Governance, Prevention, and Treatment with Implications for an Intervention from Dermatological Health in the COVID-19 Era

Morales FE, Guillen JC, Sanchez AS, Gracia TJH, Munoz EM, Lirios CG, Campas CYQ, Velazquez LMG and Ornelas RMR

Published on: 2022-03-15

Abstract

Social Work studies of dermatological health show that prevention is a low-cost factor with respect to the treatment of a disease acquired by parasite contamination. In this sense, a documentary, cross-sectional and descriptive study was carried out with a non-probabilistic selection of indexed sources, registered in ISSN and DOI, during a period that goes from 2019 to 2022 with the purpose of establishing an integral model for the study. Of an outbreak of dermatological contamination and derive intervention strategies from Social Work in basic education institutions. The propagation model turned out to be the most complete, although the integration of other models that explain the contagion problem and future treatment, recontagion and prevention scenarios is offered. The need to carry out strategies for prevention and promotion of disease-free lifestyles, as well as individual self-care and collective co-responsibility, is noted.

Keywords

Governance; Health; Disease; Parasite; Intervention

Introduction

Until January 2022, the pandemic has killed six million, although governments and health ministry’s recognize an underreporting of 18 million [1]. The number of deaths related to COVID-19 would rise to 24 million. In Mexico, the pandemic has ended the lives of 300,000 recognized by the government but underreporting reaches the figure of 700,000. The World Health Organization declared that COVID-19 is not transmitted between infants, although cases of infection, illness and death have increased [2]. Governments have followed the WHO recommendation to avoid vaccinating infants, even though the delta and omicron variants have impacted infant health. The ministries of health and education pressed for the return to classrooms and face-to-face classes without vaccinating students. In January 2022, the WHO recommended the vaccination of infants due to the increase in deaths. In Mexico, the government interpreted the WHO recommendation as avoiding immunizing students. In the framework of deaths from COVID-19, dermatological health has been affected. The public health system, being focused on the SARS CoV-2 coronavirus, has neglected attention to other diseases [3]. In addition, users of the health service have confined themselves to avoid getting infected in hospitals. Users have postponed their treatments. The pandemic also affects the basic education system in which students interrupt Their dermatological treatments or cannot Access them to avoid getting COVID-19 [4]. Dermatological Infections and diseases emerge in a context of school overcrowding but distancing and confinement redirect the cycle. Confined and isolated students tend to stress and avoid the daily personal hygiene that school dynamics require of them. Therefore, the parasite epidemic is possible, even when students are confined and isolated. The objective of the present study is to formalize a mathematical model that is closest to the investigation of contamination and interactions of lice with children [5]. Exponential function models, Quetelet logistic models, Locka-Volterra function models, McKendrick propagation models and dermatological treatment models are reviewed to establish an intervention device for the governance of dermatological health in public education institutions. Basic with emphasis on health promotion and self-care in vulnerable groups. What are the approaches that explain the impact of the pandemic on dermatological health in a scenario of infection and disease due to an epidemic of parasites in children of basic schools in Mexico City? The premises that guide this work warn: 1) The SARS CoV-2 coronavirus pandemic and the COVID-19 disease can coexist with other infections and dermatological diseases such as parasites; 2) Confinement and distancing of students reduces the chances of infection and illness, but encourages stress; 3) Students with stress levels may avoid personal hygiene, as well as parasite prevention practices; 4) COVID-19 and parasites can coexist in a scenario of confinement and distancing, increasing significantly in the return to face-to-face classes; 5) Basic education systems do not have the resources to prevent both COVID-19 and parasites, delegating the care of students to families; 6) The governance of public health, with an emphasis on dermatological health, can be built on the differences between the rulers and the ruled due to the lack of vaccination and resources.

Dermatological Health Governance

The history of public health, health policies and dermatological programs and health prevention and promotion strategies are areas of multidisciplinary research and knowledge in which Social Work acquires greater relevance by establishing an approach with vulnerable groups such as infants [6]. It is estimated that the costs of treatment exceed the costs of prevention to a greater extent, since for every peso spent on the treatment of diseases or care for accidents, a penny would be spent on prevention. In this sense, both areas, health promotion and social care for diseases, pandemics or epidemics, are central issues of management and administration in health policies. In other words, the participation of vulnerable groups is increasingly significant to the extent that they develop lifestyles and self-care strategies for their personal and collective health [7]. Precisely, in this phase the dialogue between specialized institutions and citizens is a problematic hinge in the achievement of objectives, elaboration of tasks and obtaining goals in the short, medium, and long term by health professionals in general and professionals of the Social Work in particular. In this way, the governance of dermatological health will be understood as a set of policies for the inclusion of governmental and social actors in the face of a public health problem such as dermatological diseases in vulnerable groups [8]. It is a surveillance, follow-up and co- responsibility system between the authorities and the potential victims of diseases, epidemics, or pandemics. Unlike health policies focused on research, specialization and treatment, dermatological health governance is low-cost, includes all actors and establishes co-responsibility agreements around objectives, tasks and goals established in a medium term [9]. In such a scenario, the participation of public health professionals and of social workers, is extremely important since the strategies are disseminated in the institutions and sectors most affected by dermatological contamination.

Dermatological Contamination Public Health

In Mexico, the lice epidemic, year after year, has manifested itself in public and private schools, affecting above all the child population. Insects approximately one to two millimeters long, that hide in clothing, bedding, and the scalp [10]. This parasite causes inflammation, itching and sucks the blood of the person who hosts it. Lice are brown, oviparous insects that live exclusively on human hair and can be seen with the naked eye (they measure between two and three millimeters). They don't have wings and can't fly, but their six legs, which end in small claws, allow them to hold on tightly to fur [11]. They also have a small head with mouthparts prepared to bite the scalp and suck the blood they feed on,

A louse lives between 33 and 35 days and goes through three stages:

 Nit: for 6–7 days. It is the egg of the louse (an adult female lays an average of 110-150 during her life). It is attached to the base of the hair [12]. Only 60% reach the adult louse. Nits differ from dandruff in that the former present great resistance when trying to be removed and cannot be removed with a simple wash. Nymph: for 9–10 days. It is the louse just hatched from the egg. It is invisible to the human eye. Its body undergoes three growth molts until it becomes an adult and can reproduce. Adult louse: for 15–16 days. The females deposit four to eight eggs daily at between one and two millimeters from the scalp. Her favorite places: the hairs behind her ears, on the crown of her head, and on the back of her head. To ensure their adherence to the hair, they secrete a sticky and water-insoluble substance that fixes the nit to the hair shaft. According to information from the Mexican Society of Dermatology, in 2019 there is an epidemic in our country, which has manifested itself in public and private schools, and continues to affect the child population of our country [13]. The louse does not discriminate against race or social status and despite the myths of most Mexicans, it is not a matter of poor hygiene, but rather they are spread by contact between people in closed places such as schools, workplaces, families, prisons. and hospitals.

State Of Knowledge: Mathematical Models of Public Health

Exponential function models

The exponential function is present in many growth phenomena: animal, plant, economic, spread of epidemic diseases and others [14]. In all of them, the variable is time. It is also known as unlimited population growth. It serves to describe any process that evolves so that the increase (or decrease) in a small interval of time is proportional to what was at the beginning of it. That is, the rate of change of a population only depends on its size.

-It is reasonable for small populations in large environments.

-Population growth rate is proportional to its size.

Graph of a function that satisfies the differential equation

We must take into account the following considerations:

P= Population (dependent variable)

t= Time (independent variable)

k= proportionality constant (parameter). Between the rate of population growth and its size.

The population growth rate P is the derivative  

Here we will treat only ordinary equation

Since it is proportional to the population, it is expressed as the product kP.

P (t) =0. This solution of a differential equation is called an equilibrium solution.

Consequently, the population is not constant. If k>0 and (Pt 0 )>0, at time t=t 0 and the population is growing. As t increases, P (t) becomes larger, so   increases

Logistic function model

The logistic function, logistic curve or S-shaped curve is a mathematical function that appears in various models of population growth, spread of epidemic diseases and spread in social networks [15]. Said function constitutes a refinement of the exponential model for the growth of a magnitude. It was the Belgian mathematician, statistician, and astronomer Adolphe Quetelet who in 1835 proposed the idea that population growth was slowed down by a resistance proportional to the square of said population (mechanical hypothesis).

The logistic curve

To fit the exponential population growth model, you must take into account a limited environment and resources.

If the population is small, the rate of population growth is proportional to its size.

If the population is too large to be supported by its environment and resources, the population will decrease. That is, the growth ratio is negative.

Considerations

t= time (independent variable)

P= Population (dependent variable)

k= growth rate coefficient for small populations (parameter).

We must consider that limited resources must enter another amount. This quantity is a second parameter, denoted by N (it will be called support capacity) of the environment.

In terms of carrying capacity, we assume that P(t) grows if P(t) < N; if P(t) > N is decreasing.

We had agreed that in the exponential model that  in a large environment, in this second model if

What we see in the graph is that as there are outbreaks of lice, and children who are in close contact (given the characteristics of the children), the population of lice will increase continuously.

Lotka-Volterra Model

Without a doubt, the mathematical function for calculating future populations that has aroused the most interest are the well-known ones: with the name of exponential, logistic and the Lotka-Volterra model and others [16]. No species lives in isolation and interactions between species provide some of the most interesting models, here is a simple predator-prey system of differential equations where one species "eats" the other, in this model we have two time-dependent quantities. Our model then has two dependent variables that are both functions of time. In this case we will call the prey “school children” and the predators’ “lice”, and we will denote the prey S and the predators by P. Lotka-Volterra growth model, also known as predator-prey equations , are a pair of first-order differential equations nonlinear that are used for modeling two interacting populations , a prey and a predator. The equations were independently proposed by Alfred J. Lotka in 1925 and Vito Volterra in 1926. Such equations are defined as:

Where:

  • P is the number of children with lice.
  • S is the number of children susceptible to being infected by lice.
  • dP/dt and dS/dt represent the growth of the two populations over time.
  • t represents time.

To formulate this model in mathematical terms, we need four additional parameters to our independent variable t and to our two dependent variables S and P. The parameters are:

α , β , γ and δ are parameters that represent the interactions of the two species .

α: Coefficient of the growth rate of susceptible children, of school age

β: Proportionality constant that measures the number of carrier-susceptible interactions in which lice reproduce in children.

?: Coefficient of the rate of decline of Carriers

δ: Proportionality constant that measures the benefit of the growth of the population of Carriers with respect to Susceptible children.

The Lotka-Volterra model, according to this research, we observe that it encompasses the other two models (exponential and logistic) and that the model meets the objective of demonstrating the interactions of lice with children

Dam

As can be seen; exponential growth is represented by the term .

The term of the equation comes to represent the meeting of the two species and their interaction S and P are zero, there is no interaction.

Predator

In this equation, it represents the growth of predators (note the similarity with the equation for prey, but in this case for predator growth it is necessary to use the rate at which prey are consumed S.

It represents the natural death of predators exponentially; to more predators it is necessary that the number of victims or prey increases to maintain the population.

The equation can be interpreted as the growth of predators by hunting prey minus the natural death of these.

Disease Spread Models

There are some well-known mathematical models in which we model the spread of diseases using the McKendrick model. For a model development, we basically consider the following classes:

  • (S). Children (they are not spoiled)
  • (Z). Pied Children
  • (R). Children who have had their lice removed.

Susceptible Children (S) can become cooed, due to contacts with cooed people . The Empiojada Children (Z) are those children who, when they meet other empiojadas or receive the nit, have reproduced the plague in their heads and this factor has the parameter (ζ). And the Recovered Children (R), are those children who after treatment managed to get rid of the plague in whose factor (β).

This model is a bit more complicated than the basic SIR models that generally characterize infectious diseases as this model has two mass action transmissions, which leads to having more than one non-linear term in the model [17]. Incidence specifies that an average member of the population makes enough contact to transmit the plague (βN) to others per unit of time or by too close contact, where N is the total population of children in the school (we assume that there is the closest contact). nearby) without lice. The probabilities that a random contact by a lousy person (Y/N), will turn another child lousy, therefore, the number of new lousy women through these contacts transmitting the plague in the population is given by:

(βN)(S/N)Z = βSZ

Basic Model of Contagion.

We assume that a susceptible can avoid contagion by staying away from a louse by not having close contact, and each susceptible can resist the plague (in the case of boys having gel on their heads and girls having hair tied) at a rate of α. Thus, using the same idea as above with the probability Z/N of random contact of a susceptible with some lice (not the probability of a louse approaching a susceptible), the number of louses neutralized through this process per time unit per susceptible is:

(αN) (Z/N)S = αSZ

The Ordinary Differential Equation satisfies:

S´+ Z´+ R´= Π

Therefore:

S + Z + R →  

As t → ∞, if Π ≠ 0. Therefore S → ∞, so this translates to a 'lice infestation' scenario: an outbreak of lice will lead to an infestation in the school environment, such as many children are already infected reaching adults.

If we assume that the outbreak occurs over a short time scale, then we can ignore looting rates. Therefore, we set out:

Π = δ = 0.

Setting the differential equations equal to 0 we have:

βSZ = 0

βSZ + ζR – αSZ = 0

αSZ – ζR = 0

From the first equation, we have either S = 0 or Z = 0. Therefore, this follows the form S = 0 with this we get the piojistic equilibrium.

(S, Z, R) = (0, Z, 0)

When Z = 0, we have the lice-free equilibrium.

(S, Z, R) = (N, 0, 0)

These equilibrium points show that, regardless of their stability, the child-employee coexistence is impossible.

The Jacobian is;

We have:

It follows that the characteristic equation always has a root with a positive real part. Therefore, the Lice-free equilibrium is always unstable.

Next, we have:

Then;

Since all the eigenvalues of the doomsday equilibrium are negative, it is asymptotically stable. It follows that, in a short outbreak, lice are likely to infect the entire population.

Spread of Diseases with Latent Infection

We now revise the model to include a latent class of infected people, there is a period (approximately 33-35 days) after the child is a carrier of the louse, before they lice their classmates at school and others are carriers of the louse. Same. Thus, we extend the basic model to include the (more "realistic") possibility that a susceptible individual becomes infected before becoming liceous.

Changes to the Basic Model include:

 

  • Susceptible first pass into a class of cloistered once infected and remain there for some period of time.
  • The lice children can still be disinfected, if the plague is detected, and otherwise they become lice.

We will refer to this as the SIZR model. The model is given by

As before, if Π ≠ 0, then the infection overwhelms the child population. Consequently, we have again to assume a short time frame and hence Π = δ = 0. Therefore, when we set the above equations to 0, we get either S = 0 or Z = 0 from the first equation. It follows once again from our analysis of the basic model that we achieve equilibrium:

Z = 0 (S, I, Z, R) = (N, 0, 0, 0)

S = 0 (S, I, Z, R) = (0, 0, Z, 0)

Therefore, the coexistence between healthy and empiojada children again is not possible. In this case, the Jacobian we have:

The eigenvalues are therefore λ = 0, -βz, -ρ, . Since all Eigen values are non-positive, it follows that the pest equilibrium is stable. Therefore, even with a latent period of infection, the lice will reproduce.

Dermatological Treatment Models

Suppose we can rapidly produce a cure for "greaselessness." Our treatment would be able to allow the lice-free individual to be lice-free, however, the newly lice-infected would again be susceptible to becoming lice-ridden; Therefore, our cure does not provide immunity [18]. Those lice who went through treatment and were allowed to enter the school, had their lice removed are children without lice before entering class R.

Things that need to be considered now include:

  • Since we have the treatment, we no longer need treatment.
  • The cure will allow those who are empiojadas not to be so regardless of how they acquired it.
  • Any lice become susceptible again; the cure does not provide immunity.

Thus, the model with the treatment is given by

The model is illustrated in the following figure:

Since the quadratic expression has only positive coefficients, it follows that there are no positive eigenvalues. Therefore, the coexistence equilibrium is stable.

Impulsive Eradication

Finally, an attempt was made to control the population of homeless people, obstructing the passage of infected children to school facilities or buildings, at those times that our policies allow. It was supposed to be difficult to have the resources and coordination, so he would have to check the kids more than once, and with each check, try to obstruct more lice. The result is an impulsive effect.

Discussion of the Implications of the Models in Social Work

Social Work has moved from models of beneficence, charity and altruism to models of diagnosis, intervention, participation, management and co-responsibility in accordance with health policies and targeted programs. In this sense, the models used allow the work of promoting dermatological health and the dissemination of innovations aimed at preventing diseases in vulnerable groups. In the case of dermatological contamination by parasites, the intervention of Social Work stands out for its ability to spread the infection, promote healthy lifestyles free of contamination and self-care strategies [19]. These are devices in which the social worker generates information that counteracts beliefs about the spread of diseases such as parasites. In principle, the exponential function model would allow the anticipation of scenarios of high contagion and health risks in a vulnerable group. Based on these data, the Social Worker of a basic health institution would promote through images the scenario of deterioration of health due to lack of hygiene and daily personal hygiene among students. In the case of Queenlet’s logistic model, the Social Work professional would generate an inventory from which possible victims of dermatological contamination would have to adopt preventive lifestyles by reducing their contact with groups at risk of contagion [20]. In this way, the logarithmic results would allow decisions to be made against or in favor of the separation of infected groups and groups at risk, as well as the rescheduling of their activities inside or outside the classroom. For its part, the Locka-Volterra function model would integrate the probable exponential contamination scenarios with the effects of this contamination in the groups with the highest risk and in attention to the low-risk groups [21]. In this way, the model would allow anticipating probable scenarios of a new dermatological contamination that would be confronted with a systematic and intensive dissemination of collaborative strategies around caring for the environment to avoid a new outbreak. Finally, the McKendrick propagation model, the model that is most adjusted to the requirements of cooperation and solidarity for the governance of dermatological health, includes not only the groups affected by the disease, but also future interaction scenarios in which new outbreaks in other groups and the recontagion of the first cases would generate a high-risk scenario, but with sufficient information to reduce its exponential and logistic effects Based on these models, a comprehensive model was proposed in which the dependency relationships between infected groups, potential contagion groups, self-care groups, potential recontagion groups, and groups that develop new styles of prevention and self-care are specified. In this scenario, the intervention of social work would not only be the promotion of contagion-free health, but also the dissemination of self-care lifestyles and cooperation in disease prevention. It is a collective health process in which the objective is to avoid a new outbreak, or to reduce it to its minimum expression.

Conclusion

The contribution of this work to the state of knowledge lies in the formalization of mathematical models for the study of the governance of dermatological health in vulnerable groups. This is a discussion about the scope and limits of the models to demonstrate their usefulness in decision-making, the establishment of prevention programs and the dissemination of self-care styles. Public health governance can be built from the conflict between the parties involved. Public and private, social and political actors can activate a negotiation, reach consensus and establish co-responsibilities if the forecasts of the models are considered. In the case of the exponential growth model that poses a collateral pandemic to COVID-19, the present work established that it is the most likely approximation. In a double epidemic scenario, the rulers and the ruled can reach an agreement if public health governance is prioritized. Educational systems under a prevention and self-care policy represent a feasible scenario. The parties involved can achieve co-responsibility from the negotiation of returning to the virtual classroom. Social work has the instruments to implement public health governance to demonstrate that the virtual educational system is as effective as the traditional face-to-face classroom. The prevention of both pandemics, that of the coronavirus and that of COVID-19, can be established from confinement and distancing of people with the assistance of social work.

References

  1. Flores-Morales R, Reidl-Martinez LM, Adame-Rivas AK. Covid-19: Prevalencia de emociones negativas y malestar psicológico en una muestra de adultos de la Ciudad de México. Búsqueda. 2021; 8: 530.
  2. Perez Toriz JE, Baez-Hernández FJ, Flores Merlo M, Nava Navarro V, Morales Nieto A, Zenteno Lopez M. Ángel. El significado Del cuidado enfermero en el contexto de la pandemia COVID-19. SANUS.2020; 161-13.
  3. Ganuza, CV. COVID-19: Crisis e Incertidumbre. Revista Scientific. 2021; 6:9-20.
  4. Diaz-Castrillon FJ, Toro-Montoya AI. SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19: el virus, la enfermedad y la pandemia. Medicina Y Laboratorio. 2020; 24:183-205.

 

  1. Echarri F, Barrio T, Urpi C. El Color del COVID-19. Revista ICONO 14. Revista Científica De Comunicación Y Tecnologías Emergentes. 2021; 19: 288-311.
  2. Ortiz Zurita MJ, Coromina Soler L. Efecto de la pandemia COVID-19 en las percepciones y objetivos profesionales de estudiantes de pregrado de Turismo en Ecuador. CIENCIA UNEMI. 2021; 14:15-28.
  3. Gutiérrez B, Contreras Tinoco K. Gender, psycho-emotional impacts and experiences associated with COVID-19 in adults from Guadalajara, Mexico. Interacciones. 2021; 7:180.
  4. Sandoval CH. La Educación en Tiempo del Covid-19 Herramientas TIC: El Nuevo Rol Docente en el Fortalecimiento Del Proceso Enseñanza Aprendizaje de las Prácticas Educativa Innovadoras. Revista Tecnológica-Educativa Docentes. 2020; 9: 24-31.
  5. Munoz Martinez R. Riesgo, Covid-19 y atención hospitalaria en la Ciudad de México: ¿Hacia una nueva práctica medica. Nóesis. Revista De Ciencias Sociales. 2021; 31: 26-46.
  6. Lozano-Díaz A, Fernandez-Prados JS, Figueredo Canosa V, Martínez Martínez AM. Impactos del confinamiento por el COVID-19 entre universitarios: Satisfacción Vital, Resiliencia y Capital Social Online. International Journal of Sociology of Education. 2020;9-104.
  7. Lorenzo SM. La pandemia COVID-19: lo que hemos aprendido hasta ahora desde España. APS EM REVISTA. 2021; 2: 28-32.
  8. Gago-Garcia C, Gonzalez-Relano R, Serrano Cambronero M, Babinger F. Impacto de la crisis de la COVID-19 en el empleo del sector turístico en España: perspectivas territorial y de género. Boletín De La Asociación De Geógrafos Españoles. 2021.
  9. Roque Rodríguez F, Zambrano Ortiz S, Ruiz Merma W, Huacasi Bellido A, Mendoza Gonzales I, Puma Quito, M. Potencial Antineoplásico E Inmunológico Del Lechero Africano (Synadenium Grantii Hook) En Pacientes Con Factores De Riesgo A Covid 19. Revista Veritas Et Scientia – Upt. 2020; 9; 263 - 272.
  10. Chacon-Lizarazo OM, Esquivel-Nunez S. Efectos de la cuarentena y las sesiones virtuales en tiempos del COVID-19. Eco Matematico.2020; 11: 31-39.
  11. Martinez Garcia G. Recursos y herramientas comunicacionales ante los retos de la educación virtual. Correspondencias & Análisis. 2020; 255-274.
  12. Cambra-Aliaga A, Laborda-Soriano AA, Vidal-Sanchez MI. Terapia ocupacional en situaciones de emergencia: reflexiones desde la historia: Occupational therapy in emergency situations: reflections from history. Revista Terapia Ocupacional Galicia. 2020; 17:77-84.
  13. Castaneda-Hernández DM, Rodriguez Lopez JI. COVID 19 - La pandemia. Una mirada a sus impactos en Latinoamérica. Revista Venezolana De Gerencia. 2020; 25: 746-753.
  14. Esteban-Carbonell E. Las consecuencias de la covid-19 en las personas mayores: el caso de UN centro de actividades de la ciudad de Zaragoza. Barataria. Revista Castellano-Manchega De Ciencias Sociales. 2021.
  15. Gonzalez-Payares M, Ustaris-Sierra A, Cadavid-Pena J. Uso de mascarillas en tiempos de COVID-19: Algunas manifestaciones en la piel del personal de la salud. IPSA Scientia, Revista científica Multidisciplinaria. 2020; 5:152-158.
  16. Morales-Chaine S. Impacto de la pandemia por COVID-19 en la salud mental. Enfermería Universitaria. 2021; 18:1-4.
  17. Perez Chipantiza PX, Norona Salcedo DR, Vega Falcon V. Repercusión SARS-CoV-2 en salud mental y bienestar psicológico Del personal Centro de Salud Huambalo 2020. Revista Scientific. 2021; 6:243-262.