Comparative Analysis of Motivation in Male and Female Fitness Athletes

Georgie K

Published on: 2024-04-16

Abstract

Motivation is part of the human condition. Depending on our goals, we are either intrinsically or extrinsically motivated. When it comes to exercise, men and women find different motivational reasons to spend more time at the gym. Fitness training is becoming increasingly popular because it is accessible to men and women of all ages. A number of studies have demonstrated the benefits of physical activity and found that it is the frequency of exercise, not the duration, that is important. Many researchers are also investigating the benefits of fitness training, as it can be innovative, with methods and means of organizing exercise aimed at maintaining and improving the level of physical condition of those involved. In our study, we are investigating the motivation of male and female gym-goers, as well as the social engagements that directly or indirectly accompany them, and their impact on their motivation.

Keywords

Motivation; Fitness; Men; Women

Introduction

Problem Statement

Public health and healthy lifestyles are a major issue in the rest of the world. According to many authors Phillips the reason why people do not attach importance to maintaining a healthy lifestyle is insufficient motivation [1,2]. This fact requires the implementation of a number of measures, ensuring the identification and creation of conditions for the realisation of motives for health activities and attracting the population to regular physical activity.

Through sport and physical activity, the body forms and builds its working capacity and defences. Lack of exercise leads to functional and structural deficiencies in the biological system [3].

Research in sport psychology on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation is based on cognitive appraisal theory and Harter's theory of self-efficacy. Based on these concepts, the authors suggest that the sense of autonomy and the perception of one's own ability to perform are of paramount importance for active participation in physical activity and sport. This understanding is based on the notion of the important role of intrinsic motivation for physical activity and exercise performance [4].

The regularity of fitness training depends on whether people find it enjoyable and satisfying. According to German researchers, exercise becomes a habit only with intrinsic motivation. The transition from external to internal stimuli involves focusing on the physical activity itself and becoming aware of the sensations associated with it. When activities match individual characteristics and needs, people derive pleasure, satisfaction and self-affirmation from the activity. This state is considered a central factor in intrinsic motivation.

Various authors refer to intrinsic motivation as the desire to perform, the display of persistence during activities, and the presence of satisfaction from this participation [5]. Vallerand and his colleagues initiated a new understanding of the nature and structures of intrinsic motivation [6,7,8]. According to them, motivation can be divided into three types:

  • Intrinsic motivation to secure knowledge;
  • Intrinsic motivation for achievement;
  • Intrinsic motivation for stimulation.

Intrinsic motivation was first identified by Harter as being directly related to perceptions of competence and locus of control. According to her, this relationship is manifested in the understanding that intrinsically motivated individuals perceive themselves as competent and responsible for both their successes and failures. They are also more effective than extrinsically motivated individuals in their pursuit of achievement [4].

The athlete's extrinsic motivation refers to all the activity in which the athlete participates, which is dictated by the pre-selection of the means and ways to achieve the goal external to him, most often defined by the coach. The different types of extrinsic motivation are, for the most part, predominantly self-determined in nature, even if the activity is not performed for personal enjoyment.

In terms of the content of the hierarchical model, propose to include the following four types of extrinsic motivation [9]:

  • Extrinsic motivation, which refers to behaviour that is regulated by such additional extrinsic means as are not only the specified extrinsic motivation induced by reward or coercion.
  • Extrinsic motivation that is self-determined by the athlete's value identification with the activity that is important to the athlete, that is of primary importance to the athlete.
  • Extrinsic motivation associated with the influence of others who are significant, socially prestigious and desirable to the individual, including, first and foremost, the coach, various managers and other officials in the sport. This group also includes parents, friends, acquaintances, fans, the general public, all those who evaluate the athlete, positively or negatively, but always critically.
  • An extrinsic motivation of unconscious objectification, which is the bearer of the fundamental traditional and popular values of sport, first of all the "pure game" (fair play).

Methods

The Sport Motivation Scale (SMS) was used to examine motivational orientations. The scale measures the characteristics of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation to participate in sport [2].

A questionnaire with 21 closed questions was developed specifically for this study. The first part of 11 questions uses a three-point scale - 1 - poor, 2 - good, 3 - excellent. The next part of 10 questions is multiple choice.

53 volunteers participated in the study, out of which (60.38%) 32 men and (39.62%) 21 women, aged 37.5+- 17.5 years, following a diet from 1 month to over 3 months and visiting a gym in Bulgaria, from 1 month to over 2 years.

Results

Study of Motivation in Trainees

The immobility of the population is a growing problem in today's modern society. With the introduction of computers, telephones, televisions, and the stagnation of the workplace, the use of transport rather than walking, people are becoming increasingly immobile and as a result are beginning to develop many other health problems. Recently, the number of overweight people has led to obesity being classified as a disease, and it is one of the leading causes of death.

Numerous studies have shown that physical activity contributes to a person's health, and this fact is undisputed. What modern scientists are looking at is how to motivate people to exercise and what motivates them to do so. In a busy, multi-tasking lifestyle, it is becoming increasingly difficult for people to find time to exercise, and scientists are finding that even 15 minutes of exercise a day over an extended period of time has a positive effect on both physical and mental health.

In our study, we looked at the extrinsic and intrinsic motivations of male and female fitness exercisers to find out whether they were intrinsically motivated to exercise, to be healthy, to have fun, to develop their other qualities through the rigours of the gym, or whether they were influenced by extrinsic motivations, such as the opinion of others, looking good for a particular occasion, the sea, etc.

When processing the data of extrinsic motivation in men and women, the data shows that women have a better extrinsic motivation 57.89%, while men show a score of 42.42%. This may be due to the fact that women do sport mainly to look good for some occasion, to create short term goals - wedding, sea, travel, etc (Figure 1).

Figure 1:  Results of "Extrinsic motivation".

Men tend to have more long-term goals, are more consistent and visit gyms more often (more than 5 times a week according to our survey). Intrinsic motivation is also related to the desire and satisfaction you feel when you exercise. Not everyone experiences intrinsic motivation, but it can change over time and the more regularly you go to the gym, the greater the intrinsic motivation. Men rate their intrinsic motivation as excellent - 69.7% (Figure 2).

Figure 2:  Results of "Intrinsic motivation".

The main negative factors influencing the decrease in motivation for fitness training are such factors as laziness, low self-esteem, fear of failure, low level of self-discipline. The key to success (beautiful figure, development of physical qualities, strengthening of health) depends not only on the training process, but also on the observance of a certain mode of behaviour (mode "sport").

Psychological-Motivational Profile of Trainees

With the following questions, we intend gaining a better idea of the profile of men and women who exercise and their interest in exercising in gyms. We want to get a deeper insight into whether they do it for themselves or for external motives.

For 40.63% of men and 35% of women, the pleasure of rediscovering new performance techniques is the only reason for exercising. 15.53% of men and 35% of women said it was often for them. In conclusion, we can say that new performance techniques are the main motive for athletes and that there are no significant differences between men and women. A small percentage of female respondents (15%) and male respondents (3.13%) were not motivated by this (Table 1) (Figure 3).

Table 1: Why do you practice Fitness.

For the pleasure of rediscovering new performance techniques

Male (%)

Female (%)

Does not apply to me at all

3,13

15

Very rarely applies to me

6,25

5

Applies to me to a small extent

6,25

5

Sometimes applies to me

25

10

Applies to me to a moderate degree

3,13

10

Often applies to me

15,63

30

Completely applies to me

40,63

35

 

 

 

Figure 3: Why do you practice fitness: For the pleasure of rediscovering new performance techniques.

In addition to developing a harmonious body, fitness training also helps develop mental qualities such as responsibility, discipline, determination, etc. The personal qualities to which it contributes are also numerous - self-knowledge, self-esteem, self-control, stress resistance and self-help, qualities and lessons for successful socialisation in the social environment. Hence the follow-up to the athletes' answers "To develop other aspects of my personality" (Table 2) (Figure 4).

Table 2: Why do you practice fitness.

Because it is one of the best ways I have chosen to develop some other aspects of my personality.

Male (%)

Famale (%)

Does not apply to me at all

0

5

Very rarely applies to me

0

0

Applies to me to a small extent

6,25

10

Sometimes applies to me

12,5

15

Applies to me to a moderate degree

15,63

10

Often applies to me

21,88

25

Completely applies to me

44,75

35

Figure 4: Because this is one of the best ways I have chosen to develop some other aspects of my personality.

Among the male respondents, 44.75% said it applied to them completely and 21.88% said it applied to them often, stating that they developed other aspects of their personality in this way. The results for women were similar, at 35% and 25% respectively. Only 5% of women did not agree with this statement.

The next two questions aim to find out about the motives for training - whether they are internal or external. The first question is about how they feel about exercising - as a duty, because they have to exercise to be healthy, or as a pleasure, because it brings harmony between a healthy mind and a healthy body.

The answers are very heterogeneous, ranging from "It applies to me to a lesser extent" - 9.38% of men and 10% of women, to "It applies to me completely" - 50% of men and 35% of women. All of them focused on the fact that they are aware that they need to exercise in order to be healthy. The remaining percentages are spread across the answers. "It applies to me very rarely" has 0% of both sexes. "Does not apply to me at all" is again 0% for women and 6.25% for men. A very small percentage of respondents do not exercise because they have to, but because they want to (Table 3) (Figure 5).

Table 3: Why do you practice fitness.

Because I have to exercise regularly

Male (%)

Famale (%)

Does not apply to me at all

6,25

0

Very rarely applies to me

0

0

Applies to me to a small extent

9,38

10

Sometimes applies to me

6,25

10

Applies to me to a moderate degree

18,75

20

Often applies to me

9,38

25

Completely applies to me

50

35

Figure 5: Because I have to exercise regularly.

The next question concerns the motives of sportsmen and women. To the statement "Because it allows me to improve myself in the eyes of my acquaintances" - "It does not apply to me at all" and "It applies to me very rarely", men answered - 46.88% / 9.38%, and women - 28.57% / 9.52%. A large percentage of respondents said that it applies to them to a lesser extent - men 21.88% and women 28.57%. Women said it applied to them 'often' and 'completely' - 9.52%, confirming that they are vainer about their appearance and what others think of them [10]. For men, the results were lower - 6.25% / 3.13% (Table 4) (Figure 6).

Table 4: Why do you practice fitness.

Because it allows me to rise in the eyes of my acquaintances

Male (%)

Famale (%)

Does not apply to me at all

46,88

28,57

Very rarely applies to me

9,38

9,52

Applies to me to a small extent

21,88

28,57

Sometimes applies to me

9,38

4,76

Applies to me to a moderate degree

3,13

4,76

Often applies to me

6,25

9,52

Completely applies to me

3,13

9,52

Figure 6:  Because it allows me to rise in the eyes of my acquaintances.

By identifying the profile of male and female fitness professionals, we aim to learn about their differences and similarities in practice and the use of different methods to motivate and train athletes for a better and healthier lifestyle.

Conclusions

  • Women's fitness training is extrinsically motivated, driven by other people's perceptions of their body and appearance.
  • Men have greater intrinsic motivation, developed over time through regular exercise (more than 5 times a week).
  • The main motivation for both men and women to exercise is the discovery of new exercise techniques.
  • Athletes want to develop other personality traits through training, such as self-knowledge, self-esteem, self-control, stress resistance, self-help, qualities necessary for building their social life and their development.

References

  1. ?h??o???? ?. ??????? ??????? ?? ???????????? ????????? ????????? ? ???????? ?????????? ????????? /? ????????: ?????????? ?????????? ? ???????????? ????? ??????? ????????? ????????? ???????????? ???????????? ??????-???????????? ???????????. ??? ????????? ?.?. ???????????? ?. 2017; 121-126.
  2. Pelletier LG, Tuson KM, Fortier MS, Vallerand RJ, Briere NM, Blais MR. Toward a new measure of intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation and amotivation in sports: The sport motivation scale (SMS). J Sport & Exercise Psychology. 1995; 17.
  3. Georgieva V. Body mass index, motivation and self-assessment of 11-13-year-old students, Physical Education, Sport, Kin Res J PESKR. 2022; 5: 20-27.
  4. ????? ?, ????????-???????? ?. ????????? ??? ??????????? ??????? ? ??????. ?????? ?????????. ???? ?????. ??? ????. 2021.
  5. Deci EL. Effects of externally mediated rewards on intrinsic motivation. J Per Soc Psy. 1971; 18.
  6. Vallerand RJ, Blais MR, Briere NM, Pelletier LG. Construction et validation de l’Echelle de motivation en edication. Canadian J Behav Sci. 1989; 21.
  7. Valleran RJ. Intrinsic, extrinsic, and amotivational styles as predictions of behavior: A prospective study. J Personality. 1992; 60.
  8. Vallerand RJ, Thill EE. Introduction a concept de motivation. Introduction to the psychology of motivation. 1993.
  9. Deci EL, Rayan RM. Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior. New York: Plenum press. 1985.
  10. Phillips Ch, Edwards B, Andel JD, Kilpatrick R. Daily physical activity and cognitive function variability in older adults. J Aging and Physical Activity. 2016; 24: 2.