A Brief Session of Progressive Muscle Relaxation is No Better than Quiet Time for Improving Emotional State in College Athletes

Vento KA, Vargas TM, Madrigal L and Schick EE

Published on: 2021-10-25

Abstract

The present study examined the immediate effects of a brief 20-minute session of progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) concerning perceived emotion, stress, and fatigue among athletes. Collegiate and club athletes from a Division I University (N = 30) completed two surveys, including a demographics questionnaire and the Subjective Exercise Experience Scale (SEES). Athletes were randomly assigned into two groups and asked to partake in a 20-minute coping method either in an active (PMR, n = 14) or passive (quiet time, n = 15) relaxation session. The SEES was given as a pre-and post-assessment to examine the effectiveness of PMR. Results revealed no significant differences between emotion and fatigue changes for the PMR and quiet time groups, except for stress (p < 0.05). PMR and quiet time had significant changes from baseline to post-intervention scores; stress and fatigue scores decreased, and positive emotional state increased. Athletes and non-athletes can utilize PMR and quiet time as easy and quick tools to regain emotional stability before a performance.

Keywords

Sports psychology; Mental health; Coping; Emotions; Well-being

Introduction

A Brief Session of Progressive Muscle Relaxation is No Better than Quiet Time for Improving Emotional State in College Athletes the emotional states of collegiate athletes are subject to daily stressors, including academics, relationships, self-expectations, sports training, injuries, coaches, and exhaustion [1-3]. Emotions are short-lived feelings involving physiological and psychological changes due to a known event. They may include feelings of joy, sadness, and anger, experienced with a range of intensity 4. Physical changes may be seen in one’s facial expressions and actions or hidden via the autonomic nervous system. Decision-making and reasoning may also be affected by heightened emotions[4]. Awareness of emotional state is essential not only for athletes' health but also for performing well, on and off the field, as too little or too much emotion may be harmful[5]. Athletes can utilize relaxation skills to help regulate emotions to be at their optimal level, which includes active (e.g., yoga, imagery, and breathing exercises) and passive (e.g., quiet time, lying down, and reading) methods of relaxation[6]. A variety of techniques to control emotions are utilized in the sports environment, including self-talk, imagery, meditation, music, goal setting, and breathing exercises[7, 8]. One particular active relaxation skill is progressive muscle relaxation (PMR), which involves contracting and loosening targeted muscles in the body, stimulating a reduction of stress hormones and lowering blood pressure[8-10].  PMR helps an individual become aware of tension in the body and teaches that diminishing it welcomes a calming effect. PMR has been used in a variety of sports, including soccer[11], football[12] and volleyball[13]. Most studies have focused on the effects of PMR related to sport participation in terms of mood state (i.e., long-lasting generalized state of positivity or negativity with a single unknown event), competition anxiety (i.e., nervousness related to competition), and pain threshold (i.e., perceived pain experienced). [13] studied the effects of 12 PMR  sessions on adolescent soccer players' mood states 11. These sessions were given three times a week for four weeks and lasted 30 minutes each. Although the study did not find changes in positive mood states, the authors reported reductions in the negative subscales of depression, fatigue, confusion, and tension[11]. Also, Jaworska. [14] investigated the effects of eight PMR sessions on football athletes' pain threshold[12]. They found athletes were able to endure pressure significantly longer than those who did not receive PMR. Furthermore, competition anxiety levels may be influenced by PMR. Six weeks of PMR, three times per week, successfully reduced competitive state anxiety in male volleyball players[13]. Still, research examining the immediate effects of PMR on athlete’s emotional state is amiss. According to the Relaxation Response, reductions in blood pressure, breathing, heart rate, and perceived stress and anxiety levels are witnessed between 10-20 minutes of practicing a coping method[14, 15]. The Relaxation Response works to counteract the adverse physiological effects of the fight-or-flight response of daily stressors by engaging in techniques that relax one’s mind and body[14, 15].Thus, it is plausible a 20-minute singular PMR session could elicit physiological benefits and support emotional stability. The stressors for collegiate athletes are numerous, and it is in their best interest to manage these stressors impacting emotional state before practice and competition. Methods must be readily available to address athletes’ emotional health. Examining a single PMR session's effectiveness helps assess this tool's viability for athletes’ emotional state efficiently and effectively. With a void in the literature investigating a single session of PMR on emotional state, the purpose of this study was to examine the immediate effects of a single session of PMR on the emotional state, stress, and fatigue levels in collegiate and club athletes. Since PMR is an active form of relaxation, we deemed it prudent to compare its effects to a passive form of relaxation. We hypothesized that 1) the active (i.e., PMR) and passive (i.e., quiet time) groups would not be statistically different at baseline emotional state, stress, and fatigue scores, 2) PMR and quiet time would significantly improve emotional state and decrease stress and fatigue scores, and 3) PMR would have considerably more significant positive changes in emotional state, stress and fatigue scores compared with the quiet time group. A control group doing nothing was deemed inappropriate as this did not translate into an applied setting, and therefore, a quasi-experimental design was implemented.

Materials And Methods

Participants  

Participants included male (n = 9) and female (n = 21) collegiate NCAA Division I and club athletes from a university between the ages of 18 to 25 years old (M = 20, SD = 1.61) from all class standings including seniors (n = 8), juniors (n = 9), sophomores (n =  7) and freshmen (n = 6). The sports athletes participated in included rowing (n = 3), track  and field (n = 9), cross-country (n = 8), volleyball (n = 1), softball (n = 1), water polo (n =  3), golf (n = 2), soccer (n = 1) and hockey (n = 2). Two groups were formed randomly via  dice roll prior to beginning the study into the PMR condition and quiet time condition. Data collection took place between September 2016 and February 2017. One participant’s data was dismissed due to current PMR usage. Specific demographic and baseline sport  information for each group is shown in Table 1.

Table 1: Athlete characteristics and SEES scores per relaxation condition.

 

PMR Condition (n = 15)

Passive Condition (n = 15)

n  Percentage(%)

Gender

   

Male

3 (20)

6 (30)

Female

12 (80)

9 (60)

Relationship status

   

Single

8 (53)

9 (60)

Relationship

7 (47)

6 (60)

School Year

   

Freshman

3 (20)

3 (20)

Sophomore

3 (20)

4 (27)

Junior

3 (20)

6 (30)

Senior

6 (40)

2 (13)

Race/ethnicity

   

White

7 (47)

8 (53)

Hispanic/Latino

2 (13)

4 (27)

Black/African American

3 (20)

3 (20)

Asian/Pacific Islander

2 (13)

0 (0)

Other

1 (7)

0 (0)

 

mean±SD

Grade point average

3.22±0.46

3.23±0.43

Length on team

2.40±1.20

1.93±0.93

Length playing sports

11.27±4.39

12.50±3.91

Age

20.00±1.15

20.00±1.97

 

PMR Condition (n = 15)

Passive Condition (n = 14)

 

median (IQR)

SEES

Pre                      Post

Pre                        Post

Emotional Statea

4.25 (2.25)           5.00 (3.25)*

4.00 (4.75)             5.00 (3.50)*

Stressb

1.75 (1.75)           1.00 (0.50)*

2.25 (3.25)            1.25 (3.00)*

Fatiguec

4.63 (5.75)           2.38 (3.75)**

4.75 (4.00)             3.25 (3.00)**

Measures

Subjective Exercise Experience Scale: Subjective Exercise Experience Scale (SEES) measures subjective well-being (i.e., emotional state for this study), stress, and fatigue consisting of a list of four items for each subscale (1 minute) [16]. A Likert-type scaling from 0 (not at all) to 7 (entirely) is used to rate statements such as ‘terrific,’ ‘crummy’ and ‘tired.’ All subscales demonstrate strong internal consistency ranging from 0.84 to 0.92. The purpose of this scale was to determine the intensity of the statement participants agree with currently[16]. This study found Cronbach’s alpha for each subscale to be: 0.79 for the emotional state, 0.50  for stress and 0.84 for fatigue on the pre-test scores and 0.78 for the emotional state, 0.83  for stress, and 0.82 for fatigue on the post-test scores. The SEES was chosen because of its validation against college undergraduate students, previous use of examining a single session of PMR within a clinical setting[10], and ease of transferability within the sports environment. To score the SEES, a sum for each of the three factors was calculated by combining the athlete's Likert scale representation.

Personal characteristics questionnaire: Age, gender, relationship status, race/ethnicity, and class were garnered (3 minutes). Participants were asked to report their sport and length of time on the team. The number of years playing sports and other sports played were documented. The current stress state (i.e., yes or no) and previous PMR exposure (i.e., yes or no) and utilization (i.e., yes or no) were questioned.

Conditions

Passive condition: Athletes assigned into the quiet time group (n = 15) were to sit or lay down quietly for 20 minutes with their eyes closed. The session took place in the sport psychology laboratory, with the researcher remaining in the room. Reading materials, phones, or other electronic devices were not permitted during this time. The lead investigator instructed athletes to refrain from sleeping and reflecting on negative past, current, or future instances.

PMR condition: Athletes assigned to the PMR group (n = 14) received a 20-minute session. Individually, participants were guided through a scripted PMR session by the lead investigator. The lead investigator received PMR training from a Certified Mental Performance Consultant and conducted several sessions (altogether approximately eight hours of PMR) with athletes and non-athletes. The session took place in a private area in the sport psychology laboratory. Individuals had the option of lying down on a yoga mat or sitting in a chair. The PMR session targeted the seven major muscle groups (i.e., right hand and arm, left hand and arm,  face, shoulders and neck, chest, back and belly, right leg and left leg), tensing for five seconds and relaxing for ten seconds as suggested by McCallie, Blum, and Hood (2006)9. The relaxation recall was given for each muscle group focused, and three abdominal breaths were instructed in between muscle groups. The session started with the individual’s dominant hand and arm. To end the PMR session, backward counting from four (i.e., legs and feet, hands and arms, neck and head, and opening eyes) took place. 

Procedures

Once approved by the Institutional Review Board and Athletic Departments, athletes were recruited to participate via flyer. The study flyer was circulated via email sent by authorized athletic staff personnel to the student- and club-athletes and posted on bulletin boards within the kinesiology department and athletic, academic center. The flyer contained study information and stated it focused on coping skills to improve athletic performance; the lead investigator's contact information was provided on the flyer if athletes were interested in participating in the study. If the lead investigator had previously provided sport psychology consulting services with a prospective athlete, they could not participate in minimizing bias results. After informed consent was obtained, athletes were randomized into two groups: active PMR and passive quiet time conditions. To ensure privacy, athlete’s names were coded. The personal characteristics questionnaire and SEES were given to all groups. The personal characteristics questionnaire was completed before the intervention took place. The SEES was given immediately before and after the intervention to all participants to evaluate the effectiveness of PMR on emotional state, stress, fatigue, and variations among groups. The intervention for each group was 20 minutes. Athletes partook in the study individually, and the entire process with the intervention took 30 minutes. Based on the Relaxation Response, it was believed the 20-minute conditions were an appropriate amount of time to see changes in an emotional state 14, 15. Participating athletes received a $5.00 gift card to a coffee shop.

Statistical Analysis

Data were analyzed utilizing IBM SPSS 25. The sample size was based on access to the unique target population and availability of funding and resources within a three-month time frame. Due to a small sample size and non-normal distribution, non-parametric statistics were used. Mann–Whitney U tests were conducted to determine the intervention's significance between groups and baseline scores for the emotional state, stress, and fatigue. Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were conducted to assess baseline and post-intervention changes within groups for emotional state, stress, and fatigue scores. The statistical significance level was set at p< 0.05. The factor variables were emotional state, stress, and fatigue, and the fixed factor was the condition.

Results and Discussion

Personal Characteristics

Nineteen participants (n = 9, PMR; n = 10, quiet time) reported experiencing stress at the time. Only three participants have had previous PMR exposure, and one participant reported using PMR  as a current coping mechanism.

 

Between PMR and passive conditions

Mann–Whitney U tests were conducted in order to determine differences in  emotional state, stress and fatigue baseline scores between groups; no significant  differences were found, p > 0.05. Mann–Whitney U tests were used to examine  differences in post-score changes. Results indicated no significant differences for  emotional state (U = 99.5, p = 0.81, r = 0.04) and fatigue (U = 64, p = 0.07, r = 0.33)  scores between groups. Results indicated a significant difference for stress scores between the groups, U = 58.5, p = 0.03, r = 0.40, with quiet time having lower reductions.

Within PMR and passive conditions

Wilcoxon signed rank tests were conducted to examine the results within subjects  of the PMR and quiet time conditions. Results indicated a significant change for emotional state; PMR (Z = -2.91, p = 0.004, r = 0.78) and quiet time (Z = -2.67, p = 0.008, r = 0.6).  Results indicated a significant change for stress; PMR (Z = -3.07, p = 0.002, r = 0.82) and  quiet time (Z = -3.19, p = 0.001, r = 1.01). Results indicated a significant change for fatigue; PMR (Z = -3.30, p = 0.001, r = 0.88) and quiet time (Z = -3.34, p = 0.001, r =  0.86). The median and ranges for emotional state, stress and fatigue for the PMR and quiet time conditions can be seen in Table 1. The purpose of this study was to determine if a single brief PMR session could effectively increase positive emotional state and decrease stress and fatigue in athletes. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to examine the effectiveness of a single PMR session on athletes' emotional state; a single PMR session would provide an efficient and quick tool for athletes to use before practice or competition. Our data demonstrated that PMR and quiet time significantly increased positive emotional state and decreased stress and fatigue from baseline. Stress scores were reduced more so in the quiet time group. PMR significantly increased positive emotional state and decreased stress and fatigue scores. This is consistent with current literature as PMR was more effective than the control groups at improving positive mood state and well-being[10, 17]. PMR was also able to decrease depression and anxiety levels and hospital stay length for females recovering from mastectomies[18]. Likewise,[19] found that PMR decreased aggression, tension, and anxiety with those suffering from major depression and anxiety disorders[19]. A single brief PMR session was equally as practical as quiet time in improving emotional state and reducing stress and fatigue. However, it is reasonable to assume comparisons between PMR and other emotion regulation or stress/coping methods would also reduce stress and produce changes in emotional states. [20] conducted a literature review and identified written emotional disclosures, ‘if-then’ plans, imagery, breathing, self-talk, and mindfulness to be current emotional regulation strategies employed by athletes [20]. These techniques have been found to lessen confusion, prepare for future events impacting emotion instability, enhance self-efficacy, focus on and manage stress 20. It is suggested that athletes rehearse such mechanisms and utilize ‘if-then’ scenarios so that emotional regulation strategies will become automatic 20. We encourage future studies to continue investigating PMR with other active and passive forms of relaxation. While this study offers valuable insight into the use of a single bout of PMR as a coping method, the authors acknowledge several possible limitations. First, the sample number was limited and included both Division I and club sport athletes. Differences between the club and collegiate student-athletes (i.e., training hours, expectations, and intensities) were not analyzed due to the small sample size. Although similar in experiences, these roles hold unique responsibilities. If comparing collegiate and club athletes, these differences should be examined or matched paired. The study was conducted in a controlled laboratory with a trained researcher, and it’s recommended these factors be examined before practices or competitions. Finally, the study was quasi-experimental design; studies with more extensive funding and available resources should include a proper control condition when comparing coping method effectiveness to eliminate the impacts of extraneous variables. A major strength of this study was the ability of PMR and quiet time to lower stress and fatigue, and the results help to establish a foundation for future research and application of PMR and quiet time to improve the emotional health of athletes. Future sports psychology research should continue to explore the effectiveness of brief emotion-focused coping interventions. Given the stressors and time-demands athlete’s encounter, relaxation strategies that are quick and successful in regulating emotions will be favorably used. While the current study used 20-minute individual sessions, we encourage shorter PMR and quiet time durations and group settings to be tested to maximize efficiency. Similarly, to support the Relaxation Response, a physiological component, such as heart rate, would quantify the somatic effect of brief PMR and quiet time sessions[14-20]. It is advised for coaches and practitioners to create a space and set aside 10-20 minutes for athletes to participate in PMR or quiet time before practices and competitions, making available a guided PMR voice recording and sound-canceling headphones to initiate engagement.

Conclusion

Athletes must maintain positive emotional states to be successful during practice and competition. The present study demonstrates that a brief PMR session and quiet time can boost a positive emotional state and lower stress and fatigue. Determining PMR benefits and quiet time is best realized with education and an intervention setting that mimics practice or competition.  These findings should help expand the understanding and usage of PMR and quiet time to become a part of pre-performance routines to enhance training and competition performance. PMR and quiet time have physiological and psychological benefits and are easy to conduct and require no equipment. Most importantly, however, PMR and quiet time are tools athletes can use once their athletic career is finished and for non-athletes.

Acknowledgements

We thank the student-athletes for their participation.

Refereces

  1. Kimball A, Freysinger VJ. Leisure, stress, and coping: The sport participation of collegiate student-athletes. Leisure Sciences. 2003; 25:115-141.
  2. Lu FJH, Hsu YW, Chan YS, Cheen JR, Kao KT. Assessing college student-athletes' life stress: Initial measurement development and validation. Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science. 2012; 16: 254-267.
  3. Cosh S, Tully PJ. Stressors, coping, and support mechanisms for student athletes combining elite sport and tertiary education: Implications for practice. The Sport Psychologist. 2015; 29: 120-133
  4. Rathschlag M, Memmert D. The influence of self-generated emotions on physical performance: An investigation of happiness, anger, anxiety, and sadness. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology. 2013; 35:197-210.
  5. Hanin YL. Performance related emotional states in sport: A qualitative analysis. In Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research. 2003; 4.
  6. Urech C, Fink NS, Hoesli I, Wilhelm FH, Bitzer J. Alder J, et al. Effects of relaxation on psychobiological well-being during pregnancy: A randomized controlled trial. Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2010; 35:1348-1355.
  7. Bishop DT, Karageorghis CI. Loizou G. A grounded theory of young tennis players’ use of music to manipulate emotional state. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology. 2007; 29: 584-607.
  8. Parnabas VA, Mahamood Y, Parnabas J. Abdullah NM. The relationship between relaxation techniques and sport performance. Universal Journal of Psychology. 2014; 2: 108-112.
  9. McCallie M, Blum C. Hood C. Progressive muscle relaxation. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment. 2006; 13:51-66.
  10. Vancampfort D, Hert M, Knapen J, Maurissen K. Raepsaet J, Deckx S, at al. Effects of progressive muscle relaxation on state anxiety and subjective well-being in people with schizophrenia: A randomized controlled trial. Clinical Rehabilitation. 2011; 25: 567-575.
  11. Hashim HA, Yusof HHA. The effects of progressive muscle relaxation and autogenic relaxation on young soccer players' mood states. Asian Journal of Sports Medicine. 2011 2: 99-105.
  12. Jaworska L, Hawrylak A, Burzy?ski B. Szczepa?ska-Gieracha J. Effect of progressive muscle relaxation on pain threshold and effectiveness of footballers’ training. Human Movement. 2015; 16: 225-228.
  13. Navaneethan B. Rajan RS. Effect of progressive muscle relaxation training on competitive anxiety of male inter-collegiate volleyball players. The Shield-Research J Phys Edu & Sports Science, 5. Benson, H. (1975). The relaxation response. Morrow. 2010.
  14. Benson H, Beary JF, Carol MP. The relaxation response. Psychiatry. 1974; 37:37-46.
  15. McAuley E, Courneya, KS. The subjective exercise experiences scale (SEES): Development and preliminary validation. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology. 1994; 16, 163-177.
  16. Jain S, Shapiro SL, Swanick S, Roesch SC, Mills PJ, Bell I, et al. A randomized controlled trial of mindfulness meditation versus relaxation training: Effects on distress, positive states of mind, rumination, and distraction. Annals of Behavioral Medicine. 2007; 33:11-21.
  17. Zhou K, Li X, Li J, Liu M, Dang S, Wang D, et al. A clinical randomized controlled trial of music therapy and progressive muscle relaxation training in female breast cancer patients after radical mastectomy: Results on depression, anxiety and length of hospital stay. European Journal of Oncology Nursing. 2015;19: 54-59.
  18. Lorent L, Agorastos A, Yassouridis A, Kellner M, Muhtz C. Auricular acupuncture versus progressive muscle relaxation in patients with anxiety disorders or major depressive disorder: A prospective parallel group clinical trial. Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies. 2016; 9:191-199.
  19. Davis PA. Davis L. Emotions and emotion regulation in coaching. The psychology of effective coaching and management. Nova Science Publishers Inc. 2016.
  20. Nickel C, Kettler C, Muehlbacher M, Lahmann C, Tritt K, Fartacek, et al. Effect of progressive muscle relaxation in adolescent female bronchial asthma patients: A randomized, double-blind, controlled study. J Psy Res 2005; 59: 393-398.