Information System’s Impact on an Organization (Perspectives of the Economics Impact Organizational and Behavioral Impacts)
Muda I, Gusnardi G, Simarmata MFP and Sitorus JEK
Published on: 2025-01-02
Abstract
This paper analyzes the imapct of information systems on organizations in the digital era. The deployment of information technology has transformed organizational operations, communication, and competition. This research seeks to examine the beneficial and detrimental effects of information systems on multiple facets of companies, encompassing operational efficiency, decision-making, team coordination, innovation, and competitive advantage. This study demonstrates, via literature research and case analysis, that information systems can augment efficiency, enhance decision-making, promote collaboration, and stimulate creativity. Nonetheless, the adoption of information systems presents obstacles like investment expenses, data security, and reliance on technology. This study asserts that information systems are pivotal to organizational performance in the digital age, necessitating the formulation of suitable strategies to optimize advantages and mitigate risks associated with their adoption.
Keywords
Information system; Organization; Efficiency; Effective; Management Information System; Decision Making; InnovationIntroduction
In the contemporary digital age, firms must consistently adjust to advancements in Information Systems, particularly Management Information Systems, which are essential for enhancing effectiveness. This study will examine the effects of implementing Management Information Systems on the efficiency of company processes. The digital age has compelled enterprises to confront unparalleled difficulties and opportunities [1]. The advancement of information and communication technology has catalyzed swift transformations in the corporate landscape, modifying the operational practices and strategies of firms. In this setting, Management Information Systems (MIS) have become a crucial component in steering firms through this transformation and improving their efficiency. In the digital world, firms must consistently adapt to evolving circumstances to maintain relevance and competitiveness. Frequent alterations in customer behavior, market dynamics both local and worldwide, and the rapidity of information necessitate that companies possess the appropriate tools to manage and enhance their business or organizational operations. Management Information Systems emerge in the business realm as a solution that facilitates rapid adaptation to changes, enhances efficiency, and confers a competitive edge.
Information systems have evolved into a crucial, online, and interactive instrument that is consistently engaged in operational operations and decision-making within large enterprises. In the last decade, information systems have fundamentally altered a company's economic value and greatly enhanced prospects for work organization. Economic and sociological theories and concepts will elucidate the transformations induced by information technology (IT).
The progression of information technology has transformed the manner in which firms execute their activities [2]. The implementation of business software, database management systems, sophisticated hardware, and web-based applications enables firms to access essential data and information more swiftly and efficiently for business administration. Information systems enable firms to automate numerous mundane processes, including transaction processing, inventory management, and financial reporting. This has substantially affected the company's operational efficiency.
This magazine will examine the influence of information systems on organizations. We will examine the advantages gained by firms that have implemented information systems and also address the problems encountered throughout the implementation process. Furthermore, we will examine tactics and solutions that might assist the corporation in optimizing the advantages of utilizing information technology. By comprehending the significance of information systems in enhancing operational efficiency, the organization may make more informed decisions regarding the management and optimal utilization of its information technology. Moreover, stakeholders, such as company proprietors, business executives, and IT specialists, will acquire enhanced understanding of how information technology can serve as a mechanism to attain business objectives.
Literature Review
Information System
According to Kenneth and Jane [4]: "an information system can technically be defined as a set of interrelated components that collect or obtain, process, store, and distribute information to support decision-making and control within an organization."
In the book "Management Information Systems" (Husein A. Wibowo: 2006), “a computer-based Information System is a system that relies on hardware and software technology to process and disseminate information.”
2.2. Management Information System
2.2.1 According to Jogiyanto Hartono (2000: 700), “the definition of management information system management is a collection of interacting information systems that are responsible for processing and collecting data to provide useful information for all levels of management in planning and control activities.
2.2.2 According to Leonardo Hasahatan Siregar, “the definition of a management information system is management information system is a structured system used to manage data computerized. In the management information system there are several functions functions needed, namely data presentation search and data storage. Thus the management information system can be used to facilitate the preparation of management information (e.g. schools) to be structured well.”
2.2.3 According to Azhar Susanto, “the definition of a management information system is a collection/group of sub-systems/components/parts of any kind, both physical and non-physical, that are interrelated with each other and have functions in terms of physical which are interrelated with each other and have functions in terms of evaluation, control and continuous improvement evaluating, controlling and continuous improvement.”
2.2.4 According to Margianti and Suryadi, “the definition of a management information system is a computer-based system that allows information to be used by managers for the same needs. Information contained management information system usually contains all forms of events in the company, which are events in the past in the company, which is an event in the past, present, to predictions.”
2.2.5 According to Danu Wira Pangestu [5], “the definition of management information system is a collection of information system interactions that are authorized to collect and process data to provide useful information for all levels of management in planning for all levels of management in planning and control activities control activities.”
2.2.6 According to Joel.D. Aron (in the book written by E.S Margianti), “the definition of a management information system is an information system that provides information to all levels of management. Management information system is an information system that provides information needed by a manager in making decisions.”
2.2.7 According to O'brien, “the definition of a management information system is a set of components that are interrelated and work together to achieve common interests by receiving inputs and producing outputs in transformation together by receiving input and producing output in an organized transformation which is organized.”
Result and Discussion
Result
Economics Impact
From an economic perspective, information technology alters both the relative costs of capital and the expenses associated with information. Information systems technology can be seen as a production element that may replace conventional capital and labor. As the expense of information technology diminishes, it replaces labor, which has traditionally been an increasing cost. Consequently, information technology is expected to lead to a reduction in the workforce of middle managers and clerical employees, as it replaces their labor.
As the expense of information technology diminishes, it concurrently replaces other forms of capital, such as infrastructure and machines, which continue to be comparatively costly. Consequently, we should anticipate that managers will augment their investments in IT due to its decreasing cost in comparison to other capital expenditures.
It also influences the cost and quality of information and alters the economics of information. Information technology enables organizations to shrink their size by decreasing transaction costs, which are the expenses associated with purchasing goods in the marketplace that cannot be produced in-house. Transaction cost theory posits that organizations and people endeavor to minimize transaction costs similarly to production costs. Utilizing markets incurs significant expenses due to factors such as sourcing and interacting with remote suppliers, overseeing contract adherence, purchasing insurance, acquiring product knowledge, among others [6]. Historically, companies have sought to minimize transaction costs by vertical integration by expanding, increasing their workforce, and acquiring their suppliers and distributors, as exemplified by General Motors and Ford in the past.
Information technology, particularly network use, can assist companies in reducing market participation costs (transaction costs), so incentivizing them to engage external suppliers rather than relying on internal resources. Consequently, companies may reduce their workforce as outsourcing tasks to a competitive market is far more cost-effective than employing staff. For example, with computer connections to external suppliers, automakers like Chrysler, Toyota, and Honda can realize efficiencies by sourcing over 70 percent of their components externally. Information systems enable corporations like Cisco Systems and Dell Inc. to outsource production to contract manufacturers such as Flextronics rather of manufacturing their goods in-house.
As transaction costs diminish, company size (measured by personnel count) is expected to reduce, as it becomes more efficient and economical for the firm to procure goods and services externally rather than to produce them in-house. The size of a firm may remain stable or diminish despite an increase in revenue. In 1994, when Eastman Chemical Company separated from Kodak, it reported $3.3 billion in revenue and employed 24,000 full-time staff. In 2015, it generated almost $9.6 billion in sales with merely 15,000 employees.
Information technology can also diminish internal management expenses. Agency theory posits that a corporation is perceived as a "nexus of contracts" among self-interested individuals, rather than as a cohesive, profit-maximizing organization [7]. A principle (owner) engages "agents" (workers) to execute tasks on their behalf. Agents require continuous oversight and administration; otherwise, they are likely to prioritize their own interests over those of the principals. As companies expand in size and scope, agency or coordination costs increase, necessitating greater work from owners to supervise and manage employees.
Information technology, by diminishing the expenses associated with receiving and evaluating information, enables firms to lower agency costs, as it facilitates managers in supervising a larger number of people. Information technology facilitates organizations in augmenting revenues by diminishing overall management costs and minimizing the amount of middle managers and clerical personnel. Previous chapters have illustrated how information technology has enhanced the capabilities and reach of small firms by facilitating coordinating functions, such as order processing and inventory management, with minimal clerical and managerial staff.
As information technology diminishes agency and transaction costs for enterprises, we should anticipate a reduction in company size over time with increased capital investment in IT. Companies ought to reduce the number of managers, and we anticipate an increase in income per employee over time.
Organizational and Behavioral Impacts
It Flattens Organizations
Extensive, bureaucratic entities, predominantly established prior to the digital era, frequently exhibit inefficiency, sluggish adaptability, and diminished competitiveness compared to freshly formed enterprises. Several major corporations have streamlined operations by decreasing personnel count and minimizing hierarchical levels.
Behavioral researchers propose that information technology promotes the flattening of hierarchies by expanding information dissemination, hence empowering lower-level employees and enhancing management efficiency. Information Technology decentralizes decision-making authority within the business, enabling lower-level employees to access the necessary information for autonomous decision-making. This empowerment is facilitated by elevated educational levels throughout the workforce, equipping employees with the capacity to make informed decisions. Due to the timely receipt of more precise information, managers are able to make decisions more rapidly, resulting in a reduced need for managerial positions. Management expenses decrease relative to revenues, resulting in a significantly more efficient hierarchy.
These modifications indicate that the scope of responsibility for management has expanded, allowing senior managers to oversee a larger number of employees distributed over wider geographical areas. Numerous corporations have terminated thousands of middle management positions due to these alterations.
4.1.2.2. Post-industrial Organizations
Postindustrial perspectives, grounded more in historical and sociological contexts than in economic frameworks, also endorse the idea that information technology might diminish the prevalence of hierarchical structures. In postindustrial societies, authority is increasingly derived not only from official positions but also from expertise and skill in the relevant subject. Consequently, organizational structures are streamlined as professional workers exhibit self-management. This problem requires a shift towards decentralized decision-making owing to the surplus of expertise and information within the organization. Task force-networked organizations are a category of organizations facilitated by information technology. These organizations consist of professional groups that convene briefly, either in person or virtually, to achieve a specific objective (such as creating a new automobile). Upon completion of the task, the individuals transition to new task forces. Accenture exemplifies a premier global consulting firm. A significant segment of the company's 373,000 employees must relocate to other regions to engage in projects at client sites in more than 56 nations. Who is accountable for ensuring that self-managed teams adhere to the correct trajectory? Who determines the composition of a team and the duration of each member's assignment? What techniques may managers employ to assess the performance of an individual who frequently transitions between various teams? Can individuals ascertain the trajectory of their careers? The Interactive Session on Management emphasizes the necessity of establishing innovative strategies for assessing, structuring, and engaging with personnel. Moreover, it is evident that not all enterprises can effectively execute virtual labor.
4.1.2.3. Understanding Organizational Resistance to Change
Information systems are inextricably linked to organizational politics due to their impact on access to a crucial resource-information. Information systems can influence the roles and interactions of individuals inside an organization, including the timing, location, and methods of these interactions. Numerous new information systems necessitate alterations in personal routines, which can be arduous for people affected and demand retraining and supplementary effort that may or may not be remunerated. Due to the potential of information technology to alter an organization’s structure, culture, business processes, and strategy, significant resistance often arises upon their introduction. Numerous methods exist to illustrate organizational resistance. Studies on organizational resistance to innovation indicate that four aspects are critical: the characteristics of the IT innovation, the organizational structure, the organizational culture, and the tasks influenced by the innovation. Technological changes are assimilated, analyzed, resisted, and overcome by organizational tasks, frameworks, and personnel. In this approach, change can only be achieved by simultaneously altering technology, tasks, organization, and personnel. Other authors have discussed the necessity of "unfreezing" organizations prior to the introduction of an innovation, swiftly executing it, and subsequently "refreezing" or institutionalizing the change [8]. Due to the significant organizational resistance to change, numerous information technology investments falter and fail to enhance productivity. Research on project implementation failures indicates that the predominant cause of large projects not achieving their objectives is not technological failure, but rather organizational and political resistance to change. Consequently, as a manager engaged in prospective IT investments, your capacity to collaborate with individuals and organizations is equally vital as your technical acumen and expertise.
4.1.3. The Internet and Organizations
Even the organization of business operations within a company can be significantly altered by the Internet, particularly the World Wide Web. This is because the Internet has a significant impact on the interactions that exist between several companies and external entities. Organizations benefit from increased accessibility, storage, and distribution of information and knowledge thanks to the Internet. From a fundamental standpoint, the Internet has the potential to significantly reduce the transaction and agency costs that are encountered by the majority of enterprises. For instance, brokerage firms and banks in New York are now able to save millions of dollars in distribution costs by placing their internal operating procedures manuals on the corporate website. This allows them to disseminate the manuals to their employees who are located in remote areas. Through the use of the internet, a global sales force is able to obtain practically instantaneous updates on product price information. Additionally, management can send instructions via e-mail or text messaging to mobile computers or cellphones by employing these devices. It is possible for vendors of certain large retailers to have direct access to the internal websites of those shops, allowing them to obtain up-to-the-minute sales information and immediately commence replenishment orders. In a hurry, businesses are re-building some of their most important business processes on the basis of Internet technology, and they are also making this technology an essential part of their information technology infrastructures. If previous networking experiences are any indication, one of the outcomes will be the simplification of business procedures, the reduction of the number of employees, and the formation of organizations that are far flatter than in the past.
4.1.4. Effectiveness and Operational Efficiency
Management Information Systems (MIS) are essential for improving the efficacy and efficiency of an organization's operations. Beneficial advantages are evident in multiple facets, encompassing process automation and enhanced decision-making quality [3]. A primary contribution of Management Information Systems is their capacity to automate company operations. The system can automate routine and repetitive processes, including transaction processing, inventory monitoring, and order tracking. This diminishes human participation, therefore conserving time and reducing the likelihood of errors attributable to human variables. Furthermore, the Management Information System facilitates the integration of data across multiple divisions within the organization. Data that was once dispersed across many units can now be accessible centrally and effortlessly. The elevated accessibility of this information facilitates expedited and more responsive decision-making, as the requisite data is available in real-time and with precision. The use of a Management Information System enhances the efficiency of internal communication. This system enhances interdepartmental and employee communication, hence optimizing collaboration and coordination in job completion. An uninterrupted flow of information facilitates more efficient and expedited resolution of operational challenges. Management Information Systems enhance the quality of decision-making. The Management Information System generates data that may be evaluated to yield pertinent and precise information. This information underpins more precise decision-making on business strategy and resource allocation. The enhancement of customer service can be achieved through the adoption of a Management Information System. Management of order monitoring, shipping tracking, and prompt replies to client inquiries has been streamlined. This improves client satisfaction and loyalty. The Management Information System ultimately improves resource management efficiency. Inventory, labor, and finances can be effectively administered to mitigate waste and optimize resource utilization. Management Information Systems profoundly impact the operational performance and efficiency of enterprises. Management Information Systems augment organizational efficiency and effectiveness through automation, data integration, enhanced communication, and decision-making support.
4.1.5. Enhancement in Productivity
Management Information Systems (MIS) help to greatly increase worker output. Through easy access to relevant data, MIS improves staff effectiveness. Workers no longer have to set aside time to search numerous sources or wait for data from another division. Additionally automated tedious and time-consuming tasks such data entry and report production are MIS can handle. This helps employees to focus on more strategic and value-adding chores. Therefore, MIS not only increases personal effectiveness but also helps to generalize the improvement of corporate production.
4.1.6. Decrease in Operational Expenditures
The adoption of Management information systems (MIS) can assist enterprises in minimizing operational expenses. Cost savings can be realized through the implementation of MIS in several ways, including the reduction of labor costs via the automation of business processes, which diminishes the necessity for manual labor in administrative tasks; the decrease of inventory costs through enhanced inventory management, thereby lowering storage expenses and losses from expiration or damage; the reduction of communication costs by streamlining interactions between departments and external entities, thus decreasing expenses related to phone, fax, and business travel; and the prevention of errors by enhancing data accuracy and process automation, thereby minimizing mistakes that could lead to additional costs.
4.1.7 Improving the Rate of Decision-Making
Management information systems (MIS) provide the quick and exact decision-making process that manager’s use. The management information system (MIS) provides easy access to relevant data from many departments for management's needs, includes MISulation features that enable management to forecast the consequences of various decisions prior to implementation, and helps real-time data analysis to identify trends and patterns for informed responses.
This ability allows management to make more informed, precise, and rapid decisions, thereby improving the organization's agility in responding to market fluctuations.
4.1.8. Enhancing Communication and Interaction
Management information systems facilitate communication and collaboration among divisions. By integrating data and business processes across various departments, MIS enhances information transparency, integrates departmental activities to reduce conflicts and enhance productivity, and facilitates the efficient exchange of information among various departments. As a result, it facilitates the organization's performance evaluation and monitoring. By improving communication and engagement, Management Information Systems (MIS) cultivate a more efficient and collaborative work environment.
Discussion
The results of this document analysis show that the economic status of companies is significantly influenced by the use of information technology-more especially, Management Information Systems (MIS). Management information systems not only change the relative cost of capital but also influence the expenses related with the information itself.
Management information systems can be considered as a factor of production capable of substituting for conventional labor and capital. As the cost of information technology keeps declining, management information systems are progressively replacing the responsibilities of labor, especially at the level of middle managers and administrative staff. This implies that the company can simplify its organizational structure and reduce the staff count without sacrificing the degree of output the company can offer.
Management information systems are among other elements influencing transaction expenses. The transaction cost hypothesis holds that companies run with the intention of lowering the costs incurred during the process of trading products and services with outside parties. Businesses have achieved this historically by means of vertical integration, more especially through supplier and distributor acquisition. Conversely, management information systems-especially with the advent of the internet-allow companies to choose to deal with outside vendors and reduce the costs related with market participation.
Management data systems also affect the agency's expenses. Agency theory helps one to see a company as an assembly of agreements between people with different interests. The owner of the company, the main, assigns workers, who are agents, to help with chores. Conversely, agents must be under supervision and control if we are to ensure that their interests coincide with those of the principal. Easy monitoring made possible by management information systems helps the business to reduce the expenses of the outside agency.
Based on the results of this document analysis, management information systems could, among other things, replace conventional labor, cut transaction costs, and lower agency expenses so improving the financial efficiency of companies. This is in line with the results showing companies often cut the size of their companies while yet spending more in information technology. This study also emphasizes, nonetheless, the significance of considering organizational and behavioral aspects in the application of management information systems. This is so because the success of information technology investments could be hampered by opposition to change.
Conclusion
Organizations must maintain their adaptability in order to capitalize on emerging IT innovations, particularly those associated with Management Information Systems, in order to flourish in the evolving digital landscape. Management Information Systems have played a substantial role in enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of corporate operations. Management information systems help to automate different corporate operations, therefore lowering the demand for human involvement and the possibility of mistakes. By freeing workers to focus on more critical tasks, this automation helps to save labour as well as money.
Furthermore, MIS facilitates the integration of data across departments, thereby enhancing the accessibility of information and facilitating the process of making decisions that are both accurate and timely. When data is centralized and readily accessible, management can respond to market fluctuations in real time. MIS facilitates the connection of various departments and individuals within a more collaborative working environment, which is another way in which it contributes to the improvement of internal communication.
MIS contributes to the reduction of transaction and agency costs from an economic perspective. Using information technology helps the company to improve its efficiency, cut the management count, and simplify its organizational framework. Still, it is important to keep in mind that using MIS presents certain difficulties. Resistance to change is likely to develop since MIS can alter pre-existing systems, cultures, and business practices.
Notwithstanding this, MIS cards are quite essential in the digital age of business. By means of MIS, companies can improve their efficiency, effectiveness, and competitiveness in a market growing in dynamic nature.
References
- Fajrillah F, Muda I, Sugianto S, Soemitra A and Purnami S. Implementation of Online Payment as a Transaction Solution in the Digital Era: A Comparative Study between QRIS GOPAY, and SHOPEEPAY. Int J Recent Eng Sci 2024; 11: 41-45.
- Tarmizi HB, Muda I and Lubis A. Factors Affecting the Value Chain of Asset Management and Village Boundaries in the Digital Age in Indonesia. Turkish Online Journal of Qualitative Inquiry. 2021; 12: 3758-3771.
- Santosh K, Prakash MPR, Abhang L, Muda I, Banerjee DD, Mary DSSCR et al. Analytic Hierarchy Process-Based Evaluation Approach for Digital Technology Service Management. J Theo App Info Tech. 2023; 101: 8407-8422.
- Amelia S and Bunga DA. Universitas Koperasi Indonesia. Pengaruh sistem informasi manajemen terhadap kualitas kinerja karyawan. In Nautical?: Jurnal Ilmiah Multidisiplin. 2022; 1-4: 208.
- Abdul H, Nasution and Padli MI. Analisis Dampak Implementasi Sistem Informasi Manajemen Pada Efisiensi Proses Bisnis. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Dan Manajemen. 2024; 2: 101-107.
- Laudon KC and Laudon JP. Management Information Systems: Managing the Digital Firm (Fifteenth). Pearson Education Limited. 2018.
- Wijoyo A, Ichsani D, Chotimah IN, Pratama Affia N, Anggana N, Bisnis Manajemen SDM et al. Universitas Pamulang Tangerang Selatan Indonesia PENGARUH SISTEM INFORMASI TERHADAP EFISIENSI OPERASIONAL PERUSAHAAN. TEKNOBIS?: Jurnal Teknologi. Bisnis Dan Pendidikan. 2023; 1: 1-8.
- Yusro Macam-Macam Metode Penelitian. 2021; 10.