Physical Fitness and Potential Intellingence in Primary School: Acorrelational Study

Cristiana D' Anna, Forte P, Vivona A, Pugliese E and Gomez Paloma F

Published on: 2023-04-13

Abstract

According to various studies, physical and cognitive development have been shown to be related. During growth, children’s body and brain go through many changes, which are fundamental for their psycho/social evolution. Research has been carried out concerning the roles that distinct play that includes the motor skill training, demonstrating that motor activity is strongly connected to the mental and scholastic results. The purpose of this survey is to investigatethe potential connection between physical fitness and the development of finding solutions skills in children. 56 children (7-11 years), were involved in this research. The first part consisted of a group of gymnasts; and the other part of primary school pupils, both selected by convenience sampling. There are various tools available for evaluating young girls' mental and physical growth, including: Italian version of the Gross Motor Development-3 test, which measures articular mobility and conditional/coordinative abilities in motor tests. To evaluate one's capacity for problem-solving, use the Test of Potential Intelligence and bioelectrical impedance analysis.It is noteworthy to note some links between the potential intelligence test and the other motor abilities. It appears that there are strong relationships between all of the other characteristics and potential intelligence.The values more correlated with TIP are the variables of coordinative dimension. The correlation between TIP and the gross motor development index is 0.74, but it is insufficient to demonstrate a cause-and-effect relationship.The development of coordination skills in particular, as well as other motor activities, may aid in children's cognitive growth.

Keywords

Body Composition; Cognitive Development; Gymnastic; Motor Development; Physical Fitness; School

Introduction

Theresearchesabout neuroscience have intensifiedin the most recent years, especially those concerning the correlation between brain, cognitive and motor activities, which is more evident in younger subjects. The development of cognitive processes and representationsinfluence the baby’s movements in his first moments of life. Indeed, the kinaesthetic-bodily intelligence is manifested in a child through exploratory actions and the ability to reason in a certain situation, and it represents the first expression of learning to learn (life skill), a transversal competence expected by the European community in the training of citizens. This intelligence, among other things, is now supported by neuroscience, embodied cognition theories and the consequent impact on embodied education [1-3], with an increasing focus on motor involvement in the development of the mind.Initial research on metacognition, that is, children’s awareness of what they know and how they can use it[4] and current research on Executive Functions highlight the importance of physical activity promotion [5]. Sports and motor activities provide by the involvement of the totality of the individual by activating connections between consciousness and emotion, between the body and the surrounding environment. As a result, through this balance, the subject is able to govern his or her movements.As a consequence, cognition controls the emotion, so that the subject is able to choose which action perform, making him move from input information to action [6].The relationship "myself-world" is constructedat the base of main concept of the "active body and corporeality plays an important part in this relationship.The movement represents the connection that is the fulcrum of different type of intelligence: mental-logical, verbal-organization and thinking. In fact, several studies show that physical activity increases cognitive abilities through the growth of new neurons into the hippocampus. There are many benefits, including the storage of information, neurobiological adaptation to changes, promotion of neo-formation of nerve cells, their growth and better connection. That brings to a more effectively expression of the social behavior. Central nervous system is the proponent of all the coordination skills including the control, learning, adaptation and transformation of the mobility; in particular the cerebellum and the frontal lobes are the principal actor. In recent years there has been considerable focus on the development of the child’s cognitive skills through games and playful experiences, in particular on the possibility of "transfer" to other areas of learning 10 11. The potential of transfer in games based on motor activity is intrinsic to their nature. Children’s games are based on understanding, not on memorizing rules and the more the child organizes and restructures learning experiences, the greater the transfer will be through movement.The movement promotes abstract acquisition of strategies that the child can use in different situations and contexts. Learning through games also represents a cognitive challenge for children, that should always be incremental 12 and at the same time appropriate to the child’s level of skill development 13.Cognitive challenges and problem-solving situations act on the core of Executive Functions, which develop at different times in life and begin during preschool age. Since motion and thinking are processed in the same brain area, motion games enhance and promote children’s ability to control their thoughts and actions. Physical activity is widely considered a method to improve both physical health and cognitive functions 14. Routine exercise involves physiological adaptations to both the body and the brain, but its effects on mental processing and executive functioning are yet to be explored15. It has been proved by a recent study that the short, acute and chronic exercise leads to improvement on the cognitive function, especially in children. An improvement in verbal, mathematics tests, and in the IQ, has been noticed. In adults, on the other hand, there are minor cognitive improvements due to acute physical activities.  Scientific research has highlighted and provided a new perspective on the fascinating correlation between physical fitness and cognition, as well as on the effects that physical activity has on cognitive development. Studies that investigated the nature of these findings have favored a type of exercise protocol based on aerobic exercise. Indeed, it is extremely important to understand the appropriate amount and level of exercise that an individual needs to do in order to have the maximum cognitive benefit; and, given the data on early inactivity in young individuals, it is equally clear that the belief that the nature of children is characterized by physically active behaviors is not so well founded18. Diamond 19stressed an important quality aspect related to movement, stating that, in order to have benefits for brain development and executive functions, physical activity must be challenging, emotionally and socially charged, and emphasize the role played by the metabolic demand for a vigorous type of activity.  These characteristics are the most consistent with the way in which children move during their free time:  alternating brief moments of significant and vigorous physical activity, with moments of rest. The movement game involves all these features. Contemporary research on exercise and cognition hypothesizes that an enrichment of physical activity interventions with cognitive and coordination challenges, incorporated in playful activities, could have positive results on Executive Functions, as well as improvements in motor coordination results [20]. By introducing the ingredient "playful form”, motion games interventions become suitable for the child. Since body movement is closely linked to attention, emotional responses and regulation, and reaction/response feedback, these playful challenges are considered appropriate emotional activities that help the development of the executive processes. [22] Tomporowski marks that the physical activities, in addition to all positive effects already mentioned, can reduce deviant behaviors in children and adolescents. All these effects are reported as case of study in the papers of Tomporowski et al.[23]; especially the relation between fitness levels and cognitive performance in literature and mathematics.This complex analysis, to study the connection between physical activities and mental and social growth, have difficulty reproducing the real learning context and environment. To achieve this, static methods were used and it was not possible to create sensitive tables of learning abilities. Sports lead to increase the number of neurons through a process of stimulating curiosity, transmitting information between various part of the body and brain, and motor performances and cognitive functions. This work analyzes two groups of children who practice sports, which are more predisposed to respond to environmental stimuli in a brief period, in particular girls aged from 6 to 11 years old. A group of them practices gymnastics, and the second are schoolchildren. The core of this paper is to study the relation between critical thinking and problem-solving skills and the different physical-motor components; and the tests was a various number and different type to evaluate the level of coordinative, conditional motor capacities and coordinative skills, articular mobility and body composition together with the evaluation of problem-solving skills.

Materials and Methods

Participants

The sample consists of 56 females aged 7 to 11 years. The athletes have been practicing artistic gymnastics for about 2 years and are registered with the Italian gymnastics’ federation. The gymnasts train with a federal trainer for 5 hours a week, in addition to practice 2 hours of physical education per week in the curriculum at school, with a primary school teacher not specialized in sports science. While pupils perform only 2 hours of physical education per week at school.

Methodological Procedures

The dissemination calendar containing the guidelines to be followed by participants and technical and teaching staff was provided. They also signed the consent form relating to the use of personal data in accordance with the privacy policy.The parents were informed by written communication. The trials occurred between April and May 2013.The motor tests, in the group of pupils, were carried out during the morning hours of physical education, the test of dynamic measurement of problem-solving skills (TIP) was carried out before the afternoon school lessons,Bioelectric impedance analysis (BIA) was administered by a doctor at 10:00 in fasting conditions. As for the gymnasts, all tests were conducted in the sports association, using the same procedures.

Tools

The chosen protocol for assessing the physical fitness of girls takes into account the following criteria: standardized international tests, test fitted for the school environment, cheap tools. The table I shows the different type of selected tests and their standardizations in a synthetic form. Following some information about the specific assessment of body composition and problem-solving skills.

Table 1: List of assessment test used.

Test

Standardization

Conditional Capacity

 

1_Run test (Mt. 20)

Electronic timer

2_Sargent

Sargent

3_Standing long Jump

OCM CONI-CAS

4_Throw of the ball (150 gr.)

F.I.D.A.L. 

5_Shuttle run test 5x5

O.C.M. CONI Livorno

Coordinative Capacity And Gross Motor Skills

 

6_Dexterity Circuit

Research CONI-CAS

7_Grosso motor development TGMD3-italian version

Ulrich D.A., D’Anna C. et al 25

Articular Mobility

 

8_Back flexibility test

 

9_Shoulder mobility test

Research CONI-CAS

10_Hip mobility test

Research CONI-CAS

Body Composition

Research CONI-CAS

11_Bioelectrical BIA

Via Biomedical

The motor tests have been chosen from the Manual of standardization of CONI [27]. The Potential Intelligence Test (TPL) is a tool for measuring cognitive modifiability and elasticity to adapt new situations in children and young people aged 3 to 19. It is a «dynamic» test because, in addition to measure the results obtained in the various tests, it also provides a teaching procedure within the test situation, which allows you to assess the level of potential development (in addition to the level of development already achieved) and to avert the risk of erroneously achieving lower than average results not because of a real intellectual problem but a possible socio-cultural disadvantage. It consists of several items and is suitable for various types of subjects: students with normal performance (to verify the potential for intellectual development), pupils with some disadvantage due to their social or cultural origin (which may lead to poor performance in traditional tests), pupils with learning difficulties and pupils with high skill levels with low performance. The tests used in this study are those for primary school. Conventional tests are not adequate to provide accurate information on individual learning ability, change processes, and the plasticity and variability of cognitive processes. Instead, with the dynamic indices of this test, the suggestions a person uses to

find a two-step solution to the problem are measured: in the

learning phase when the individual tries to solve a new problem; in the transfer phase, when the individual makes a generalization of the rule learned to a new and more complex problem solving.The test contains 14 items (7 of which are related to the learning phase and the other 7 to the transfer phase).The BIA is a method of screening body fat in few seconds. On the subject in the supine position electrodes are attached to various parts of the body, a small electrical signal passes through the body to provide information in terms of water absorption and nutrition statement.

Data Analysis

All the results of the assessment of physical fitness have been evaluated by ANOVA. The specific analyses are:

  • a descriptive analysis with summary table (average, standard deviation, standard errors, minimum and maximum value;
  • Person's correlation coefficient between the different variables and problem-solving skills.

Results

The descriptive statistics shown in Table 2 highlight for the two subgroups of girls the mean values, standard deviation and standard error, standard error, and minimum and maximum value recorded in the different tested variables.

Table 2: Descriptivestatistics.

 

 

N

Mean

SD

Minimum

Maximum

Height

Gymnasts

28

136,30

8,94

119

154

pupils

28

133,63

8,93

119

155

Tot

56

134,96

8,96

119

155

Weight

gymnasts

28

33,26

5,19

25

46

pupils

28

37,26

8,93

30

73

Tot

56

35,26

7,51

25

73

FM (%)

gymnasts

28

19,971

6,30

10,6

34,4

pupils

28

29,339

3,96

20,2

37,1

Tot

56

24,655

7,03

10,6

37,1

FFM (%)

gymnasts

28

80,029

6,30

65,6

89,4

pupils

28

70,650

3,95

62,9

79,8

Tot

56

75,339

7,04

62,9

89,4

BMI

gymnasts

28

17,39

1,39

15

21

pupils

28

20,25

2,75

16

30

Tot

56

18,82

2,60

15

30

ShoulderMob_Test

gymnasts

28

44,61

9,89

20

63

pupils

28

60,88

19,32

16

102

Tot

56

52,74

17,28

16

102

Back Flexibility Test

gymnasts

28

14,63

5,42

-1

25

pupils

28

,96

8,43

-16

22

Tot

56

7,79

9,84

-16

25

Hip Mobility Test

gymnasts

28

168,39

12,77

145

180

pupils

28

130,18

22,50

90

180

Tot

56

149,29

26,46

90

180

TGMD subtest Loc_skillspt_std

gymnasts

28

11,57

1,68

9

15

pupils

28

6,39

3,56

1

14

Tot

56

8,98

3,80

1

15

TGMD subtest

gymnasts

28

10,57

2,25

5

15

Ball skills_pt_std

pupils

28

5,79

2,71

1

12

 

Tot

56

8,18

3,45

1

15

GMI

gymnasts

28

106,43

9,58

82

127

pupils

28

76,54

15,27

49

118

Tot

56

91,48

19,67

49

127

6_Dexterity Circuit

gymnasts

28

22,139

4,25

16,8

31,7

pupils

28

36,459

8,73

23,9

62,0

Tot

56

29,299

9,92

16,8

62,0

2_Sargent test

gymnasts

28

29,00

5,20

19

38

pupils

28

21,25

3,94

13

28

Tot

56

25,13

6,01

13

38

3_Standing long Jump

gymnasts

28

143,75

20,68

110

170

pupils

28

102,93

18,25

100

142

Tot

56

121,58

32,48

100

170

4_Throw of the ball (150 gr.)

gymnasts

28

11,823

3,16

7,3

18,5

pupils

28

7,683

2,43

4,3

13,1

Tot

56

9,753

3,49

4,3

18,5

1_Run test (Mt. 20)

gymnasts

28

41,236

,46

3,28

5,22

pupils

28

50,639

,76

3,96

7,50

Tot

56

45,938

,78

3,28

7,50

5_Shuttle run test 5x5

gymnasts

28

49,993

5,63

43,1

60,0

pupils

28

55,693

5,75

45,2

66,0

Tot

56

52,843

6,33

43,1

66,0

TIP_Q

gymnasts

28

116,48

9,41

100

150

pupils

28

83,50

12,70

60

112

Tot

56

99,99

19,99

60

150

Pearson's coefficient (r) was used for correlation analysis. Table 3 shows in detail the different correlations between the various quantitative variables (motor test battery) and the potential intelligence variable (cognitive test).

Table 3: Pearson's correlation coefficient .

Discussion and Conclusions

The analyzed data clearly confirm that there is a significant difference in the tested sample when comparing the two groups, is confirmed what was hypothesized at the ex-ante stage. For all motor test variables, the mean value recorded in the group of gymnasts is higher than that obtained in the group of pupils; this seems quite obvious also because the gymnasts train continuously on these motor skills.  Although to a lesser extent also in the test of potential intelligence, the group of gymnasts presents a higher average value than the group of pupils. In general, there is an average value of the entire sample that is nevertheless higher than the average: this is probably positively conditioned by the socio-cultural variable of the subjects, which as highlighted in the characteristics of the sample It should be emphasized that the tested sample, as previously described, belonging to an upper-middle sociocultural level, obtained a generically high TIP value, representing an average high IQ. It is important to point out that the standard deviation in all administered tests for different motor skills shows a higher value in the pupil sample than in the gymnast sample.The present correlation study wanted to focus on the correlation index between the motor variables and the cognitive variable analyzed with the TIP, which are shown in the last row of Table 3. The different correlation coefficients obtained in the analysis between the conditional skills (tests 1-5) tested and the test of potential intelligence (TIP) although positive, is between 0.39 and 0.53. More significant, however, appear to be the correlation analyses between the variables of body composition and TIP, ranging from 0.46 to 0.60 and between the test mobility (8-10) and TIP, ranging from 0.45 to 0.63. The values more correlated with TIP are the variables of coordinative dimension (test 6-7). The coefficient value of the subtest of gross motor development are both 0.67, the gross motor development quotient correlated with tip is 0.74 and the correlation with dexterity circuit is -0.61 (its value is expressed in seconds and the lower value shows the best performance). This trend confirms the positive correlation between physical fitness and cognitive dimension,showing a higher correlation between the coordinative and cognitive dimensions. It is important to point out that the homogeneity of the group of gymnasts, in which there are very similar observations, is a critical issue in this study, which draws attention to the need to investigate these variables in a more representative (numerically larger and heterogeneous) sample.The analysis although conducted on a limited sample shows a close relationship between general fitness and problem-solving skills, but it is deemed necessary to study this trend on a larger sample, also in order to identify and distinguish the contribution and effects of each variable also comparing different sports disciplines. For instance, performances of athletes practicing a sport characterized by dynamic environment could be compared to athletes practicing, instead, sports in stable environment. This further investigation stems from observations noted during the administration of the tests, which revealed a different approach to the conduct of the TIP between the two groups: in particular, in the gymnasts, greater confidence and healthy competition was noted, which also emerged from the lower number of requests for suggestions.To the comparison between groups of different sports disciplines it could be added the gender analysis. In conclusion, research studies have shown that there is a significant correlation between physical fitness and problem-solving skills, thus highlights the fundamental role that physical activity and sport plays in children's optimal biopsychosocial development.

Acknowledgments

The Pegaso University will help fund the publication of the article that is part of the scientific products of internally funded research

The authors ensure that people acknowledged should agree to be so named.

Funding Information

This contribute refers to the following source of funding of Pegaso University - PI Cristiana Danna, title: Motor development and learning.

n.FR 2022 0016

They are involved the following authors associated with specific funding:

Cristiana D'Anna

Angelina Vivona

References

  1. Francesconi D, Tarozzi M. Educazione incarnata. Una convergenza di pedagogy e incarnazione. Studia Phaenomenologica, XII. 2012; 263-288.
  2. Ceciliani A. Dall’EmbodiedCognition all’EmbodiedEducation nelle scienze dell’attività motoria e sportiva. Encyclopaideia, 2018; 22: 11-24.
  3. D’Anna C, Minghelli V, Forte P, Gomez Paloma F. Un approccio Embodied nella scuola dell’infanzia. Lo sviluppo del bambino tra pensiero creativo in azione e movimento e abilità grosso-motorie. In Gomez Paloma F. (Ed.) Embodiment & School. 2020; 1: 420-440.
  4. Bransford J, Brown AL, Cocking R R. How people learn: brain, mind, experience and school. Washington, DC: National Academy Press. 1999.
  5. Diamond A, Kathleen L.Interventions shown to Aid Executive Function Development in Children 4–12 Years Old. Science, 2020; 333:2020. 959-964.
  6. Le Doux Il cervello emotivo, Milano: Baldini Castoldi Dalai. 2003.
  7. Gomez Paloma F. Corporeità, didattica e apprendimento, Salerno: Edisud. 2004.
  8. D’Alessio C, Minichillo I. Le neuroscienze e l’educazione, Lecce: Pensa editore.
  9. Hogan M, Kiefer M, Kubesch S, Collins P, Kilmartin L, Brosnan M. The interactive effects of physical fitness and acute aerobic exercise on electrophysiological coherence and cognitive performance in adolescents. Experimental brain research. 2013; 85-96.
  10. Diamond A, Kathleen L. Interventions shown to Aid Executive Function Development in Children 4–12 Years Old. Science, 2013; 333: 959-964.  
  11. Homer BD, Raffaele C, Henderson H. Games as playful learning: Implications of developmental theory for game-based learning. Handbook of game-based learning. 2020; 25-52.
  12. Diamond A. Executive Functions. Annual Review of Psychology, 2013; 64:135-168.
  13. Pesce C. Shifting the focus from quantitative to qualitative exercise characteristics in exercise and cognition research. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2012; 34:766-786.
  14. Donnelly JE, Hillman CH, Castelli D, Etnier JL, Lee S, Tomporowski P. Physical activity, fitness, cognitive function, and academic achievement in children: A systematic review. Medi-cine and science in sports and exercise, 2016; 48: 1223-1224.
  15. Tomporowsky P, McCullik B, Pesce C. Enhancing Children’s Cognition with Physical activity games. Human Kinetics Publishers. 2015.
  16. Sibley BA, Etnier JL. The relationship between physical activity and cognition in children: a meta-analysis. Pediatric exercise science, 2003; 15; 243-256.
  17. Schmit C, Brisswalter J. Executive functioning during prolonged exercise: a fatigue-based neurocognitive perspective. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2020; 13: 21-39.
  18. Faigenbaum AD, Myer GD. Exercise deficit disorder in youth: play now or pay later”. Current sports medicine reports, 2012; 11:196-200.
  19. Diamond A. Executive Functions. Annual Review of Psychology, 2013; 64:135-168.
  20. Pesce C, Masci I, Marchetti RI, Vazou S, Sääkslahti A, Tomporowski P D. Deliberate Play and Preparation Jointly Benefit Motor and Cognitive Development: Mediated and Modera-ted Effects. Frontiers in Psycology. 2013; 7:349.
  21. Pesce C, Ben-Soussan TD. “Cogito ergo sum” or “ambulo ergo sum”? New perspectives in developmental exercise and cognition research. In T. McMorris (ed.), Exercise-Cognition Interaction: Neuroscience Perspectives.2016; 251-282.
  22. Diamond A, Kathleen L. Interventions shown to Aid Executive Function Development in Children 4–12 Years Old. Science. 2011; 333:959-964.
  23. Tomporowski PD, Davis CL, Miller PH, Naglieri JA. Exercise and children’s intelligence, cognition, and academic achievement. Educational psychology review. 2008; 20:111-131.
  24. Castelli DM, Hillman CH, Buck SM, Erwin HE. Physical Fitness and Academic Achievement in Third-and Fifth-Grade Students. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 2007; 29: 239-252.
  25. Ulrich DA, D' Anna C et al. Test per la valutazione dello sviluppo grosso-motorio. Trento: Erickson. 2023.
  26. Fabio RA. TIP Test d’intelligenza potenziale. Trento: Erickson. 2007.
  27. Buonaccorsi A. Manuale di standardizzazione. Osservatorio Nazionale delle Capacità Motorie, C.O.N.I. Comitato Nazionale Olimpico Italiano, Rome, 2003.