Comparison of Efficacy of Group versus Individual Exercise in Improving Depression in Community Dwelling Elderly Population

Aurangabadkar S, Todi B and Deo M

Published on: 2020-06-12

Abstract

Background: Depression is the most common problem among elderly. Most of the elderly rely on antidepressants but antidepressants can cause increase risk of falls. Research has shown physical activity, and resisted exercises are effective against depression. Though physical therapist can choose either individual or group aerobic exercises, there is inadequate research comparing the effects of them in improving depression. Methodology: Community dwelling elderly aged 60 years and above were screened according to study protocol. The subjects were randomly allotted to one of the group. Individual aerobic exercises were given to group A for six weeks, three sessions per week. Group B were given group aerobic exercises for same duration. ACSM guidelines for aerobic training for elderly were followed and training was divided into warm up, conditioning and cool down phase. The Pre and Posttest depression level were measured on Hindi version of Geriatric Depression scale. Results: Statistical Analysis using Wilcoxon paired t test to know the effectiveness of individual and group exercises in improving depression and unpaired t test was used to compare the effectiveness between them. Group A post intervention showed 0.667 difference and Group B showed 2.467 difference on Wilcoxon paired t test. The two tailed P value for comparing the effectiveness of group versus individual exercises was 0.0049. Conclusion: Both group and individual exercise therapy are effective in treating depression but group exercises are more effective than individual exercises.

Keywords

Individual exercises; Group exercises; Depression; Geriatric depression scale

Introduction

Today the average life expectancy has gone up and is expected to increase even more in the future. Consequently, the health, fitness and well-being of the senior population are of increasing concern in today’s society. The degenerative changes of biological and psychological functions of elderly people come with age. Depression is a common condition in elderly that negatively affects numerous parts of their lives. Recent studies have reported that untreated depression is related to increase of illness and disability, suicide and mortality [1]. It places a substantial burden on family caregivers as well as health and social services. Depression is most common psychological mood problem in older person and is a significant problem encountered by physiotherapists working with elderly. Most depressed patient s first seek treatment from their primary care providers .Generally depressed patients treated in primary care setting receive pharmacologic treatment alone. Depression is often neglected in the geriatric, possibly because of lack of awareness in the society, lack of insight and many times mental health issues are overshadowed by physical problems. The characteristics of depression includes problems with mood, cognition, self-esteem, interpersonal interactions, and somatic functions.

Causes

There are several causes for depression in geriatric, some of them are:

  1. Health problems: Illness and disability; chronic or severe pain; cognitive decline; damage to the body image due to surgery or sickness.
  2. Loneliness and isolation: Living alone; a dwindling social circle due to deaths or relocation; decreased mobility due to illness or a loss of driving privileges.
  3. Reduced sense of purpose: Feelings of purposelessness or loss of identity due to retirement or physical limitations on recreational activities.
  4. Fears: Fear of death or dying; anxiety over financial problems or health issues.
  5. Recent bereavements: The death of friends, family members, the loss of a spouse or partner.
  6. Medical conditions: Any chronic medical condition, particularly if it is painful, disabling, or life-threatening, can lead to depression or make depression symptoms worse eg. Parkinson s disease, Stroke, Cancer, Diabetes, Dementia and Alzheimer.

Depressed patients treated in primary care settings receive predominantly pharmacologic therapy, fewer receiving adjunct cognitive or behavioral interventions. Research has also shown that depressed patients are less fit and have diminished physical work capacity on the order of 80-90% of age predicted norms, which in turn may contribute to other physical health problems [2-5], [11-14]. Involvement in structured exercises has shown to promise in alleviating symptoms of clinical depression. Many studies have examined the efficacy of exercises to reduce symptoms of depression and overwhelming majority of studies have described positive benefits associated with exercise involvement. Research has also suggested that benefits of exercise involvement may be long lasting [6]. (20)  Aerobic and non-aerobic mode of exercises have also been compared to determine if certain types of activities are more effective than others. In one clinical trial, Martissen et al (20) assessed 90 depressed patients who were randomly assigned to aerobic and non-aerobic exercises .Aerobic exercises consisted of jogging/ brisk walking and non-aerobic exercises included strength training ,relaxation, flexibility training for 60 minutes ,3 times/week for eight weeks. Both groups experienced reduction in depression but there was no significant differences between groups with respect to magnitude of changes in depression [7]. When it comes to exercise, there is also the factor of whether it is performed alone or in group .The health effects of exercises may be the result of not only physiological mechanism of physical activity but also the social network and social support mechanism of participation in group activity. Several studies have already proved that physical activity and exercises like resisted exercises, tai chi, aerobic exercises are shown to be beneficial in improving depression levels in elderly. These exercises can be either given in groups or individually. The health effects of group exercise which cannot be obtained through individual exercises may potentially be the result of the difference in the type of exercise. It is likely that type of exercise would differ between individuals and groups. In the Japan Gerontological Evaluation study [JAGES], which examined community dwelling elderly who are not eligible for long term care, the questions, ‘Do you exercise with family, friends, acquaintances? , Do you exercise by yourself? Were used to determine the frequency of participation in group exercise and individual exercise. [8]. Thus though systematic reviews have shown physical activity either group /individual exercises have preventive effects on depression and promoting physical activity may reduce risk of developing depression [9]. (24) There in inadequate research studying the effects of them on the levels of depression in elderly. Thus efforts were taken in this study to compare the effects of group versus individual exercises in improving depression in elderly population.

Aim

Comparison of effectiveness of group exercises and individual exercises in reducing depression in elderly population.

Objectives

  1. To study the effectiveness of individual exercises to improve depression in elderly.
  2. To study the effectiveness of group exercises in improving depression in elderly.
  3. To compare the effectiveness of individual exercises vs. group exercises in improving depression in elderly.

Methodology

This experimental study was s conducted among community dwelling elderly residing in urban parts of Mumbai. Total thirty patients, both male and female, who came to an OPD basis to at a primary care setting were recruited for the study. Permission to carry out the study was taken from the ethical committee. A set of population, that followed the inclusion and exclusion criteria was selected.  The inclusion criteria for the study was Community dwelling elderly, both male and female, sixty years and above, ambulatory with or without assistive devices. They were clinically diagnosed to have mild to moderate depression. Study procedure was explained and written informed consent was taken.  After taking written consent, information and purpose of the the study was explained to them. Samples were randomly allocated to one of the treatment regime. Elderly with severe cognitive impairment not able to follow command or communicate, those with unstable cardio respiratory conditions and severe musculoskeletal, neurological disorders were excluded from the study.  The study protocol was designed using the ACSM guidelines for aerobic exercises and the outcome measures used were Geriatric Depression Scale [Hindi version]  . The study population was randomly divided into two groups and their pretest level of depression was noted on Geriatric depression scale. Individual exercise therapy was given to 15 individuals of group A for 6 weeks, 3 sessions/week and their depression levels was measured using outcome levels before and after the treatment. To group B, Group exercise therapy was given to 15 individuals for 6 weeks, 3 sessions/week and their depression levels was measured using outcome levels before and after the treatment. Therapy consisted of general mobility and aerobic exercises. Their results were compared using outcome measures.

The study programme comprised of following exercises  

  1. Warm up gradually for 5 to 10 minutes. Upper limb and lower limb movements in sitting was given. Stretching and repetitive movements at slow speeds, gradually increasing the efforts was given.
  2. Conditioning phase for 15-25 minutes was given. It included breathing exercises, thoracic expansion exercises, fast walking, spot marching, mini squats, and lunges were given.
  3. Cool down for 5 to 10 minutes with slow, total body repetitive motions and stretching activities was given in the form of upper limb and lower limb movements in slow pace ending with shavasana.

The general exercise prescription guidelines for the senior population developed from the ACSM guidelines: [10].

Mode

The mode of exercise for the older population should be activities with low-impact on their joints. The activities include walking, stationary cycling, water exercise, swimming, or machine-based stair climbing. The activity needs to be accessible, convenient, and enjoyable to the participant.

Duration

The duration of an exercise program should start with short periods and gradually progress in length. During the initial stage, it may be difficult for some old adults with physiologic limitations to perform exercise for 20 minutes. It will be possible for them to perform exercise in shorter sessions of five to 10 minutes repeated several times throughout the day. In addition to the duration of the exercise program itself, elderly people need additional warm-up and cool down time, perhaps as much as 10 minutes or more.

Intensity

The intensity of the exercise program must start out low since elderly people are more prone to exercise-related injuries. Because low intensity exercise is associated with a lower risk for injury, it should be encouraged in the elderly population. Exercise intensity should be sufficient to overload the cardiovascular, pulmonary, and musculoskeletal systems without overstraining them. The recommended intensity by the ACSM for older adults is 50 to 70% of heart rate reserve (1995). The intensity level of exercise should be regularly monitored by heart rate, or rating of perceived exertion (Borg, 1982).

Frequency

Generally, the frequency of exercise programs recommended is three to five days per week (ACSM, 1995). Emphasis on more frequent activity (five to seven days per week) may be made with seniors if they exercise very low intensity with short duration. This recommended increase in frequency has physiological relevance for the maintenance of endurance capacity as well as flexibility. In addition, the greater frequency may enhance compliance and lead to a greater probability of the subject assimilating physical activity in the daily routine.

Statistical Analysis

  1. 34 subjects, clinically diagnosed with depression were enrolled for the study, out of which four were not ready to volunteer for six weeks study citing the reason of their illness, so only thirty subjects were selected for study programme. After completion of study programme, the data was collected and analysed.
  2. Wilcoxon matched paired test was used to compare the score of depression on geriatric depression scale at pre and post individual exercise sessions.
  3. Wilcoxon matched paired test was used to compare the score of depression on geriatric depression scale at pre and post group exercise sessions.
  4. Unpaired t test was used to compare the effects of group exercise vs. Individual exercises on the levels of depression on geriatric depression scale.

Results

Figure 1: shows the graphical representation of number of people having Diabetes Miletus .17 people had diabetes out of total 30 subjects.

 

Pre

Post

Difference

Mean

13.73

11.267

2.467

 

SD

3.57

4.758

1.995

Figure 2: shows graphical representation of number of subjects having hypertension.Out of total 30 subjects 19 had hypertension.

Figure 3: shows graphical representation of number of subjects having history of falls 7 subjects gave history of single /multiple history of falls.

Figure 4: shows the pre and post test values of GDS after giving individual exercises to group A. The interpretation is the post intervention group showed significant improvement with mean difference 0.6667 and SD 1.113 after analysing with Wilcoxon matched pair.

Figure 5:Figure 5: shows the pre and post test values of GDS after giving group exercises to group B. The interpretation is post intervention there was improvement in depression on GDS with mean difference 2.467 and SD 1.995 after giving group exercises.

Figure 6: shows the comparison of effectiveness of individual versus group exercises on GDS scores. There was more improvement in the scores of depression in group B with two tailed p value of 0.0049 on unpaired t test, which is significan0074.

 

Mean difference

Unpaired two  tailed p value

Group A

0.667

 

Group B

2.467

0.0049

 

Discussion

This study studies the effect of exercises, both individual and group exercises on the level of depression in community dwelling elderly. The study population, comprised of both male and females, clinically diagnosed case of mild to moderate depression recruited from an OPD of primary care setting for elderly population. All the elderly population were ambulatory, with or without assistive devices. Along with depression, they had co morbities like hypertension, diabetes, and history of falls. Out of sample size of 30, seven people had history of one or multiple falls. This goes in accordance with studies which states that there is increased incidences of falls in depressed elderly patients [11]. In this study it was found that there were reduction in score of depression on GDS after 6 weeks of aerobic exercise in both group A and group B the p value being 0.0425, for group A and 0.0009, for group B. Thus aerobic exercise can be considered effective in reducing depression in elderly population. Study done by Martisen et al has also proved effectiveness of aerobic exercises in reducing depression in elderly [4]. Following could be the postulated hypothesis as explained in the study of Lynett l Craft et al for reduction of depression levels in both the groups after structured exercise programme [12].

Thermo genic hypothesis

The thermo genic hypothesis suggests that a rise in core body temperature following exercise is responsible for the reduction in symptoms of depression. It has been hypothesized that increases in temperature of specific brain regions, such as the brain stem, can lead to an overall feeling of relaxation and reduction in muscular tension.

Endorphin Hypothesis

The endorphin hypothesis predicts that exercise has a positive effect on depression due to an increased release of β-endorphins following exercise. Endorphins are related to a positive mood and an overall enhanced sense of well-being. Several studies have shown increases in plasma endorphins following acute and chronic exercise; yet, it remains unclear if these elevations in plasma endorphins are directly linked to a reduction in depression. 

Monoamine Hypothesis

The monoamine hypothesis appears to be the most promising of the proposed physiologic mechanisms. This hypothesis states that exercise leads to an increase in the availability of brain neurotransmitters (e.g., serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine) that are diminished with depression. These neurotransmitters increase in plasma and urine following exercise, but whether exercise leads to an increase in neurotransmitters in the brain remains unknown.

Distraction Hypothesis

Several psychological mechanisms have also been proposed. As was the case with the physiologic mechanisms, many of these theories have not been tested extensively. The distraction hypothesis suggests that physical activity serves as a distraction from worries and depressing thoughts. In general, the use of distracting activities as a means of coping with depression has been shown to have a more positive influence on the management of depression.

Self-Efficacy Hypothesis

The enhancement of self-efficacy through exercise involvement may be another way in which exercise exerts its antidepressant effects. Self-efficacy refers to the belief that one possesses the necessary skills to complete a task as well as the confidence that the task can actually be completed with the desired outcome obtained. Depressed people often feel inefficacious to bring about positive desired outcomes in their lives and have low efficacy to cope with the symptoms of their depression. This can lead to negative self-evaluation, negative ruminations, and faulty styles of thinking. It has been suggested that exercise may provide an effective mode through which self-efficacy can be enhanced based on its ability to provide the individual with a meaningful mastery experience.  

More research is needed to determine which, if any, of the mechanisms described herein are important moderators of the exercise effect. It is highly likely that a combination of biological, psychological, and sociological factors influence the relationship between exercise and depression. Therefore, while several physiologic mechanisms remain plausible, methodological difficulties have prevented this line of research from advancing. Testing biochemical hypotheses is often difficult in humans due to the invasive procedures necessary to obtain samples (e.g., spinal taps for cerebrospinal fluid samples). Further, biochemical samples obtained from blood or other bodily fluids may not directly reflect the activity of these compounds in the brain. Hopefully, with the advent of new less invasive neuroimaging techniques, future researchers can examine whether exercise leads to the neurochemical changes in the brain predicted by these physiologic hypotheses. Further when the GDS scores reduction in group A and group B were compared, it was seen that the mean reduction in group B (receiving group exercise) is more than in group A (receiving individual exercise).   Thus, it can be concluded that giving exercise therapy in a group is more beneficial than giving it individually. In their meta-analysis, Carron et al (1996) reported that the intention to engage in physical activity is associated with social support from family. (13) Similarly ,some studies  have found strong support for physical activity intervention that include social support in form of members of cohesive classes, members of collectives, interested family and friends- do have an effect on the involvement in and benefits derived from physical activity. In our study group exercises could have been beneficial in reducing depression due to following reasons.

  1. The patients were given confidence in the treatment and is therefore stimulated to further effort , as progress on the part of other members of the group does not pass unnoticed.
  2. Patients were helped to forget their disability temporarily when they interact with others.
  3. They were able to share their feelings and complains with other members of the group.
  4. The patient was given confidence in his ability to hold his own with others when the group performs exercise in unison.
  5. Group therapy generates motivation among the participants along with creating a healthy environment that will help participants to interact with people suffering from same complaints and will promote their social life.
  6. Effort is stimulated by activities which call for a mild form of competition.
  7. Motivates patients to go outdoors

Thus, the advantages of group exercises outweigh the benefits of individual exercises in treating depression.

Clinical Implication

  1. Depression in geriatrics should not be ignored and non-pharmacological interventions like aerobic exercise should be encouraged.
  2. Awareness in the society regarding depression in geriatric should be increased.
  3. The study will help to the physiotherapist to select between group exercises and individual exercises to encounter depression while treating geriatric population.

Limitations of the Study

  1. Small sample size
  2. Objective measures of depression by psychiatrists
  3. Frequency of antidepressant medication s before and after exercises should be considered.

Scope for Future for Studies

Comparing effectiveness of group exercise therapy given in an open environment and close environment and exercising individually at home with contact and at home without contact of physiotherapist to improve depression.

Conclusion

Both group and individual exercises are effective in treating depression but group exercises are more effective than individual exercise in reducing depression in elderly.

List of Abbreviations

GDS –Geriatric Depression Scale

RPE –Rate of perceived exertion

Author Contribution

Concept, design data collection, statistical analysis, manuscript writing and editing –Dr Sheetal Aurangabadkar (PT) 

Data collection, statistical analysis, manuscript writing   -Dr Bhakti Todi (PT)

Permission to carry the study and supervision –Dr Medha Deo (PT)

Funding

None

Acknowledgement

We are thankful to all our community dwelling elderly for participating and adhering to our study programme and the authorities of elderly primary care setting for allowing us to conduct the study and make it possible.

References

  1. Lee Y, Choi K, Lee YK. Association of co morbidity with depressive symptoms in community dwelling older persons. Gerontology 2001; 47: 254-262.
  2. Morgan WP. Selected physiological and psychomotor correlates of depression in psychiatric patients. Res Q. 1968; 30: 1037-1043.
  3. Morgan WP. A pilot investigation of physical working capacity in depressed and non depressed males. Res Q. 1969; 40: 859-861.
  4. Martisen EW, Medhus A, Sandvik L. Effects of aerobic exercise on depression: a controlled study. Br .Med J Clin Res E D. 1985; 291: 109.
  5. Martisen EW Strand J, Paulson G, Kaggestad J. Physical fitness level in patients with anxiety and depressive disorders. Int J Sports Med. 1989; 10: 58-61.
  6. Di Lorenzo TM, Bargman EP, StuckyRopp R, Brassingtona GS, Peter A.Frenscha PA, et al. Long term effects of aerobic exercise on psychological outcomes. Prev Med. 1999; 28: 75-85.
  7. Martinsen EW, Hoffart A, Solberg O. Comparing aerobic and non aerobic forms of exercise in treatment of clinical depression :a randomised trial. Compr psychiatry. 1989; 30: 324-331
  8. Sartoru K, Tomoko T, Shigeru I. Determinants of participation in group exercises and its association with health outcomes. J Phys Fitness Sports Med. 2015; 4: 315-320.
  9. Mammen G, Faulkner G. Physical activity and prevention of depression. A Systematic Review of prospective studies. Am J.Prev Med. 2013; 45: 649-657.
  10. Nelson ME, Rejeski WJ, Blair SN, Duncan PW, Judge JO. Physical activity and public health in older adults: recommendation from american college of sports medicine and american heart association. Journal of the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2007; 116: 1094-1105.
  11. Byres AM, Sheeran T, Bruce ML. Depression and Risk for adverse falls in older home care patients. Res Gerontol Nurs. 2008; 1: 245-251.
  12. Craft LL, Perna FM. The benefits of exercise for the clinically depressed. Prim Care Companion J Clin Psyciatry. 2004; 6: 104-111.
  13. Carron AV, Hausenblas HA , Mack D. Social influenceand exercise: a meta analysis. J Sport Exerc Psychol 18: 1-16.