Similar Egogram Pattern in Cases of both Medical Profession and Music Therapists
Bando M, Fukuda Y and Bando H
Published on: 2024-09-25
Abstract
Concerning Transactional Analysis (TA), Tokyo University Egogram (TEG) has been useful inventory. Three subjects are 43, 63, 67-years old and have dual profession, which are both medical staffs of physician/reseacher and musician of player/music therapist. For TEG, they showed similar personality traits of Trapezoidal I type, where egos of critical parent (CP) and adapted child (AC) are low. It is observed only 2.7% statistically in Japan, and presents mild and kind personality trait. Its characteristics includes psychologically self-affirming, healthy, cheerful, performing their work competently, and enjoying playing. Other common factors include activities of Integrative Medicine (IM) and Psychosomatic Medicine (PSM).
Keywords
Transactional analysis (TA); Tokyo University Egogram (TEG); Trapezoidal I type; Integrative medicine (IM); Psychosomatic medicine (PSM)Case Report
From psychological point of view, people in the developed countries have always various stressors during working place, home and other occasions. In order to obtain stable daily life, Transactional Analysis (TA) has been one of the psychotherapy and counseling measures for long, which can deal with human relationships for family, profession and other time place and occasion [1]. TA has included integrated coherent and systematic approach, associated with some contemporary theory, research and practice [2]. Thus, theoretical aspect and actual practice have undergone progressive changes over the years for adapting the current situations.
Transactional Analysis (TA) can be beneficial in our daily social, medical and psychological responses. Specifically, it gives suggestions for various stresses that each person has felt [3]. Knowledge of the egogram also improves smooth communication in human relationships [4]. Concerning TA, various reports have been found in the region of COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments (COSMIN). Among COSMIN, there were Life Position Scale (LPS), Adjective Check List (ACL), Tokyo University Egogram (TEG), which are evaluated as excellent validated psychological questionnaire inventory [5].
Tokyo University Egogram (TEG) is a personality questionnaire battery developed by Tokyo University. It has been revised for ver2 [6], and after that revised for ver3 [7]. It has been known as valid test for behavioral patterns and personality traits that can deepen self-understanding. Authors and collaborators have presented several reports concerning TEG, in which the applicants were university students, music therapist, music learners, and their parents [8-10]. Our group has been involved in Integrative Medicine Japan (IMJ) for years. In particular, three authors have been all medical profession as well as music therapists/musician. We have cooperated several activities, and we recently happened to know the similar results of egogram this time. Such phenomenon may be impressive, and then some perspectives are described in this article.
Subjects And Methods
The subjects enrolled for current research were 3 authors. Their backgrounds and related information are summarized in the followings.
- Case 1 is 42-year-old male medical researcher who is working at Tokushima University, research center [11]. Further, he has been musician, composer, and Japanese traditional shamisen (3-string guitar) player who played international festival many times accompanied by international Awa Dance Festival. His composed traditional music has been popular, and he often co-operate the music session as actual music therapist in various opportunities [12].
- Case 2 is 63-year-old female who is working in the clinical office of the integrated medicine (IM). Formerly, she worked in the research office in the university hospital. She has continues music therapy session as music therapist for years [13]. In addition, she has presented international medical papers until now concerning IM and music therapy [14].
- Case 3 is 67-year-old male who is a physician, and major in diabetes, music therapy, and sports medicine for long. He has been a pianist who won the prize in international piano contest, and continued music therapy session with his music therapy group and music therapy lecture [15]. He was the director of annual congress of Japanese psychosomatic medicine, Chugoku-Shikoku district in October 2023 [16].?During the congress, 3 lecturers are held by 3 authors in this report.
As the method in the current research, well-known psychological questionnaire battery is Tokyo University Egogram (TEG) ver2 [17]. We applied this to three subjects. It takes about 5 minutes to answer 60 question. It has 5 egos, which are critical parent (CP), nurturing parent (NP), adult (A), free child (FC) and adapted child (AC). From the characteristic pattern of 5 egos, 29 kinds of personality traits can be decided in Japan [6]. TEG ver2 is adequate for middle-older ages, and ver3 is adequate for younger generation. This inventory was applided to three subjects in August 2024. The analysis was performed, and then, the similarity of the results was found.
Results
When analyzing TEG data, very similar patterns were surprisingly found. Their TEG patterns are shown in Figure 1a,b,c. For psychological results of TEG, 29 kinds of personality traits have been observed [6]. Among them, obtained type of 3 subjects are judged as the Trapezoidal I type. It has high points of NP, A and FC, with low CP and AC. For this type, the person is likely to show mild and kind personality trait. From statistics of TEG, the prevalence ratio of Trapezoidal I type was only 2.7% from thousands of Japanese people [17].
Figure 1: The results of egogram pattern for 3 subjects
a: Case 1, b: Case 2, c: Case 3.
Current 3 subjects have usual medical profession and music-related activities. Regarding their general daily life style, related information are presented in (Figure 2a,b,c).
Figure 2: Social activity of three subjects.
a: medical researcher, composer and playing the shamisen (3-string Japanese traditional guitar) b: working medical office and taking care of the children as music therapist c: physician, pianist, music therapist and the lecturer of medicine, music and art.
Discussion
Ego states represent the energies of each mind that underlie thoughts, feelings and actions psychologically. The egogram has five factors of ego states [18]. General characteristics of them are summarized as follows: i) CP: moral, ethical, dominant, overbearing, idealistic, ii) NP: nurturing, protective, caring, warm, intrusive, iii) A: objective, realistic, rational, planned, callous, iv) FC: active, curious, aggressive, free-spirited, self-centered, v) AC: cooperative, obedient, dependent, passive [7]. The relative balance of these determines each person's temperament.
This study summarized three subjects. The egogram results were similar, and all three participants shared many commonalities, such as performing music, music therapy activities, and research while also working in clinical medicine and research on a daily basis. They also shared the fact that they gave lectures at the Integrative Medicine Society and the Psychosomatic Medicine Society (2023) [19]. Considering their work, they do not simply present music, but rather change their music, conversation, explanations, actions, gestures, and movements depending on the client’s response.
The egogram result was determined to be trapezoid I type in TEG. The three central factors of NP, A, and FC scores were high, and the two ends CP and AC were low. This type tends to show calm and kind personality traits [6]. According to TEG statistics, the prevalence of trapezoid I type among several thousand Japanese people was 2.7%. People with this type are psychologically self-affirming, healthy, cheerful, performing their work competently, and enjoy playing [20]. However, if the two ends CP and AC show extremely lower points, caution is required that the person is less adaptable to daily behaviors and activities of the organizations and societies.
Concerning transcultural response and understanding, individual personality trait and character would become crucial factors [21]. From this perspectives, big five personality traits can be involved. They are known as follows: i) Extraversion (E): warmth, talkative, active, ii) Agreeableness (A): trust, appreciative, not critical, iii) Conscientiousness (C): responsive, efficient, competence, dependable, iv) Neuroticism (N): anxiety, anxious, thin-skinned, v) Openness (O): artistic, fantasy, wide range of interests. The concept of egogram can be beneficial for some treatment as well as diagnosing therapeutic effect by psychosomatic practice. As for TEG, five factors of ego were analyzed and compared with big five by the application of Japanese Adjective Check List (ACL) [22]. The results showed that ACL seemed to be mutually responsive, but TEG did not cover the personality trait as extraversion (E). Consequently, TEG possibly includes 4 factors, not 5 factors, suggesting the perspectives not big five but big four.
Each personality seems to be related strongly with daily lifestyle in each person [23]. Current 3 cases have kind characters (NP), satisfactory medical knowledge (A), playful creativity (FC), less compliance trends (low A) and following own will (low AC). These managing styles may be developed from duplicate roles of medicine and music. Furthermore, these subjects seem to have satisfactory inter-personal communication skill (IPCS) [24]. Consequently, they can manage well and cooperate various matters so far, even if the factors of CP and AC were lower level.
Certain limitation may be present as to this reports. There are only 3 subjects who are involved in medicine and music. They happen to show almost similar egogram type. Egogram pattern will be easily changed due to the profession and daily situation. Then, we will follow up the progress with careful attention.
In summary, impressive 3 cases were presented here. TEG evaluation would be simple and reliable psychological battery, and we will take most advantages of TEG associated with providing subjective well-being (SWB) and happiness of all people and society.
Conflict Of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Funding: There was no funding received for this paper.
References
- McLean B. Transactional analysis and relationship Psychotherapy: A need for renewed interest and contemporary thinking. Transact Analys J. 2023; 53: 113-129.
- Barnes G. Not without the couch: Eric Berne in basic differences between transactional analysis and psychoanalysis. Trans Anal J. 2007; 37: 41-50.
- O'Connor DB, Thayer JF, Vedhara K. Stress and Health: A review of Psychobiological Processes. Annu Rev Psychol. 2021; 72: 663-688.
- Li Q, Yan J, Liao J, Zhang X, Liu L, Fu X, et al. Distinct Effects of social stress on working memory in obsessive-compulsive disorder. Neurosci Bull. 2021; 37: 81-93.
- Vos J, Rijn BV. A systematic review of psychometric transactional analysis instruments. Transactional Analys J. 2021; 51: 127-159.
- Kuboki T, Nomura S, Wada M, Akabayashi A, Nagataki M, et al. Multidimensional assessment of mental state in occupational health care--combined application of three questionnaires: Tokyo University Egogram (TEG), Time Structuring Scale (TSS), and Profile of Mood States (POMS). Environ Res. 1993; 61: 285-298.
- Tokyo Uinversity Egogram (TEG) group. Tokyo University Egogram-New Ver. 3. Kaneko Publishing. 2019.
- Yokoyama T and Bando H. Investigation of useful revised psychological battery, Tokyo University Egogram (TEG). Res J Sport Health Psychol. 2023; 5: 132.
- Bando H, Yoshioka A, Nishikiori Y, Hirai Y, Kusaka Y, et al. Effective music therapy session for vocalization and movement of extremities. Curr Res Complement Altern Med. 2019; CRCAM-136.
- Yoshioka A, Bando H, Yoshioka T. Effect of musical experience on optimization of egogram. Jap J Music Ther 2004; 4: 191-197.
- Bando M, Masumoto S, Kuroda M, Tsutsumi R, Sakaue H. Effect of olive oil consumption on aging in a senescence-accelerated mice-prone 8 (SAMP8) model. J Med Invest. 2019; 66: 241-247.
- Bando M. Zomeki and Dawn of the world. Awa Dance Festival Association, Tokushima.
- Roland Music School Tezukayama.
- Fukuda Y, Nose H, Morishima H, Bando H. Clinical efficacy of music therapy for children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) By Bioresonance Measurement. Arch Traditional Complementary Med. 2024; 3: 121.
- Bando H. Welcome to the world for medicine, music, sports and reports.
- Bando H, Yoshioka A, Nishikiori Y. Pursuit of human happiness by Hinohara-Ism of New Elderly Association (NEA) and Japanese Concept of Harmony “Wa”. Global J Arts Social Sci. 2024; 6: 204.
- Psychosomatic medicine department of Tokyo University. Egogram pattern new edition. Personality analysis. 1995. Kaneko publishing, Tokyo.
- Berne E. Transactional Analysis in Psychotherapy: A systematic individual and Social Psychiatry. Martino Fine Books. . 2015.
- Kitanishi T, Fukuda Y, Sharma HI and Bando H. Current status and potential of Ayurveda in Japan. Arch Traditional Complementary Med. 2024; 3: 119.
- Bando H, Yokoyama T. New Edition of Tokyo University Egogram (TEG) Along With Social Changes as Transactional Analysis (TA). SunText Rev Neurosci Psychol 2022; 3: 153.
- Hirabayashi N. A study on personality trait extraction considering user's ego state, and service development adapted to personality traits using ACL. Transcultural Management Review. 2020; 17: 41-62.
- Kashiwagi S. The trait theoretic evaluation of the TEG from the viewpoint of the Five-Factor Model. Jap J Psychol. 1999; 69: 468-477.
- Suka S, Takeuchi T, Hashimoto K, Nakamura Y, Miyakoda J, Koyama A, et al. The Investigation of Personality of Each Gender in Tokyo University Egogram New Ver. II in Smokers with Depression and of Smoker Patients with Asthma. Jpn J Psychosom Med 62:127-131, 2022.
- Kimura K, Kato C, Otsuka Y, Aoki K. Examination of the relationship between stress coping and personality for University Students. Open J Soc Sci. 2020; 8: 340-352.