Dominance And Obedience in Japanese School Sports Clubs: A Bourdieusian Analysis of Sports-Oriented Habitus and Masculine Domination

Kataoak A

Published on: 2025-12-07

Abstract

This article examines a paradox of Japanese school sport: although corporal punishment is officially banned and Japan enjoys international success, many junior high, high school, and university athletes still accept violent coaching and excessive sanctions as “normal.” Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu’s concepts of habitus and field, combined with Michel Foucault’s notion of disciplinary power, the article conceptualizes school sports clubs (bukatsu) as cultural apparatuses that corporealize obedience while preserving masculine desires for domination.

A mixed-methods design is employed. Questionnaire data from 383 undergraduates at five universities are used to examine how students classify themselves into “student types” such as “sports-oriented” and “otaku,” and how these classifications are associated with values and attitudes. The survey shows that sports-oriented male students constitute a sizable group and, compared with otaku, subcultural, and other types, are more likely to endorse gendered division of labor, authoritarianism, traditionalism, leadership, and victory supremacism.

Semi-structured interviews with ten club members (eight men, two women) then clarify the content and reproduction of this habitus. Analysis identifies four recurring sources of “unreasonableness”: arbitrary coaching and corporal punishment; collective responsibility and group sanctions; informal violence and intimidation by seniors; and dense club and school rules extending to speech, appearance, and private life. Adaptation to these conditions is interpreted not as simple internalization, but as oriented toward three perceived “profits”: deferred authority over juniors, a personal growth narrative of “overcoming hardship,” and anticipated advantages in education and employment. Together, these mechanisms foster a form of pseudo-autonomy in which self-discipline is produced under surveillance and does not readily translate into independent life plans beyond sport.

The article argues that, as long as victory supremacism, seniority, and closed homosocial networks remain central to school sport, Japanese clubs will continue to reproduce a configuration of subordination and masculine domination, raising unresolved questions for gender equality and safeguarding in youth sport.