out her presentation in more dynamic terms, but the Psychosomatic Body Image and Schema Test indicates a not yet mature integration between different body schema systems (interceptive and psychomotor ones). Our search is under wide development via cross-validation with other tests, such as human drawing, single case stories, focus groups and clinical conversation, personality tests such as the Big five tests, etc. But from these exploratory two single case research, it is possible to consolidate Embodied self-image and Exbodied auto expression as the columns to take into count in the psychology of the contemporary bodies.
References
- Csordas TJ. Embodiment and experience: the existential ground of culture and self / edited by Thomas J. Csordas. Cambridge: Cambridge University press. 2001.
- Preester H, Knockaert V. Body Image and Body Schema, John Benjamins Publishing Company, Amsterdam, Philadelphia. 2005.
- Pitron V, Alsmith A, Vignemont F. How do the body schema and the body image interact? Consciousness and Cognition. 2018; 65, 352-358.
- Gadsby S. Distorted body representations in anorexia nervosa. Consciousness and Cognition. 2017; 51: 17-33.
- Zamariola G, Vlemincx E, Corneille O, Luminet O. Relationship between interoceptive accuracy, interoceptive sensibility, and alexithymia. Personality and Individual Differences. 2018; 125: 14-20.
- Lindblom J. Embodied social cognition / Jessica Lindblom. Chan: Springer. 2015.
- Varela FJ, Rosch E, Thompson E. The Embodied Mind: Cognitive Science and Human Experience, Cambridge, MIT Press. 1992.
- Stewart J, Gapenne O, Di Paolo EA. Enaction. Toward a New Paradigm for Cognitive Science, MIT Press, Boston. 2010.
- Farr RM, Moscovici S, Rappresentazioni Sociali, II Mulino, Bologna, 1989.
- Howe CQ, Beau Lotto R, Purves D. Comparison of Bayesian and empirical ranking approaches to visual perception. Journal of Theoretical Biology. 2006; 241: 866-875.
- Mead George Herbert Mind, self and Society; edited by Charles W. Morris, annotated ed. by Daniel R. Huebner and Hans Joas, 2015.
- Lakoff G, Johnson M, Metaphor We Live by. Chicago, London: The University of Chicago Press. 1982.
- Seth AK. Interoceptive inference, emotion, and the embodied self. Trends in Cognitive Sciences. 2013; 17: 565-573.
- Seth AK, Tsakiris M. Being a Beast Machine: The Somatic Basis of Selfhood. Trends in cognitive sciences. 2018; 22:
- Lewin K. Field Theory and Experiment in Social Psychology: Concepts and Methods. The American journal of sociology. 1939; 44: 868-896.
- Zatti A, Zarbo C. Embodied and exbodied mind in clinical psychology. A proposal for a psycho-social interpretation of mental disorders, Frontiers in Psychology, HYPOTHESIS AND THEORY ARTICLE published: 03 March 2015.
- Ondobaka S, Kilner J, Friston K. The role of interoceptive inference in theory of mind. Brain and Cognition. 2017; 112: 64-68.
- Lopez C, Schreyer HM, Preuss N, Mast FW. Vestibular stimulation modifies the body schema. Neuropsychologia. 2012; 50: 1830-1837.
- Bernardi N, Marino B, Maravita A, Castelnuovo G, Tebano R, Bricolo E. Grasping in wonderland: altering the visual size of the body recalibrates the body schema. Experimental Brain Research. 2013; 226: 585-594.
- Hakim Catherine Erotic Capital: The Power of Attraction in the Boardroom and the Bedroom. Basic Books, London. 2011.
- Diamond N. Between Skins: The Body in Psychoanalysis, Chichester, Wiley-Blackwell. 2013.
- Gallagher S, Zahavi D. The Phenomenological Mind. 2nd ed. London; New York: Routledge. 2012.
- Stern E. Embodied cognition: A grasp on human thinking. Nature. 2015; 524: 158-159.
- Adams F. Embodied cognition. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 9: 619-628.
- Bruin L, Michael J. Prediction error minimization: Implications for Embodied Cognition and the Extended Mind Hypothesis. Brain and Cognition. 2010; 112: 58-63.
- Froese T, Ziemke T. "Enactive Artificial Intelligence: Investigating the Systemic Organization of Life and Mind." Artificial Intelligence. 2009; 466-500.
- Schulz A. Interoception. Elsevier. 2015.