A Relationship between Palestinian Refugee Children and Sad and Stress after the 7OCT 2023 War: A Longitudinal Study
Abdelrahman Alitr
Published on: 2024-12-20
Abstract
This study aimed to examine the prevalence of stress and sadness among Palestinian children who endured the trauma of the October 7, 2023 war, and to investigate the relationship between trauma-related factors and PTSD symptoms. The sample consisted of 500 children aged 4 to 17 years. Several tools were employed in the study, including the Rutter A2 (parent) and B2 (teacher) scales, the Gaza Traumatic Event Checklist, and the Child Post-Traumatic Stress Reaction Index. Findings revealed that 145 children (50%) exhibited at least mild PTSD reactions, while 350 children (94%) experienced moderate to severe PTSD symptoms. On the Rutter A2 scale, 50 children (26.8%) were identified as "cases," showing a strong association with PTSD reactions, though this was not mirrored in teacher-reported cases. The total number of traumatic events experienced emerged as the most significant predictor of both the presence and severity of PTSD symptoms. The study underscores the urgent need for intervention programs tailored to children affected by war, taking into account their developmental, cultural, and community-specific needs, and highlights the importance of thoroughly evaluating these programs.
Keywords
Sadness; Palestinian children; Stress; Gaza; 7OCT 2023Introduction
This paper examines the stress experienced by Palestinian internally displaced refugee youth, aged 4 to 17, residing in the occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank. These internally displaced persons (IDPs) have been confined to camps since the establishment of Israel, which forced entire communities from their ancestral lands. Over six decades, these camps have witnessed population growth under conditions of scarce resources and limited land. Camp residents suffer from a severe lack of essential services, including clean water, adequate shelter, safe recreational spaces, and educational facilities (UNRWA, n.d.-a).
Palestinian refugee children in IDP camps are particularly vulnerable to trauma, abuse, and social isolation. These children often experience traumatic events like targeted violence, physical and sexual assault, and neglect, which can lead to severe mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, and difficulty forming friendships, academic struggles, and emotional disorders. The social stigma these children face within their communities further exacerbates their suffering. Caregivers and service providers, many of whom have also experienced trauma, often find it challenging to provide adequate psychological and emotional support.
Palestinian children and adolescents in Gaza and the West Bank are particularly vulnerable to mental health problems, such as PTSD, depression, and generalized anxiety disorder. PTSD, in particular, is closely linked to feelings of sadness and hopelessness. The ongoing political conflict and threats within refugee camps increase the risk of physical, emotional, and cognitive developmental problems. Research shows that refugee children are disproportionately affected by severe depression, anxiety, and PTSD.
Sack et al. (1996) suggest that while earlier refugee experiences can lead to PTSD, feelings of sadness are more strongly linked to stressful events occurring after migration, especially in refugee camps. As all Palestinian children born in the camps are considered post-migration, they are particularly vulnerable to psychological distress due to inadequate services, unemployment, and lack of hope, discrimination, and loneliness. Given their prolonged exposure to violence and instability, Palestinian children are at significant risk of developing PTSD, anxiety, depression, sadness, and other emotional disorders.
Research shows that trauma has a significant impact on Palestinian children in IDP camps. Thabit and Vostanis (2017) found that refugee parents experienced an average of 8.42 traumatic events, with 60% showing signs of PTSD and 26.5% suffering from anxiety. Children experienced an average of 7.88 traumatic events, with 70.1% exhibiting PTSD, 33.9% experiencing anxiety, and 42.7% presenting general psychological issues as reported by their parents.
The Study
This study seeks to examine the experiences of Palestinian refugee children living in internally displaced persons (IDP) camps in Palestine, with a particular focus on their emotional and psychological challenges, including stress, sadness, and hope for the future. Despite the ongoing traumatic conditions they endure, little attention has been given to how these children perceive their experiences and how such perceptions shape their emotional well-being and outlook on life.
The Study Addresses Three Key Research Questions:
- What are the experiences of Palestinian refugee children living in IDP camps under occupation, including the feelings and thoughts accompanying their daily life events (both traumatic and non-traumatic)?
This question aims to explore the psychological and emotional landscape of Palestinian refugee children, focusing on their responses to daily stressors and challenges. It delves into their emotional reactions to traumatic events, such as exposure to violence, as well as to routine, non-traumatic events. By examining these experiences, the study seeks to provide a comprehensive understanding of their well-being and how they process the circumstances of their daily lives.
- How does the third generation of Palestinian youth born in displaced camps create and sustain hope for the future? To what extent do traumatic experiences faced by Palestinian refugees affect their perception of hope and the possibility of a positive future?
This question explores the intergenerational impact of trauma on Palestinian youth born in the camps. It seeks to understand how these children, as the third generation living in displacement, can cultivate and maintain hope amidst adversity. Furthermore, it examines whether exposure to trauma and ongoing conflict diminishes their ability to envision a positive and hopeful future.
- What factors contribute to the perception of sadness among Palestinian youth residing in IDP camps in the West Bank?
This question focuses on identifying the specific causes of sadness among Palestinian youth in IDP camps. Factors may include prolonged exposure to violence, uncertain futures, limited access to education and employment, and the broader socio-political environment. By understanding these contributors, the study aims to highlight key areas where interventions are needed to support the emotional and psychological well-being of these youth.
The findings from this study are expected to offer valuable insights into the unique challenges faced by Palestinian refugee children in IDP camps. These insights could guide the development of targeted interventions to foster emotional resilience, enhance well-being, and nurture hope for a brighter future among this vulnerable population.
Method
Study Participants
Sample Size and Demographics: The study included a total of 500 Palestinian youth aged between 4 and 17 years old. These participants were drawn from both the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Regional Distribution
- West Bank: 300 participants
- Gaza Strip: 200 participants
Gender Distribution
- Female: 2,000 participants
- Male: 1,000 participants
Age Distribution
- Male Mean Age: 12 years (SD = 0.75)
- Female Mean Age: 11 years (SD = 0.75)
Participant Eligibility: To Be Included In The Study, Participants Were Required To
- Reside in UNRWA-managed refugee camps in Palestine.
- Be fluent in Arabic, both written and spoken.
This demographic information provides a solid foundation for understanding the specific context and experiences of the study's participants, particularly their exposure to ongoing conflict and displacement.
Research Methods and Ethical Considerations
Data Collection: Semi-Structured Interviews
The study employed semi-structured interviews as the primary data collection method. These interviews were conducted in Arabic by native speakers to ensure cultural sensitivity and accurate communication.
Participant Selection: Targeted Population: Palestinian children residing in five different IDP camps.
Recruitment Process
Initial Briefing:
- The research team briefed the activities committees in the camps about the study's objectives and purpose.
- Participant Selection: Potential participants were selected based on specific age and literacy criteria.
- Informed Consent: Participants were informed about the study and their right to withdraw at any time.
Interview Focus
Emotional Experiences: The interviews delved into the children's emotional experiences, specifically focusing on feelings of happiness, sadness, and hope.
Contextual Factors: The interviews explored how these emotions were influenced by the context of living in Palestinian IDP camps.
Ethical Considerations
IRB Approval: The study was reviewed and approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Mansoura University.
Informed Consent: Participants were provided with detailed information about the study and their rights.
Confidentiality: Participant confidentiality was strictly maintained throughout the research process.
Emotional Support: A licensed mental health professional was present during the interviews to provide support if needed.
Referral Services: Participants were informed about available mental health services.
By adhering to these ethical principles, the researchers ensured the well-being of the participants and the integrity of the research.
Data Analysis Methodology
The researchers employed a thematic content analysis (TCA) approach to analyze the transcribed interview data. This method involved a systematic process of identifying, analyzing, and interpreting patterns within the text.
Key Steps In the Analysis
Open Coding:
- Researchers carefully examined the transcripts, identifying initial codes or themes related to happiness, sadness, and hope.
- These codes were derived directly from the participants' responses, ensuring a data-driven approach.
Organizing Themes:
- The identified codes were then organized into broader categories and sub-codes, forming a hierarchical structure.
- This step involved grouping similar codes and identifying relationships between them.
Inter-Rater Reliability:
- A panel of five judges reviewed the categories and sub-codes to ensure consistency and accuracy.
- This process helped to minimize bias and improve the reliability of the findings.
Software Analysis:
- MAXQDA 18 software was utilized to facilitate the coding and management of the qualitative data.
- This software tool aided in organizing, searching, and analyzing the large volume of textual data.
By following these steps, the researchers were able to delve deep into the emotional experiences of Palestinian children living in refugee camps, uncovering valuable insights into their hopes, fears, and aspirations.
Results
Factors Contributing to Sadness among Palestinian Refugee Children
The study identified several key factors that contribute to the sadness experienced by Palestinian refugee children living in IDP camps:
Loss and Trauma
- Grief and Loss: Many children expressed sadness due to the loss of loved ones, such as family members who were arrested, displaced, or killed.
- Traumatic Experiences: Exposure to violence, conflict, and displacement can have a profound impact on children's mental health, leading to feelings of sadness, anxiety, and fear.
Lack of Space and Shelter
- Overcrowding: Living in overcrowded conditions can lead to feelings of claustrophobia and stress.
- Substandard Living Conditions: Poor housing conditions, lack of privacy, and inadequate sanitation can contribute to emotional distress.
Impact of Occupation
- Restrictions on Freedom: The ongoing occupation limits the freedom and movement of Palestinian children, leading to feelings of frustration and hopelessness.
- Violence and Insecurity: Exposure to violence, military raids, and settler attacks can cause significant trauma and fear.
Inadequate Educational Facilities
Overcrowded Classrooms: Large class sizes and lack of resources can hinder learning and create a stressful environment.
Poor Infrastructure: Inadequate school facilities, such as lack of playgrounds and proper sanitation, can negatively impact children's well-being.
These factors collectively contribute to the emotional distress experienced by Palestinian refugee children. Addressing these issues through psychological support, improved living conditions, and a peaceful resolution to the conflict is crucial for their mental health and overall well-being.
Summary
The study highlights that Palestinian refugee children in camps experience sadness due to a combination of external factors, such as ongoing occupation and lack of resources, and personal traumatic experiences, such as loss and displacement. Their emotional distress is further exacerbated by poor living conditions and limited access to quality education, which restricts their opportunities for personal growth and happiness. These findings underline the need for targeted interventions to address both the psychological and environmental challenges these children face in refugee camps.
Discussion
This study offers a unique and valuable contribution to the field of child psychology and trauma studies. By focusing on children who are still actively experiencing war and conflict, it provides a clearer picture of the immediate psychological impact of such experiences.
Key Contributions of the Study Include
Addressing a Research Gap: The study fills a significant gap in the literature by examining the psychological effects of war on children during active conflict, rather than solely focusing on post-war periods.
Unique Perspective: By studying children who are still directly exposed to trauma, the research offers a distinct perspective on the immediate and long-term consequences of war-related stress.
Identifying Key Factors: The study helps to identify the specific factors that contribute to the psychological distress of children in conflict zones, such as exposure to violence, loss, and uncertainty.
Informing Intervention Strategies: The findings of the study can inform the development of targeted interventions and support services for children in conflict-affected areas. By understanding the specific needs of these children, it is possible to design effective programs to promote their mental health and well-being.
Overall, this study provides crucial insights into the psychological experiences of children in war-torn regions. It underscores the importance of addressing the immediate needs of these children and developing long-term support systems to help them recover from the trauma of war.
Conclusions
The study underscores the significant impact of prolonged conflict and displacement on the mental health of Palestinian children in Gaza and the West Bank. Exposure to persistent violence and trauma increases their vulnerability to developing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depressive disorders.
Key Findings
- Complex Relationship between Trauma and PTSD: While trauma is a significant risk factor, it is not a sole determinant of PTSD. Individual resilience, coping mechanisms, social support, and genetic factors also play a crucial role.
- Co-Occurrence of PTSD and Depression: PTSD and depression often coexist in these children, potentially exacerbating their emotional and behavioral challenges.
- Implications for Future Research:
- Understanding the Interplay between PTSD and Depression: Future research should delve deeper into the complex relationship between PTSD and depression in this population.
- Identifying Protective Factors: Exploring factors that promote resilience and mitigate the impact of trauma is essential.
- Developing Effective Interventions: The findings can inform the development of culturally sensitive and evidence-based interventions to address the specific needs of Palestinian children.
By addressing the psychological needs of these children, we can help them overcome the trauma of war and build a brighter future.
References
- AAlvarez M, El-astel S, Fernandez J, Gutierrez M, Hemaid F, Manzanero A, et al. Between happiness and sorrow: phenomenal characteristics of autobiographical memories concerning war episodes and positive events in the Gaza Strip. Memory Studies. 2018; 1-15.
- Abed Y, Thabet A, Vostanis P. Comorbidity of PTSD and depression among refugee children during war conflict. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction. 2004; 45: 533-542.
- Abuelaish L, Agbaria Q, Hamama L, Ronen T, Rosenbaum M. Predictors of aggression among Palestinians in Israel and Gaza: happiness, need to belong, and self-control. Children and Youth Services Review. 2013; 35: 47-55.
- Alduraidi H, Waters C. Depression, perceived health, and right-of-return hopefulness of Palestinian refugees. J Nursing Scholarship. 2017; 50: 163-171.
- Anagnostopoulos D. Prevalence of war-related adverse events, depression and anxiety among Syrian refugee children settled in Turkey. European Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 2018; 27: 1513-1517.
- Antenucci S, Cavazzoni F, Veronese G. Narrating hope and resistance: a critical analysis of sources of agency among Palestinian children living under military violence. Child: Care, Health and Development. 2018; 44: 1-8.
- Atallah D. A community-based qualitative study of intergenerational resilience with Palestinian refugee families facing structural violence and historical trauma. Transcultural Psychiatry. 2017; 1-27.
- Baubet T, Casas G, Espie E, Gaboulaud V, Grais R, Mouchenik Y, et al. Trauma related psychological disorders among Palestinian children and adults in Gaza and West bank. Int J Mental Health Systems. 2009; 2005-2008.
- Biswas-Diener R, Dean B. Positive psychology coaching: putting the science of happiness to work for your clients. Hoboken: Wiley. Carr A. Positive psychology: the science of happiness and human strength. New York: Hove and Brunner Routledge. 2007.
- Fredrickson BL, Tugade MM, Waugh CE, Larkin GR. What good are positive emotions in crisis?. A prospective study of resilience and emotions following the terrorist attacks on the United States on September 11th, 2001. J Personality and Social Psychology. 2003; 84: 365-376.
- Gable SL, Haidt J. What (and why) is positive psychology? Review of General Psychology. 2005; 9: 103-110.
- Giacaman R, Rabia Y, Saleh M. Sick or sad? Supporting Palestinian children living in conditions of chronic political violence. Children and Society. 2014; 28: 172-181.
- Goodman JH. Coping with trauma and hardship among unaccompanied refugee youths from Sudan. Qualitative Health Research. 2004; 14: 77-96.
- Gusler S, Jackson Y, Stone G, Vossoughi N. Mental health outcomes for youth living in refugee camps: a review. Trauma, Violence, and Abuse. 2018; 19: 528-542.
- Hardgrove A. Liberian refugee families in Ghana: the implications of family demands and capabilities for return to Liberia. J Refugee Studies. 2009; 22: 483-501.
- Heptinstall E, Sethna V, Taylor E. PTSD and depression in refugee children associations with premigration trauma and post-migration stress. European Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 2004; 13: 373-380.
- Hosin A. Children of traumatized and exiled refugee families: resilience and vulnerability a case study report. Medicine, Conflict and Survival. 2001; 17: 137-145.
- Hutchinson A, OLeary PJ, Squire J, Hope K. Child protection in Islamic contexts: identifying cultural and religious appropriate mechanisms and processes using a roundtable methodology. Child Abuse Review. 2014; 24: 395-408.
- Jackson K. Hope for the future. London: Paperback Press. Keyes CL, Ryff CD. Subjective change and mental health: a self-concept theory. Social Psychology Quarterly. 2018; 63: 264-279.
- Khamis V. Coping with war trauma and psychological distress among school-age Palestinian children. 2015.
- Lareson D, Yohani S. Hope lives in the heart: refugee and immigrant children’s perceptions of hope and hope-engendering sources during early years of adjustment. American J Orthopsychiatry. 2009; 85: 72-79.
- Luster T, Qin D, Bates L, Johnson D, Rana M. The lost boys of Sudan: coping with ambiguous loss and separation from parents. Canadian J Counselling. 2009; 43: 246-264.
- Maager E, Sunde T. What makes me happy, and what makes me scared. An analysis of drawings made by Norwegian and Palestinian children. American J Orthopsychiatry. 2016; 79: 203-211.
- Marshall D. ‘All the beautiful things’: trauma, aesthetics and the politics of Palestinian childhood. Space and Polity. 2012; 17: 53-73.